第7章

Howmanymenhaveappearedinmytimewhohavemadetheseessayswithsuccess,andhavemadenoprogressafterwards?Somehavedropped,fromtheirfirstflights,downintothevulgarcrowd,havebeendistinguished,nayheardof,nomore!Otherswithbetterparts,perhapswithmorepresumption,butcertainlywithgreaterridicule,havepersistedinmakingtheseessaystowardsbusinessalltheirlives,andhaveneverbeenabletoadvancefarther,intheirpoliticalcourse,thanapremeditatedharangueonsomechoicesubject。Ineversawoneoftheseimportantpersonssitdownafterhisoration,withrepeatedhear—himsringinginhisears,andinwardraptureglowinginhiseyes,thathedidnotrecalltomymemorythestoryofaconceitedmemberofsomeparlementinFrance,whowasoverheard,afterhistediousharangue,mutteringmostdevoutlytohimself,Nonnobis,Domine,nonnobis,sednominituodagloriam!

Eloquence,thatleadsmankindbytheears,givesanoblersuperioritythanpowerthateveryduncemayuse,orfraudthateveryknavemayemploy,toleadthembythenose。Buteloquencemustflowlikeastreamthatisfedbyanabundantspring,andnotspoutforthalittlefrothywateronsomegaudyday,andremaindrytherestoftheyear。ThefamousoratorsofGreeceandRomewerethestatesmenandministersofthosecommonwealths。Thenatureoftheirgovernmentsandthehumourofthoseagesmadeelaborateorationsnecessary。Theyharanguedoftenerthantheydebated:andthearsdicendi,requiredmorestudyandmoreexerciseofmind,andofbodytoo,amongthem,thanarenecessaryamongus。Butasmuchpainsastheytookinlearninghowtoconductthestreamofeloquence,theytookmoretoenlargethefountainfromwhichitflowed。HearDemosthenes,hearCicerothunderagainstPhilip,CatilineandAnthony。IchoosetheexampleofthefirstratherthanthatofPericleswhomheimitated,orofPhocionwhomheopposed,orofanyotherconsiderablepersonageinGreece;andtheexampleofCiceroratherthanthatofCrassus,orofHortensius,orofanyotherofthegreatmenofRome;becausetheeloquenceofthesetwohasbeensocelebratedthatweareaccustomedtolookuponthemalmostasmereorators。Theywereoratorsindeed,andnomanwhohasasoulcanreadtheirorations,aftertherevolutionofsomanyages,aftertheextinctionofthegovernments,andofthepeopleforwhomtheywerecomposed,withoutfeelingatthishourthepassionstheyweredesignedtomove,andthespirittheyweredesignedtoraise。Butifwelookintothehistoryofthesetwomen,andconsiderthepartstheyacted,weshallseetheminanotherlight,andadmiretheminanhighersphereofaction。

Demostheneshadbeenneglected,inhiseducation,bythesametutorswhocheatedhimofhisinheritance。Cicerowasbredwithgreateradvantage:andPlutarch,Ithink,saysthatwhenhefirstappearedthepeopleusedtocallhim,bywayofderision,theGreek,andthescholar。Butwhateveradvantageofthiskindthelattermighthaveovertheformer,andtowhichofthemsoeveryouascribethesuperiorgenius,theprogresswhichbothofthemmadeineverypartofpoliticalknowledge,bytheirindustryandapplication,wasmarvellous。Ciceromightbeabetterphilosopher,butDemostheneswasnolessastatesman:andbothofthemperformedactionsandacquiredfame,abovethereachofeloquencealone。Demosthenesusedtocompareeloquencetoaweapon,aptlyenough;foreloquence,likeeveryotherweapon,isoflittleusetotheowner,unlesshehavetheforceandtheskilltouseit。

ThisforceandthisskillDemostheneshadinaneminentdegree。Observetheminoneinstanceamongmany。ItwasofmightyimportancetoPhiliptopreventtheaccessionofThebestothegrandalliancethatDemosthenes,attheheadoftheAtheniancommonwealth,formedagainstthegrowingpoweroftheMacedonians。

PhiliphademissariesandhisambassadorsonthespottoopposetothoseofAthens,andwemaybeassuredthatheneglectednoneofthoseartsuponthisoccasionthatheemployedsosuccessfullyonothers。Thestrugglewasgreat,butDemosthenesprevailed,andtheThebansengagedinthewaragainstPhilip。Wasitbyhiseloquencealonethatheprevailedinadividedstate,overallthesubtletyofintrigue,allthedexterityofnegotiation,alltheseduction,allthecorruption,andalltheterrorthattheablestandmostpowerfulprincecouldemploy?WasDemostheneswhollytakenupwithcomposingorations,andharanguingthepeople,inthisremarkablecrisis?HeharanguedthemnodoubtatThebes,aswellasatAthens,andintherestofGreece,whereallthegreatresolutionsofmakingalliances,wagingwar,orconcludingpeace,weredeterminedindemocraticalassemblies。Butyetharanguingwasnodoubttheleastpartofhisbusiness,andeloquencewasneitherthesole,northeprincipaltalent,asthestyleofwriterswouldinduceustobelieve,onwhichhissuccessdepended。Hemusthavebeenmasterofotherarts,subservientlytowhichhiseloquencewasemployed,andmusthavehadathoroughknowledgeofhisownstate,andoftheotherstatesofGreece,oftheirdispositions,andoftheirinterestsrelativelytooneanother,andrelativelytotheirneighbours,tothePersiansparticularly,withwhomheheldacorrespondence,notmuchtohishonour:Isay,hemusthavepossessedanimmensefundofknowledge,tomakehiseloquenceineverycasesuccessful,andevenpertinentorseasonableinsome,aswellastodirectitandtofurnishitwithmatterwheneverhethoughtpropertoemploythisweapon。

LetusconsiderTullyonthegreatesttheatreoftheknownworld,andinthemostdifficultcircumstances。WearebetteracquaintedwithhimthanwearewithDemosthenes;forweseehimnearer,asitwere,andinmoredifferentlights。HowperfectaknowledgehadheacquiredoftheRomanconstitutionofgovernment,ecclesiasticalandcivil;oftheoriginalandprogress,ofthegeneralreasonsandparticularoccasionsofthelawsandcustomsofhiscountry;ofthegreatrulesofequity,andthelowpracticeofcourts;ofthedutyofeverymagistracyandofficeinthestate,fromthedictatordowntothelictor;andofallthestepsbywhichRomehadrisenfromherinfancy,toliberty,topowerandgrandeuranddominion,aswellasofallthosebywhichshebegantodecline,alittlebeforehisage,tothatservitudewhichhediedforopposing,butlivedtoseeestablished,andinwhichnotherlibertyalone,butherpowerandgrandeuranddominionwerelost?HowwellwasheacquaintedwiththeRomancoloniesandprovinces,withthealliesandenemiesoftheempire,withtherightsandprivilegesoftheformer,thedispositionsandconditionsofthelatter,withtheinterestsofthemallrelativelytoRome,andwiththeinterestsofRomerelativelytothem?