第2章

Supposethepubliconcefairlybroughttothatcondition,towhichitishasteningwithsuchamazingrapidity;supposethelandtobetaxedeighteenornineteenshillingsinthepound;foritcanneverbearthewholetwenty;supposealltheexcisesandcustomstobescreweduptotheutmostwhichthenationcanbear,withoutentirelylosingitscommerceandindustry;andsupposethatallthosefundsaremortgagedtoperpetuity,andthattheinventionandwitofallourprojectorscanfindnonewimposition,whichmayserveasthefoundationofanewloan;andletusconsiderthenecessaryconsequencesofthissituation。

Thoughtheimperfectstateofourpoliticalknowledge,andthenarrowcapacitiesofmen,makeitdifficulttoforteltheeffectswhichwillresultfromanyuntriedmeasure,theseedsofruinareherescatteredwithsuchprofusionasnottoescapetheeyeofthemostcarelessobserver。

Inthisunnaturalstateofsociety,theonlypersons,whopossessanyrevenuebeyondtheimmediateeffectsoftheirindustry,arethestock—holders,whodrawalmostalltherentofthelandandhouses,besidestheproduceofallthecustomsandexcises。Thesearemen,whohavenoconnexionswiththestate,whocanenjoytheirrevenueinanypartoftheglobeinwhichtheychusetoreside,whowillnaturallyburythemselvesinthecapitaloringreatcities,andwhowillsinkintothelethargyofastupidandpamperedluxury,withoutspirit,ambition,orenjoyment。Adieutoallideasofnobility,gentry,andfamily。

Thestockscanbetransferredinaninstant,andbeinginsuchafluctuatingstate,willseldombetransmittedduringthreegenerationsfromfathertoson。Orweretheytoremaineversolonginonefamily,theyconveynohereditaryauthorityorcredittothepossessor;andbythismeans,theseveralranksofmen,whichformakindofindependentmagistracyinastate,institutedbythehandofnature,areentirelylost;andeverymaninauthorityderiveshisinfluencefromthecommissionaloneofthesovereign。Noexpedientremainsforpreventingorsuppressinginsurrections,butmercenaryarmies:Noexpedientatallremainsforresistingtyranny。Electionsareswayedbybriberyandcorruptionalone:Andthemiddlepowerbetweenkingandpeoplebeingtotallyremoved,agrievousdespotismmustinfalliblyprevail。Thelandholders,despisedfortheirpoverty,andhatedfortheiroppressions,willbeutterlyunabletomakeanyoppositiontoit。

Thougharesolutionshouldbeformedbythelegislaturenevertoimposeanytaxwhichhurtscommerceanddiscouragesindustry,itwillbeimpossibleformen,insubjectsofsuchextremedelicacy,toreasonsojustlyasnevertobemistaken,oramidstdifficultiessourgent,nevertobeseducedfromtheirresolution。Thecontinualfluctuationsincommercerequirecontinualalterationsinthenatureofthetaxes;whichexposesthelegislatureeverymomenttothedangerbothofwilfulandinvoluntaryerror。Andanygreatblowgiventotrade,whetherbyinjudicioustaxesorbyotheraccidents,throwsthewholesystemofgovernmentintoconfusion。

Butwhatexpedientcanthepublicnowemploy,evensupposingtradetocontinueinthemostflourishingcondition,inordertosupportitsforeignwarsandenterprizes,andtodefenditsownhonourandinterests,orthoseofitsallies?Idonotaskhowthepublicistoexertsuchaprodigiouspowerasithasmaintainedduringourlatewars;wherewehavesomuchexceeded,notonlyourownnaturalstrength,buteventhatofthegreatestempires。Thisextravaganceistheabusecomplainedof,asthesourceofallthedangers,towhichweareatpresentexposed。

