第3章

IftheMoneyofanparticularCountryshouldencreasebeyondtheproportionthatCountrybearstoEurope;itwouldundervalueMoneythere,or,accordingtothewayofspeaking,itwouldraiseGoods:ButasMoneywouldbeundervaluedeverywherethesame,orneartowahtitwerethere;itwouldbeofgreatAdvantagetothatcountry,thotherebyMoneywerelessvaluable:ForthatCountrywouldhavethewholeBenefitofthegreaterQuantity,andonlybearashareofthelesservalue,accordingtotheproportionitsMoneyhadtotheMoneyofEurope。WhentheSpaniardsbringMoneyorBullionintoEurope,theylessenitsvalue,butgainbybringingit;becausetheyhavethewholebenefitofthegreaterQuantity,andonlybearashareofthelesservalue。

Whathasbeensaid,proves,1st。ThatSilverMoneyisanuncertainvalue;becauselyabletobealter’dintheFinenessorDenominationbythePrince。ACrownhasnomoreSilverinitthanhalfaCrownor15Pencehada150or200Yearsago。

2ndly。ThatasSilverithasfallenfromtheValueithad,thesameQuantitynotbeingworththe5thor10thpartofwhatitwasworththen。AMoney’dManthenwortha1000lib。wasRicheratthattimethanaLandedManof240ChalderofVictualRent:ButaManofsuchaMoneyEstate,wouldnotnowbeworthone50thpartofsuchaLandEstate。

3dly。Thatthofallensomuch,yetitisgivenasMoneyorSoldasBullion,formuchmorethanitsValueasaMettal;towhichitwillbereduced,sosoonasanotherMoneyissetup。

ConsideringthepresentstateofEurope,FranceandSpainbeingMastersoftheMines。TheotherNationsseemtobeunderanecessityofsettingupanotherMoney。TheonlyReasoncanbegivenwhyithasnotbeenrightlyunderstood:OrtheywouldnothavecontinuedbuyingSilverfromSpainaboveitsValueasaMettal,whentheyhadamorevaluableMoneyoftheirown,andeverywaymorefittedforthatUse。

TheReceiverofSilvercanhavenogreathopesthattheValueofitwillbegreater;For’tisnottobesupposeditwillbeapply’dtoanyotherUses,thanitisnowapply’dto,wherebytheDemandforitmaybeencreas’d:OrthattheQuantityExportedandConsum’d,willbegreaterthantheQuantityImported。

ThoitbescarceinanyparticularCountry,yettheMony’dMenwillhavenogreatBenefitbysuchscarcity,ashasbeenshown:ForunlessthescarcityisthesameinallplaceswithwhichthatCountryTrades,MoneywillnotbevaluedmuchhighertherethaninotherCountries。

IfitisalledgedtheMinesintheWest—Indiesmayfail。’TistheInterestoftheSpaniardstogiveoutthattheirMinesbegintofail,tokeepupthePriceofSilver;butifthatweretrue,FranceoughtnothaveengagedherselfinaWar,whenbythePartitionTreatyshecouldhavegotanyotherpartsofthatMonarchythatarevaluable。

AllowingtheMinesdofail,weoughttherathertoprovideourselveswithanotherMoney。

Chapter6

TheProposalgivenintotheParliamentbyDrH。C。ExaminedIDidnotintendtohavesaidanythingabouttheDrs。Proposal,thatAffairhavingbeenrefer’dtoaCommittee,whoaretomaketheirReport。ButSeveralisnotpracticable,beingagainstwhatIamtoPropose,becausetheythink’tisthesamewithhisinsomeotherdress:IthoughtitneedfultogiveashortAccountoftheDrs。

Proposal,andinwhatIdifferfromhim。

HisProposalistogiveoutNotesuponLand,tobecancell’dbyyearlyPaymentsofabout2andQuarterperCent,for45Years。AndthattheseNotesbecurrentasSilverMoney,tothevaluetheyarecoin’dfor。

IfNotesgivenoutafterthatmanner,wereequalinvaluetoSilver—money;TheneveryLandedManinScotland,woulddesireashareofthisgreatandcertainAdvantage:AndIdon’tseehowitispracticabletogiveeveryLandedManashare。

