第3章

Mr.AldrichoncenoticedthatwheneveranauthordiedinBoston,theNew—

Yorkersthoughttheyhadaliterarycentre;anditisbysomesuchmeansthattheprimacyhaspassedfromBoston,evenifithasnotpassedtoNewYork.ButstillthereisenoughliteratureleftinthebodyatBostontokeepherfirstamongequalsinsomethings,ifnoteasilyfirstinall.

Mr.AldrichhimselflivesinBoston,andheis,withMr.Stedman,theforemostofourpoets.AtCambridgeliveColonelT.W.Higginson,anessayistinacertainsortwithoutrivalamongus;andMr.WilliamJames,themostinterestingandthemostliteraryofpsychologists,whosereputeisEuropeanaswellasAmerican.Mr.CharlesEliotNortonalonesurvivesoftheearlierCambridgegroup——Longfellow,Lowell,RichardHenryDana,LouisAgassiz,FrancisJ.Child,andHenryJames,thefatherofthenovelistandthepsychologist.

ToBostonMr.JamesFordRhodes,thelatestofourablerhistorians,hasgonefromOhio;andthereMr.HenryCabotLodge,theMassachusettsSenator,whoseworkinliteratureismakingitselfmoreandmoreknown,wasbornandbelongs,politically,socially,andintellectually.Mrs.

JuliaWardHowe,apoetofwidefameinaneldergeneration,livesthere;

Mr.T.B.Aldrichlivesthere;andthereaboutsliveMrs.ElizabethStuartPhelpsWardandMrs.HarrietPrescottSpofford,thefirstofafamebeyondthelast,whowasknowntoussolongbeforeher.ThenatBoston,ornearBoston,livethoseartistssupremeinthekindofshortstorywhichwehavecarriedsofar:MissJewett,MissWilkins,MissAliceBrown,Mrs.Chase—Wyman,andMissGertrudeSmith,whocomesfromKansas,andwritesoftheprairiefarm—life,thoughsheleavesMr.E.W.Howe(of\'TheStoryofaCountryTown\'andpresentlyoftheAtchisonDailyGlobe)toconstitute,withthehumorouspoetIronquill,afrontierliterarycentreatTopeka.OfBoston,too,thoughsheisofwesternPennsylvaniaorigin,isMrs.MargaretDeland,oneofourmostsuccessfulnovelists.MissWilkinshasmarriedoutofMassachusettsintoNewJersey,andistheneighborofMr.H.M.AldenatMetuchen.

AllthesearemoreorlessembodiedandrepresentedintheAtlanticMonthly,stillthemostliterary,andinmanythingsstillthefirstofourmagazines.Finally,afterthechiefpublishinghouseinNewYork,thegreatestAmericanpublishinghouseisinBoston,withbyfarthelargestlistofthebestAmericanbooks.RecentlyseveralfirmsofyoungervigorandvalorhaverecruitedthewastedranksoftheBostonpublishers,andareespeciallytobenotedforthenumberofrathernicenewpoetstheygivetothelight.

V.

Dealingwiththequestiongeographically,intherightAmericanway,wedescendtoHartfordobliquelybywayofSpringfield,Massachusetts,where,inalittlecityoffiftythousand,anewspaperofmetropolitaninfluenceandofdistinctlyliterarytoneispublished.AtHartfordwhileCharlesDudleyWarnerlived,therewasanindisputableliterarycentre;MarkTwainlivestherenolonger,andnowwecanscarcelycountHartfordamongourliterarycentres,thoughitisapublishingcentreofmuchactivityinsubscriptionbooks.

AtNewHaven,YaleUniversityhaslatterlyattractedMr.WilliamH.

Bishop,whosenovelsIalwayslikedforthebestreasons,andhaslongheldProfessorJ.T.Lounsbury,whois,sinceProfessorChild\'sdeathatCambridge,ourbestChaucerscholar.Mr.DonaldG.Mitchell,onceendearedtothewholefickleAmericanpublicbyhisReveriesofaBachelorandhisDreamLife,dwellsonthebordersofthepleasanttown,whichisalsothehomeofMr.J.W.DeForest,theearliestrealAmericannovelist,andforcertaingiftsinseeingandtellingourlifealsooneofthegreatest.

AstoNewYork(wheretheimaginationmayarrivedailyfromNewHaven,eitherbyaSoundboatorbyeightortenoftheswiftestexpresstrainsintheworld),IconfessIammoreandmorepuzzled.Hereabidethepoets,Mr.R.H.Stoddard,Mr.E.C.Stedman,Mr.R.W.Gilder,andmanywhomanenviousetceteramusthidefromview;thefictionists,Mr.R.H.

Davis,Mrs.KateDouglasWiggin,Mr.BranderMatthews,Mr.FrankHopkinsonSmith,Mr.AbrahamCahan,Mr.FrankNorris,andMr.JamesLaneAllen,whohasleftKentuckytojointhelargeSoutherncontingent,whichincludesMrs.BurtonHarrisonandMrs.McEneryStuart;thehistorians,ProfessorWilliamM.SloaneandDr.Eggleston(reformedfromanovelist);

theliteraryandreligiousandeconomicessayists,Mr.HamiltonW.

Mabie,Mr.H.M.Alden,Mr.J.J.Chapman,andMr.E.L.Godkin,withcritics,dramatists,satirists,magazinists,andjournalistsofliterarystampinnumbertoconvincethewaveringreasonagainstitselfthatherebeyondallquestionisthegreatliterarycentreoftheseStates.ThereisanAuthors\'Club,whichaloneincludesahundredandfiftyauthors,and,ifyoucometoeditors,thereissimplynoend.Magazinesarepublishedhereandcirculatedhencethroughoutthelandbymillions;andbooksbythetonarethedailyoutputofourpublishers,whoarethelargestinthecountry.

Ifthesethingsdonotmeanagreatliterarycentre,itwouldbehardtosaywhatdoes;andIamnotgoingtotryforareasonagainstsuchfacts.

Itisnotqualitythatiswanting,butperhapsitisthequantityofthequality;thereisleaven,butnotforsolargealump.ItmaybethatNewYorkisgoingtobeourliterarycentre,asLondonistheliterarycentreofEngland,bygatheringintoitselfallourwritingtalent,butithasbynomeansdonethisyet.WhatwecansayisthatmoreauthorscomeherefromtheWestandSouththangoelsewhere;buttheyoftenstayathome,andIfancyverywisely.Mr.JoelChandlerHarrisstaysatAtlanta,inGeorgia;Mr.JamesWhitcombRileystaysatIndianapolis;Mr.