第2章

AndtothinkthattheinsanepolicyofaGovernmentorGovernmentsshouldbringaboutthewholesaleslaughterofsuchmienasallthesethatIhavedescribed。

Tothinkthatthelongersuchawargoeson,thelessheroicandgenerousitbecomes,andthemoredominatedbyhatredandrevenge——bythewishtoscoreamilitaryvictoryorthedesiretosecuremerepoliticalandcommercialadvantages。

Tothinkthatnationswhoconsiderthemselvescivilizedshouldbethusacting:socontrarytothenaturallawsandinstinctsofhumanitythatofteninorderforabayonetchargemenmustbeprimedwithliquortothevergeofintoxication。

Weneednotgofurther。

Ofthethreegreatnationsprimarilyinvolvedthoseindeedofwhichwecanspeakmostconfidently,knowingthembest——itisintolerabletothinktheyshouldthusmutilateanddestroyeachother。

Allwecansayis:Neveragainmustthisthinghappen!

WhenonethinksofthewholedreadCoilandEntanglement,and,whatitisfor,themindreelsindespair。

Whenonethinksofthemarvellousscientificingenuityandskill,directedinakindofdiabolicconcentrationontheonepurposeofslaughter。

Ofthehugeguns,the12。5’s,weighing40tonsapiece,andboxedandrifledtothenicetyofthethousandthpartofaninch(IhavewatchedthembeingmadeatSheffield)。

Ofthelarger15in。guns,withrangeof13or14miles,soaccuratethattheshellsthrownatthatdistancewilldeviatehardlyacoupleofyardstotherighthandortheleftoftheirlineoffire(andintheJutlandbattlethefiringopenedatnearly11miles)。

Ofthestilllargergunsevennowbeingconstructed。

Oftheshellsthemselvesvaryingfromafewpoundstonearly,atoninweight,andsodelicatelyfashionedthatthemomentoftheirexplosioncanbepositivelytimedtothetenthpartofasecond:

Whenonethinksoftheingenuityputintoaeroplanesandairships,andalmostentirelywithaviewtothedestructionoflife;

Oftheautomaticsteeringofsubmarinetorpedoesbymeansofgyroscopes,sothatwhendeviatedbyanyobstacleoraccidentfromtheirsetcoursetheywillactuallyreturnofthemselvestothatcourseagain;

Oftheeverlastingduelgoingoninanyonecountrybetweenarmourplatesandprojectilesbutofcoursealwaysbetweenthearmourplatesofonefirmandtheprojectilesofanother(sinceobviouslyforanyonefirmtoproveitsowninferiorityineitherlinewouldbebadbusiness)!

OfthecompetitionevennowinprogressbetweentheRussianuniversitiesfortheinventionofanewexplosiveoranewgasmoredevastatingthananyhithertoproduced;

OftheweightyAdvisoryCommitteeofscientificExpertssittingpermanentlyinBritainforthediscussionandhandlingofthetechnicalproblemsoftheWar;

WhenonethinksofwhataParadiseallthisingenuity,allthisexpenditureoflabourandtreasure,mightmakeofourmortalEarth——ifitwereonlydecentlyemployed;

ThatGreatBritainalonehasalreadyspentontheWarenoughtoprovideeveryfamilyinthewholekingdomwithacomfortablecottageandanacreofland;

Whenfurtheronethinksofallthemassofhumanmaterialthereis,suchaswehavealreadydescribed——oftheveryfinestquality,andfittobuildthemostsplendidracesandcities\"thesunevershoneupon\"——andthenthatitisbeingusedfortheseutterlysenselesspurposes;

Howheart—rendingthewasteandthefolly!Howdisgustingthesinofthosewhoareresponsible!

Butto—daysurelythearmiesthemselvesofthesethreecountriesarebeginningtoseethroughtheillusionswhichhavebeendangledbeforethensolongbythoseinpower——the\"My—country——right—or—wrong\"

kindofPatriotismwhichhassooftenbeenevokedonlyinordertoservetheplotsofprivateschemers;

TheyaresurelybeginningtoseethatthedirectingofState—policyandforeignrelationsmustnolongerbeleftinthehandsofafewhighborndiplomats(mostlyignorantoftheactualmodernworldamidwhichtheylive),butmustbesubjecttotheseverestscrutinyandsurveillancebythepeopleatlargeandtheirrepresentatives;

Theyarebeginningtoseethatifcourage,devotiontoanIdea,loveoftheFather—orMother—land,Fidelityofcomradetocomrade,Efficiency,daringinAdventure,exactnessinOrganization,andsoforth,arethequalitieswhichinthepasthavemadetheprofessionofarmsgreatandglorious,itistheseveryqualitieswhichwillbedemandedandevokedforallfuturetimeinthegreatfreearmiesofIndustry。

ForwiththecessationofMilitarismastheleadingprincipleofnationallifemustinevitablycometheliberationofIndustry——elsethelaststateofoursocietieswillindeedbeworsethanthefirst。

TrulythereisnothingveryexhilaratingaboutIndustryasithasinmoderntimesbeenconceived,andonedoesnotaltogetherwonderthatalldownthecenturiesthemanwiththeswordhasdespisedthemanwiththehoe,sincethelatterhasgenerallybeenlittlebetterthanaslave。

ButwhenonceLabourisfreed——orratherwhenonceitfreesitself——fromthethraldom,oftheoldFeudalsystem,andfinallyfromthefearfulburdenofmodernCapitalism——whenonceitcanliftitsheadandseethegreatconstructivevisionofthenewsocietywhichawaitsit——thensurelyitwillperceivethatallthegreatqualitieswehavenamedasexhibitedinthepastintheolddestructiveWarfare,andnowbecomethesplendidheritageofthepeoplesofEurope,willbenecessaryandwillhaveafieldfortheirexerciseinthebeneficentconstructiveconquestsofNatureandthebuildinguponEarthofthatgreatCityoftheSunwhichforsomanyageshasbeenthedreamandinspirationofMan。

AndoftheoldmadWarfareitwillthensayThisodiousandinhumanThingmustneverbeagain!