Supposingitpracticable,45YearsPurchaseintheseNotes,willnotbeofsomuchvalue,as20YearsPurchaseofSilverMoney。

NoAnticipationisequaltowhatalreadyis。AYearsRentnowisworth15YearsRent50Yearshence,becausethatMoneyletoutatInterest,bythattimewillproducesomuch。AndthotheParliamentwouldforcetheseNotes,yettheywouldnothaveCurrency,anymorethaniftheGovernmentCoin’dpiecesofGoldequalinWeightandFineness,withatGuinea,andorderedthemtopassfor5lib。

TheseBillsarepropos’dtoberepay’dandcancell’dinaTermofYears,withoutpayinganyInterest,butonlysomuchaswoulddefraytheChargesoftheOffice,whichwouldbeaboveonehalfpercent。

TherewouldthenbemanyLenders,butfewifanyBorrowers,exceptfromtheLand—Bank:Foras’tistheLandedManborrowsoftheMoney’dMan,hewouldsatisfiehisCreditor,andhaveBillstoLend。

TheMoney’dManwouldlikewisehaveoftheseBillstoLend,buttherewouldbenoBorrowers;OrifanydesiredtoBorrow,theywouldhavetheseBillsataverylowUse。Supposeat2percent,thentheseBillswouldbeconsiderablylessvaluablethanSilver。

Anythingthatispropos’dtohaveaCurrencyasMoney,andisgivenforalesserInterestthanSilverMoney,willbeoflessValue。

Itisnottobesuppos’danypersonwilllendSilverMoneyat2

percent,whentheycanhave6percentinEngland。Soa100lib。

SilverMoney,willyieldalsmuchas300lib。oftheseBillswould:

and100lib。inSilver,willbeequalto300lib。inBills。The6lib。

the100lib。ofSilveryields,beingSilver,andthe6lib。the300ofBillsyields,beingpayedintheseBills:and1lib。Silver,beingworth3lib。inBills;sothe6lib。Interestofthe100lib。inSilver,wouldbeequalto18libortheInterestof900lib。inBills。

Andthotheyweregivenouttoberepay’din20years,at5percentforthattime;orin10years,at10percent:theywouldnotbeequallyvaluablewithSilver。Thedifferencewouldnotbesogreat,aswhengivenoutfor45years,TheAdvantagetheNationwouldhavebytheDrs。Proposalis;thatthotheseNotessellunderthevalueofSilverMoney,and500lib。inNoteswereonlyequalto100lib。inSilver:YettheNationwouldhavethesameAdvantagebythat500lib。inNotes,asifanAdditionofa100lib。hadbeenmadetotheSilver—money。

SofarastheseBillssellunderthevalueoftheSilverMoney,sofarwouldExchangewithotherCountriesberais’d。AndifGoodsdidnotkeeptheirPrice,(i。e。)IftheydidnotsellforagreaterQuantityotheseBills,equaltothedifferencebetwixtthemandSilver:Goodsexportedwouldbeundervalued,andGoodsimportedwouldbeovervalued,ashasbeenexplain’dpage24aboutExchange。

TheLanded—manwouldhavenoAdvantagebythisProposal,unlessheowedDebt:Forthohereceiv’d50lib:oftheseBills,forthesameQuantityofVictualhewasinusetoreceive,10lib。Silver—money;

yetthat50lib。wouldonlybeequalinValueto10lib。ofSilver,andpurchaseonlythesameQuantityofHomeorForreignGoods。

TheLanded—manwhohadhisRentpay’dhiminMoney,wouldbeagreatloser。ForbyalsmuchastheseBillswereundertheValueofSilver,hewouldreceivesomuchlessthanbefore。

TheLanded—manwhoowedDebt,wouldpayhisDebtwithalessValuethanwascontractedfor:ButtheCreditorwouldlosewhattheDebitorgain’d。