Butsincewemuststillsupposegreatcommerceandopulencetoremain,evenaftereveryfundismortgaged;theserichesmustbedefendedbyproportionalpower;andwhenceisthepublictoderivetherevenuewhichsupportsit?Itmustplainlybefromacontinualtaxationoftheannuitants,or,whichisthesamething,frommortgaginganew,oneveryexigency,acertainpartoftheirannuities;andthusmakingthemcontributetotheirowndefence,andtothatofthenation。Butthedifficulties,attendingthissystemofpolicy,willeasilyappear,whetherwesupposethekingtohavebecomeabsolutemaster,ortobestillcontrouledbynationalcouncils,inwhichtheannuitantsthemselvesmustnecessarilybeartheprincipalsway。

Iftheprincehasbecomeabsolute,asmaynaturallybeexpectedfromthissituationofaffairs,itissoeasyforhimtoencreasehisexactionsupontheannuitants,whichamountonlytotheretainingmoneyinhisownhands,thatthisspeciesofpropertywouldsoonloseallitscredit,andthewholeincomeofeveryindividualinthestatemustlieentirelyatthemercyofthesovereign:Adegreeofdespotism,whichnoorientalmonarchyhaseveryetattained。If,onthecontrary,theconsentoftheannuitantsberequisiteforeverytaxation,theywillneverbepersuadedtocontributesufficientlyeventothesupportofgovernment;asthediminutionoftheirrevenuemustinthatcasebeverysensible,wouldnotbedisguisedundertheappearanceofabranchofexciseorcustoms,andwouldnotbesharedbyanyotherorderofthestate,whoarealreadysupposedtobetaxedtotheutmost。Thereareinstances,insomerepublics,ofahundredthpenny,andsometimesofthefiftieth,beinggiventothesupportofthestate;butthisisalwaysanextraordinaryexertionofpower,andcanneverbecomethefoundationofaconstantnationaldefence。Wehavealwaysfound,whereagovernmenthasmortgagedallitsrevenues,thatitnecessarilysinksintoastateoflanguor,inactivity,andimpotence。

Sucharetheinconveniencies,whichmayreasonablybeforeseen,ofthissituation,towhichGREATBRITAINisvisiblytending。Nottomention,thenumberlessinconveniencies,whichcannotbeforeseen,andwhichmustresultfromsomonstrousasituationasthatofmakingthepublicthechieforsoleproprietorofland,besidesinvestingitwitheverybranchofcustomsandexcise,whichthefertileimaginationofministersandprojectorshavebeenabletoinvent。

Imustconfess,thatthereisastrangesupineness,fromlongcustom,creepedintoallranksofmen,withregardtopublicdebts,notunlikewhatdivinessovehementlycomplainofwithregardtotheirreligiousdoctrines。Weallown,thatthemostsanguineimaginationcannothope,eitherthatthisoranyfutureministrywillbepossessedofsuchrigidandsteadyfrugality,astomakeaconsiderableprogressinthepaymentofourdebts;orthatthesituationofforeignaffairswill,foranylongtime,allowthemleisureandtranquillityforsuchanundertaking。Whatthenistobecomeofus?WereweeversogoodChristians,andeversoresignedtoProvidence;this,methinks,wereacuriousquestion,evenconsideredasaspeculativeone,andwhatitmightnotbealtogetherimpossibletoformsomeconjecturalsolutionof。Theeventsherewilldependlittleuponthecontingenciesofbattles,negociations,intrigues,andfactions。Thereseemstobeanaturalprogressofthings,whichmayguideourreasoning。Asitwouldhaverequiredbutamoderateshareofprudence,whenwefirstbeganthispracticeofmortgaging,tohaveforetold,fromthenatureofmenandofministers,thatthingswouldnecessarilybecarriedtothelengthwesee;sonow,thattheyhaveatlasthappilyreachedit,itmaynotbedifficulttoguessattheconsequences。Itmust,indeed,beoneofthesetwoevents;eitherthenationmustdestroypubliccredit,orpubliccreditwilldestroythenation。Itisimpossiblethattheycanbothsubsist,afterthemannertheyhavebeenhithertomanaged,inthis,aswellasinsomeothercountries。

Therewas,indeed,aschemeforthepaymentofourdebts,whichwasproposedbyanexcellentcitizen,MrHUTCHINSON,abovethirtyyearsago,andwhichwasmuchapprovedofbysomemenofsense,butneverwaslikelytotakeeffect。Heasserted,thattherewasafallacyinimaginingthatthepublicowedthisdebt;

forthatreallyeveryindividualowedaproportionalshareofit,andpaid,inhistaxes,aproportionalshareoftheinterest,besidetheexpenceoflevyingthesetaxes。Hadwenotbetter,then,sayshe,makeadistributionofthedebtamongourselves,andeachofuscontributeasumsuitabletohisproperty,andbythatmeansdischargeatonceallourfundsandpublicmortgages?