Inconclusion,andtolooktothefuture:

Ithinkwemayseethatthenewconceptionoflifewillonlycomethroughthepeelingoffinthevariousnationsoftheoldhusksofthediplomatic,military,legal,andcommercialclasses,withtheirantiquated,narrow—mindedandprofoundly。irreligiousandinhumanstandards——thosehuskswhichhavesolongrestrictedandstrangulatedthegrowinglifewithin。

Itwillonlycomewiththedeterminationoftheworkers(thatis,ofeverybody)toproducethingsuseful,profitable,andbeautiful,infreeandrationalco—operation——thingsusefulbecausedeliberatelymadeforuse,thingsprofitableforallbecausenotmadeforthegainofthefew,andthingsbeautifulbecauseofthejoyandgladnesswroughtintotheirveryproduction。

Simultaneouslywiththispeelingoff,oftheOld,anddisclosureoftheNew,willofnecessityappear——indeeditistakingshapealreadytheblossomofinternationalsolidarityandfederation——thecommoncauseofHumanityandofLabourliberatedovertheworld。

Naturallysuchprocesswillnotmatureallatonce。Itmay,bitthatthefourWesternnations,England,France,ItalyandBelgium,combiningwithsomeoftheneutralStates,willconstitutethefirstEuropeanFederationoratanyratethenucleusofaFederationdestined,asitexpandstoabsorbwithinitsbordersGermanyherself(ofcoursewhensheshallhavetakenonhertruerepublicanform)

andtheotherStatesinduesuccession。

SuchFederationwhenfirmlyconsolidatedmight,itisnotunlikely,stillretainforalongperiodamilitarysystem,ofsomekind,ifonlyforitsownprotectionagainstoutlyingandnonEuropeandangers;butthatmilitarysystemwouldbesmallandsecondary。

ItrightreasonablybenomoredominantormeddlesomethanthemilitarysystemofChinahasbeenduringthelastthousandyearsincomparisonwiththemassiveimperturbabilityofthegreatChineseEmpireitself。

Meanwhileletusrememberhowimportantitisforthefutureoftheworldthateachnationandpeopleshouldbefreetocontributeitsspecialqualityandcharactertothewhole;norberidden—overroughshodbytheothers;

Thateachshouldcontribute,inTradeorotherwise,itsspecialgiftsorfacilities;andthattheInternationalismwhichalreadyrulesinlabouraffairsandinCommerceandScienceandFashionandFinanceandPhilanthropyandLiteratureandArtandMusic,shouldatlastberecognizedinPolitics。

LetusfurtherrememberhowimportantitisthateverymanandwomanshouldinsistontherightsofPersonalitytopreservesacredhisorhermostintimatesenseofselfnessanddutythevery,essenceofFreedom。

ThoughIdonot,forinstance,thinkthatarefusaltofightunderanyconditionorcircumstancecanreasonablybemaintainedtoitslogicalconclusion,andthoughIcertainlywouldnotengagemyselftorefusetofightinanyandeverycase。Still,Idohonourandrespectthegenuineconscientiousobjectors(ofwhomtherearegreatnumbers)verysincerely。

Someofthemmay,benarrow—mindedandfaddist(asconscienceoftenis),butletusrememberthatthegreatthingsofHistoryhavebeeninitiatedbysuchfolk。

ItwastheywhobarredandbrokethegladiatorialgamesatRome;

itwasthey,who,steeredthe\"Mayflower\"acrosstheAtlantic,andstartedthegreatRepublicoftheUnitedStates;

Anditisthey,whoarepossiblysowingtheseedagreatMovementwhichwillspreadalloverEurope,andultimatelybyopposingcompulsorymilitaryserviceinaugurateaworld—eraofPeace。

(Forcertainly,withoutConscriptiontheContinentalPowerswouldneverhavebecomeinvolvedinthepresentwar)

Letusrecognizetherightandthedutyofeachmantopondertheseworld—problemsforhimself:toplayhispartandtomakehisownvoiceheardinthesolutionofthem。

LetusrecognizethefalsityofSciencedivorcedfromtheHeart,andbeginto—daytocreateapolitical,aneconomic,andamaterialworldwhichshallbethetrueandsatisfyingexpressionoftherealhumansoul;

LetusacknowledgeevenatthelastthattheWarmayhavebeena,necessaryeviltoshowusbycontrasttheway,ofdeliverance;

Letusrender,homagetothosewhohavegiventheirlivesinit;

letusvowthattheirgreatsacrificeshallnotbeinvain,butshallconsecrateforusanewpurposeandanewideal;

LetusbelievethatLove,notHatred,isthepowerbywhichintheendtheWorldwillbesaved;

AndletuspraythataHeroismequaltothat,shownto—dayinthecauseofDestructionmayurgeusinthefuturetowardsagreatandgloriousConstructiveerainsociallife——andinspireuswithanewhope:

Outofpurgatorytobuildaparadise,inwhichtheugliness,vulgarity,sordidnessandcrueltyofthepresentschemeofthingswillberepeated。

August1916