Dr。C。seemstobeoffendedatmymeddlinginthisAffair,having,ashesays,borrow’dwhatIknowofthisSubjectfromhim。TwoPersonsmayprojectthesamething,butsofarasIcanjudge,whatI

amtoproposeisdifferentfromhis,andwhatIhadform’daSchemeofseveralyearsbeforeIhadseenanyofhisPapers:WhichIcanprove,ifthatwerenecessary,bypersonsofworthIthenshow’ditto。I

havenot,tomyknowledge,borrowedanythingfromDr。C。LandindeedistheValueuponwhichhefundshisProposal,and’tisuponLand,thatIfundmine:IfforthatReasonIhaveincroach’duponhisProposal,theBankofScotlandmaybesaidtohavedonethesame:

TherewereBanksinEuropelongbeforetheDrs。Proposal,andBooksahvebeenwritontheSubjectbeforeandsince。TheFundationIgouponhasbeenknownsolongasMoneyhasbeenlentonLand,andsolongasanheretableBondhasbeenequaltoaQuantityofLand。

WhethertheStructureheorIhavebuiltuponthatFundationbemostsafe,advantageousandpracticalbe,theParliamentcanbestjudge。

Dr。C’sProposalisbyAnticipation,tomakeLandworth50ora100yearsPurchase;andmaintainsthata100lib。tobepayedyearlyfor10,50ora100years,isavaluablePledgefora1000,5000,ora10000lib。ofBills:AndthattheseBillswillbeequaltoSilver—

money。IfhecansatisfietheNationthathisProposalispracticable,hedoesaverygreatService,andgivesacertainadvantagetotheLanded—man,withoutwrongingtheMoney’d—man。IhaveshowntheReasonswhyIthinktheProposalisnotpracticable;andthatnotwithstandinganyActofParliamentmadetoforcetheseBills,theywouldfallmuchunderthevalueofSilver。ButallowingtheywereatfirstequaltoSilver,itisnexttoimpossiblethattwodifferentSpeciesofMoney,shallcontinueequalinvaluetooneanother。

Everythingreceivesavaluefromitsuse,andtheValueisraised,accordingtoitsQuality,QuantityandDemand。ThoGoodsofdifferentkindsareequalinvaluenow,yettheywillchangetheirValue,fromanyunequalChangeintheirQuality,Quantity,orDemand。

AndasheleavesittothechoiceoftheDebitor,topayinSilver—moneyorBills;heconfinesthevalueoftheBills,tothevalueoftheSilver—money,butcannotconfinetheValueoftheSilver—

moneytothevalueoftheBills:SothattheseBillsmustfallinvalueasSilver—moneyfalls,andmayfalllower:Silvermayriseabovethevalueofthesebills,buttheseBillscannotriseabovethevalueofSilver。

WhatIshallpropose,istomakeMoneyofLandequaltoitsvalue;andthatMoneytobeequalinvaluetoSilver—money:AndnotlyabletofallinvalueasSilver—moneyfalls。

AndGoodsthathavetheQualitiesnecessaryinMoney,maybemadeMoneyequaltotheirvalue。5OuncesofGoldisequalinvalueto20

lib。andmaybemadeMoneytothatValue。AnAcreofLandrentedat2

BollsofVictual,theVictualat8lib。andLandat20yearspurchase,isequalto20lib。andmaybemadeMoneyequaltothatValue,forithasalltheQualitiesnecessaryinMoney。ButthatAcreofLandcannotbecoin’dtotheValueof50lib。nomorethanthe5OuncesofGold。

Andthothe5OuncesofGold,the20lib。SilverMoney,andtheAcreofLand,benowequalinvalue;yettheycannotwellcontinueso:ForasIhaveshownalready,anddisproportion’dChangeintheQuality,Quantity,orintheDemandofeitherofthem,willmakethesameQuantityoftheothers。LandiswhatinallappearancewillkeepitsValuebest,itmayriseinvalue,butcannotwellfall:GoldorSilverarelyabletomanyAccidents,wherebytheirValuemaylessen;butcannotwellriseinvalue。