Heseemsnottohaveconsidered,thatthelaboriouspoorpayaconsiderablepartofthetaxesbytheirannualconsumptions,thoughtheycouldnotadvance,atonce,aproportionalpartofthesumrequired。Nottomention,thatpropertyinmoneyandstockintrademighteasilybeconcealedordisguised;andthatvisiblepropertyinlandsandhouseswouldreallyatlastanswerforthewhole:Aninequalityandoppression,whichneverwouldbesubmittedto。Butthoughthisprojectisnotlikelytotakeplace;itisnotaltogetherimprobable,that,whenthenationbecomesheartilysickoftheirdebts,andiscruellyoppressedbythem,somedaringprojectormayarisewithvisionaryschemesfortheirdischarge。Andaspubliccreditwillbegin,bythattime,tobealittlefrail,theleasttouchwilldestroyit,ashappenedinFRANCEduringtheregency。andinthismanneritwilldieofthedoctor。

Butitismoreprobable,thatthebreachofnationalfaithwillbethenecessaryeffectofwars,defeats,misfortunes,andpubliccalamities,orevenperhapsofvictoriesandconquests。I

mustconfess,whenIseeprincesandstatesfightingandquarrelling,amidsttheirdebts,funds,andpublicmortgages,italwaysbringstomymindamatchofcudgel—playingfoughtinaChinashop。Howcanitbeexpected,thatsovereignswillspareaspeciesofproperty,whichispernicioustothemselvesandtothepublic,whentheyhavesolittlecompassiononlivesandproperties,thatareusefultoboth?Letthetimecome(andsurelyitwillcome)whenthenewfunds,createdfortheexigenciesoftheyear,arenotsubscribedto,andraisenotthemoneyprojected。Suppose,eitherthatthecashofthenationisexhausted;orthatourfaith,whichhashithertobeensoample,beginstofailus。Suppose,that,inthisdistress,thenationisthreatenedwithaninvasion;arebellionissuspectedorbrokenoutathome;asquadroncannotbeequippedforwantofpay,victuals,orrepairs;orevenaforeignsubsidycannotbeadvanced。Whatmustaprinceorministerdoinsuchanemergence?

Therightofself—preservationisunalienableineveryindividual,muchmoreineverycommunity。Andthefollyofourstatesmenmustthenbegreaterthanthefollyofthosewhofirstcontracteddebt,or,whatismore,thanthatofthosewhotrusted,orcontinuetotrustthissecurity,ifthesestatesmenhavethemeansofsafetyintheirhands,anddonotemploythem。

Thefunds,createdandmortgaged,will,bythattime,bringinalargeyearlyrevenue,sufficientforthedefenceandsecurityofthenation:Moneyisperhapslyingintheexchequer,readyforthedischargeofthequarterlyinterest:Necessitycalls,fearurges,reasonexhorts,compassionaloneexclaims:Themoneywillimmediatelybeseizedforthecurrentservice,underthemostsolemnprotestations,perhaps,ofbeingimmediatelyreplaced。Butnomoreisrequisite。Thewholefabric,alreadytottering,fallstotheground,andburiesthousandsinitsruins。Andthis,I

think,maybecalledthenaturaldeathofpubliccredit:Fortothisperiodittendsasnaturallyasananimalbodytoitsdissolutionanddestruction。