ChapterVII

TheProposalwithReasonsforit。

ToSupplytheNationwithMoney,itishumblypropos’d,That40

CommissionersbeappointedbyParliament,AnswerabletoParliamentfortheirAdministration,andtheAdministrationoftheOfficersunderthem:TheNominationoftheseOfficersbeinglesttotheCommissioners。

ThattheCommissionershavePowertoCoinNotes:WhichNotestobereceivedinPayments,whereoffer’d。

ThataCommitteeofParliamentbeappointedtoinspecttheManagement,andthatnoneoftheCommissionersbeMembers。

ThattheCommissionandCommitteemeettwiceayearatWhitsunday,andMartinmass;theirMeetings,tobegin10daysbefore,andtocontinue10daysaftereachTerm。

Therearethreewayshumblyoffer’dtotheParliament,forgivingouttheseNotes:theyintheirWisdommaydeterminewhichwillbemostsafe。

1。ToauthorizetheCommissiontolendNotesonLandSecurity,theDebtnotexceedingonehalf,ortwoThirdsoftheValue:AndattheordinaryInterest。

2。TogiveoutthefullPriceofLand,asitisvalued,20yearspurchasemoreorless,accordingtowhatitwouldhavegiveninSilver—money。ThecommissionentringintoPossessionofsuchLands,byWadsetgrantedtotheCommissionorAssigneys;andredeemablebetwixtandexpiringofaTermofyears。

3。TogivethefullPriceofLand,uponSalemadeofsuchLands,anddisponedtotheCommissionorAssigneysirredeemably。

ThatanypersonshallhavesuchBonds,Wadsets,orEstatesassign’dordispon’dtothem,uponpayinginthevaluetotheCommission。

ThattheCommissiondon’treceiveotherMoneythantheseNotes。

ThatnopersonwhohascontractedfortheseNotes,shallbeobligedtoreceiveSilverorMettalMoney。

ThattheCommissionhavenotpowertocoinmorethan50000lib。

atatime,andthatnomorebecoin’dsolongasthereis25000lib。

remianingintheOffice。

ThatforayearandahalftheCommissionbelimitedtoacertainSum,afterthattimetohavepowertocoinwhatSumsaredemanded:

unlessrestrictedbyensuingParliaments。

ThatthesewhodesiretohaveMoneyfromtheCommission,giveinaNotetotheLawyersfortheCommissionaMonthbeforetheTerm,ofwhatSumstheywant,withtheRightsoftheLandstheyofferinPledge:andthatthesewhohaveNotestopayintotheCommission,givewarning10daysbeforetheTerm。

ThattheStateofCommission,theSumofNotescoin’d,theDebitandCredit,withthehighestNumberofdifferentNotes,bepublish’deveryTerm。

Thatanypersonwhoshalldiscover2NotesofthesameNumber,orofahigherNumberthanthesepublish’d,shallhavea100lib。reward。

ThattheUnder—OfficersbeinstructedwiththeSumof20000lib。

tochangeNoteswith;andthattheyattendthewholeyear。

ThatanyMemberofParliamentmayinspecttheStateoftheCommission。

ThatnoNotesbecoin’d,Moneylent,orRightsassign’dbytheCommission,butattheTermsofWhitsundayandMartinmass:Andinpresenceofatleast20Commissioners,andoneThirdoftheCommittee。

ThattheRevenueoftheCommission,overwhatpaystheCharges,andwhatparttheParliamentthinksneedfultomakegoodanyLossesmayhappentotheCommission,beapplyedbywayofDrawback,forencouragingtheExport,andManufactureoftheNation。

ThatPaper—moneydonotrisemorethan10percentabovesilvermoney;sothathewhocontractstopayinPaper,mayknowwhatheistopayincasehecannotgetPaper—Money。

TheParliamentmayenterintoaResolve,thatthenextSessionsofthisorthenextensuingParliament,theStateoftheCommissionbetakenintoConsideration,preferabletoallotherBusiness:AndiffoundhurtfultotheCountry,theParliamentmaydischargeanymoreNotestobegivenout,andorderwhatNotesarethenouttobecalledin。

Thatafter3monthsfromtheDateoftheAct,ScotsandForreignMoneybereducedtotheEnglishStandard。TheEnglishCrownto60

pence,andtheotherMoneyinProportiontoitsvalueofSilver。The40penceto38pence,thenewMarkto13pence1/12theoldMarktoitsWeight,theDucatdownsto68pence。DollarstotheirWeight。

Guineasnottopass22sh。

Thatafter4MonthsnoScotsMoney,(exceptwhatshallbecoin’daftertheAct)noranyForreignMoneyexcepttheEnglishMoney,bereceivedinanypayments,orbesoldasBullionbutattheMint。

ThatforwhatoldMoneyorBullionisbroughttotheMint,theMintreturntothefullvalueinnewMoneyof12pence,6pence,and3

pencePieces;ofelevenDeniresfine,the12penceof3Drops3Grainsweight,theotherPiecestoweighinproportion:TheExpenseofCoinagetobepayedoutoftheFundsappropriattothatuse。

Thatfor3Months,aftertheAct,thenewMoneypassfor13

pence,6pencehalf—penny,and3pence1/4。

Thatafter3Months,BullionandwroughtPlatebeofelevenDeniresfine,and5sh。and2d。theOunceofSilver,Goldnottopass4lib。

ThePaper—moneypropos’dwillbeequalinvaluetoSilver,foritwillhaveavalueofLandpledg’d,equaltothesameSumofSilver—

money,thatitisgivenoutfor。IfanyLossesshouldhappen,one4thoftheRevenueoftheCommission,willinallappearancebemorethansufficienttomakethemgood。

ThisPaper—moneywillnotfallinvalueasSilver—moneyhasfallen,ormayfall:GoodsorMoneyfallinvalue,iftheyincreaseinQuantity,oriftheDemandlessens。ButtheCommissiongivingoutwhatSumsaredemanded,andtakingbackwhatSumsareoffer’dtobereturn’d;ThisPaper—moneywillkeepitsvalue,andtherewillalwaysbealsmuchMoneyasthereisoccasion,orimploymentfor,andnomore。

IfaContractforPaper—MoneycouldbesatisfiedbypayingthesameQuantityofSilverMoney,thanthatPaper—MoneycouldnotriseabovetheValueofSilver,andwouldfallwithit。ButasthePaperMoneyisadifferentSpeciesfromSilver,soitwillnotbelyabletoanyofthechangesSilverMoneyislyableto。

ThotheParliamentcouldgiveSilverMoneytothePeople,inalsgreatQuantityastherewereOccasion:theParliamentcouldnotjustlyknowwhatSumwouldservetheCountry,fortheDemandchanges。IftheQuantityofMoneyislessthantheDemand,theLandedManiswrong’d:

Fora100lib。thenbeingmoreValuable,willbuyagreaterQuantityoftheLandedMansGoods。IftheQuantityofMoneyisgreaterthantheDemand,theMoney’dManiswrong’d,fora100lib。thenisnotsoValuable,sowillnotbuythesameQuantityofGoodsa100lib。boughtbefore。

IftheCommissiondonotgiveoutMoneywhenitisdemanded,wheregoodSecurityisoffer’d;’tisahardshiponthePersonwhoisrefus’d,andaLosstotheCountry:ForfewifanyborrowMoneytokeepbythem;andifemploy’ditbringsaProfittotheNation,thotheEmployerloses。

IftheCommissiondidnottakebackwhatSumswereoffer’dtobereturn’d,itwereahardshipontheMoney’dMan,whohasaSumpayedhim,anddoesnotknowhowtoemployit;andtheQuantitybeinggreaterthantheDemandforit,ifwouldfallinValue。

AftertheMethodpropos’d,theQuantitybeingalwaysequaltotheDemandforit,itwillkeepitsValue,andbuythesameQuantityofGoods50yearshence,asnow:unlesstheGoodsalterintheirValue,fromanyChangeintheirQuantity,orintheDemandforthem。

SupposethisCommissionhadbeenestablisht200yearsago,Landthenat14yearsPurchase,Moneyat10percent,victualat8shil。

and4PencetheChalder,andPaperMoneytohavebeengivenoutuponLand;8shiland4penceofthatPaperMony,wouldnowhavebeenequaltoaChalderofVictual,andto8lib。6sh。and4penceSilver—money:

BecauseSilver—moneyhavingincreas’dinQuantity,morethantheDemand;andhavingbeenalter’dintheDenomination,hasfallentoone20thofthevalueithadthen。NorwouldtheLanded—manhavereceiv’dlessforhisVictual,thannow;ForthatPaper—moneywouldhavebroughthim20timestheQuantityofGoods,Silver—moneywillbuy。

LandhasamorecertainValuethanothergoods,foritdoesnotencreaseinquantity,allothergoodsmay。TheUsesofGoodsmaybedischarge,orbyCustombetakenfromthem,andgiventootherGoods:

TheuseofBreadmaybetakenfromOats,andwhollygiventoWheat:

TheuseofMoneymaybetakenfromSilver,andgiventoLand:TheuseofPlate,andtheotherusesofSilverasaMettal,maybetakenfromSilver,andgiventosomeotherMettal,orsomeMixturethatmaybemorefittedfortheseuses。Inanyofthesecases,theseGoodsloseapartoftheirvalue,proportion’dtotheusesaretakenfromthem:Butlandcannotloseanyofitsuses。ForaseverythingisproducedbyLand,sotheLandmustkeepitsvalue,becauseitcanbeturn’dtoproducetheGoodsthatareinuse。IfWheatismoreus’d,andOatsless,astheLandcanproduceboth,itwillbeturn’dtoproducewhatismostused,becausemostvaluable。

ThisMoneywillnotreceiveanyadditionalValuefrombeingusedasMoney,sotheReceiverwillbecertainhecanbenoloser,thoafteraTermofyearstheuseofMoneyistakenfromit。TheLandwillreceiveanadditionalValue,frombeingusedasthePledgeuponwhichtheMoneyisissued;andthatadditionalValuewouldbegreaterthanwhatSilverreceived:Because,thoLandbeusedasthePledgetoissueoutMoneyupon,yetnoneofitsotheruseswouldbetakenfromit:

Silvercannotbeus’dasMoneyandPlateatthesametime。ButasLandisingreaterQuantitythantherewillbeoccasionfortogiveoutMoneyupon;sotheadditionalValueitreceives,willnotbenearsogreatasthatSilver—Moneyhasreceiv’d。

SupposetheAdditionalValueofLandreceivedwereone4th,Landnowat20yearsPurchase,wouldthenbeat25yearsPurchase。IftheParliamentcall’dinthePaperMoney,hewhohadPaperMoneycouldbenoloserbyit,thotheLandlosttheAdditionalValue;FornomoreofitisgivenoutthantheValueoftheLandabstractfromitsUseasMoney,hewhohadSilverwouldlooseahalf,or2Thirds;SilverfallingthentoitsValueasaMettal。

SothatthisPaperMoneypropos’d,havingabetterValuethanSilver;andreceivingnoAdditiontoitsValue,frombeingusedasMoney;andnotbeinglyabletoanychangeinitsValue,theQuantityandDemandencreasinganddecreasingtogether:ItissofarmoreQualifiedtobethemeasurebywhichGoodsarevalued,theValuebywhichGoodsareExchanged,andinwhichContractsaremadepayable。

TheotherQualitiesnecessaryinMoney,Are,1。EasyofDelivery。

2。OfthesameValueinoneplacetowhatitisinanother。

3。TobekeptwithoutLossorExpense。

4。Tobedividedwithoutloss。

5。TobecapableofaStamp。

PaperMoneyhastheseQualitiesinagreaterdegreethanSilver。

1。ItiseasierofDelivery:500lib。inPapermaybepayedinlesstime,than5lib。inSilver。

2。Itisnearerthevalueinoneplacetowhatitisinanother,beingofeasiercarriage。

3。Itcanbeeasierkept;takinguplessroom。Andwithoutloss:

BecauseitmaybeExchangedattheOffice。TheConsumptionofPaperisnotofsomuchvalueastheConsumptionofSilver:TheConsumptionofthePaperisalosstotheOffice,theConsumptionofSilverisalosstotheOwner。