Sogreatdupesarethegeneralityofmankind,that,notwithstandingsuchaviolentshocktopubliccredit,asavoluntarybankruptcyinENGLANDwouldoccasion,itwouldnotprobablybelongerecreditwouldagainreviveinasflourishingaconditionasbefore。ThepresentkingofFRANCE,duringthelatewar,borrowedmoneyatlowerinterestthaneverhisgrandfatherdid;andaslowastheBRITISHparliament,comparingthenaturalrateofinterestinbothkingdoms。Andthoughmenarecommonlymoregovernedbywhattheyhaveseen,thanbywhattheyforesee,withwhatevercertainty;yetpromises,protestations,fairappearances,withtheallurementsofpresentinterest,havesuchpowerfulinfluenceasfewareabletoresist。Mankindare,inallages,caughtbythesamebaits:Thesametricks,playedoverandoveragain,stilltrepanthem。Theheightsofpopularityandpatriotismarestillthebeatenroadtopowerandtyranny;

flatterytotreachery;standingarmiestoarbitrarygovernment;

andthegloryofGodtothetemporalinterestoftheclergy。Thefearofaneverlastingdestructionofcredit,allowingittobeanevil,isaneedlessbugbear。Aprudentman,inreality,wouldratherlendtothepublicimmediatelyafterwehadtakenaspungetoourdebts,thanatpresent;asmuchasanopulentknave,eventhoughonecouldnotforcehimtopay,isapreferabledebtortoanhonestbankrupt:Fortheformer,inordertocarryonbusiness,mayfindithisinteresttodischargehisdebts,wheretheyarenotexorbitant:Thelatterhasitnotinhispower。ThereasoningofTACITUS,asitiseternallytrue,isveryapplicabletoourpresentcase。Sedvulgusadmagnitudinembeneficiorumaderat:Stultissimusquisquepecuniismercabatur:Apudsapientescassahabebantur,quoenequedarinequeaccipi,salvarepublica,Poterant。Thepublicisadebtor,whomnomancanobligetopay。

Theonlycheckwhichthecreditorshaveuponher,istheinterestofpreservingcredit;aninterest,whichmayeasilybeoverbalancedbyagreatdebt,andbyadifficultandextraordinaryemergence,evensupposingthatcreditirrecoverable。Nottomention,thatapresentnecessityoftenforcesstatesintomeasures,whichare,strictlyspeaking,againsttheirinterest。

Thesetwoevents,supposedabove,arecalamitous,butnotthemostcalamitous。Thousandsaretherebysacrificedtothesafetyofmillions。Butwearenotwithoutdanger,thatthecontraryeventmaytakeplace,andthatmillionsmaybesacrificedforevertothetemporarysafetyofthousands。Ourpopulargovernment,perhaps,willrenderitdifficultordangerousforaministertoventureonsodesperateanexpedient,asthatofavoluntarybankruptcy。AndthoughthehouseofLordsbealtogethercomposedofproprietorsofland,andthehouseofCommonschiefly;andconsequentlyneitherofthemcanbesupposedtohavegreatpropertyinthefunds。Yettheconnectionsofthemembersmaybesogreatwiththeproprietors,astorenderthemmoretenaciousofpublicfaith,thanprudence,policy,orevenjustice,strictlyspeaking,requires。Andperhapstoo,ourforeignenemiesmaybesopoliticastodiscover,thatoursafetyliesindespair,andmaynot,therefore,showthedanger,openandbarefaced,tillitbeinevitable。ThebalanceofpowerinEUROPE,ourgrandfathers,ourfathers,andwe,havealldeemedtoounequaltobepreservedwithoutourattentionandassistance。

Butourchildren,wearyofthestruggle,andfetteredwithincumbrances,maysitdownsecure,andseetheirneighboursoppressedandconquered;till,atlast,theythemselvesandtheircreditorsliebothatthemercyoftheconqueror。Andthismayproperlyenoughbedenominatedtheviolentdeathofourpubliccredit。

Theseseemtobetheevents,whicharenotveryremote,andwhichreasonforeseesasclearlyalmostasshecandoanythingthatliesinthewomboftime。Andthoughtheancientsmaintained,thatinordertoreachthegiftofprophecy,acertaindivinefuryormadnesswasrequisite,onemaysafelyaffirm,that,inordertodeliversuchpropheciesasthese,nomoreisnecessary,thanmerelytobeinone’ssenses,freefromtheinfluenceofpopularmadnessanddelusion。