4。Itcanbedividedwithoutloss:BecauseitmaybechangedforlesserNotesattheOffice。

5。ItiscapableofaStamp,andlessliabletobeCounterfeit。

ThePracticeofmostTradingNationsconfirms,thatPaperismoreQualifiedfortheUseofMoney,thanSilver;providingithaveaValue。InHollandSilverispledg’d,andPaperisusedasMoney。ThatLandpledg’disabetterValuethanSilverpledg’d,isevidentfromwhathasbeensaid。InEngland,beforetheBankwassetup,Gold—

smithsNoteswerereceivedinPaymentspreferabletoGoldorSilver:

WhichshowsthatPaperMoneyhadalltheQualitiesnecessaryinMoney,somuchmorethanGoldorSilver,astoequaltheDangerofaGold—

smithsbreaking,orwhichthereweremanyExamples。Mr。Lock,pag。7thonInterestofMoney,says,thatoneGold—smith’sCredit(beingusuallyaNoteunderoneofhisServantsHands)wentforaboveElevenhundredthousandPoundsatatime。

TheNotesoftheBankinScotlandwent,thotherewasnoMoneyintheBank,andthotheirAcceptancewasvoluntary。TheSecurityforthePaperpropos’dwillbealsGood,theAdministrationmaybemoresafeandsatisfactorythanthatBank,oranyotherprivatBank;becauseitismorepublick,andtheCommissionhasnotanyshareoftheprofits。

BesidesitwillnotbeliabletotheHazardBanksareliableto,fromtheSaleofshares。

AnditseemsstrangethattheAdministrationofsuchaCommissionshouldbedoubted,whentheParliamenthastheNominationoftheManadgers;whentheManadgersaretobeaccountabletotheParliament;

whentheTrustistobesosmall,formoreNotescannotbeCoin’dsolongas25000lib。isintheOffice;aCommitteeofParliamentistobeappointedtoinspecttheManadgement,theBooksaretobeopentotheInspectionofanyMemberofParliament,andtheStateoftheCommissionistobepublishedinPrint。

SincetheNotesoftheBankwentuponavoluntaryAcceptance,thotherewasnoMoneyinBank;’tisReasonabletothinkthePaperMoneypropos’dwillatleasthavethesameCurrency:BeingCurrentbyLawdoesnotmakeitlessvaluable。HewhotookBankNotes,couldnotbesuretheBankwouldbeinaConditiontogiveMoneyforthem;andthePersonhewastopayMoneyto,mightrefusethem:Sohewasmoreuncertain,thaniftheyhadbeencurrentbyLaw。

TheSilverMoneybeingtofallbetwixt8and9percentin3

months,itisnottobesuppos’dthatSilverwillbeprefer’dtoPaperMoney;sincetheNotesoftheBank,whichisPaperuponthesameFund,wentattheordinaryInterest:AndthotheReceiverwasnotcertainoftheMoneyatthetimeitwaspromised,orthatthepersonhewasOwingtowouldreceiveit。

ItmaybeObjected,thatPaperwentbecauseSilvercouldbegotfortiwhenDemanded,oratacertaintime。

Thatwasveryreasonable,butwouldnotbesointhiscase:TheSecuritypledg’dforthatPaperMoney,wasSilver。TheSecuritypledg’dforthisPaperMoney,isLand。ThisMoneyhasnoRelationtoGoldorSilver,morethantootherGoods。Anditweremoreextravaganttosay,Iwon’ttakea100lib。inSilverfortheGoodsIsell;

becauseIamnotsureif6Monthshence,itwillbuymesuchaQuantityofWine,forWinemaygrowdearer。

4Crownswon’tbuyaGuinea,thotheywereCoin’dforthesameValue;norwon’tbuythe10thpartofGoods4Crownsbought200Yearsago,yetSilverisreceiv’dasaValue,andContractedfor,thoitsValuelessenseveryYear,andtho’tisnotperhapsworthaboveaThirdofwhat’tisgivenorContractedfor,abstractfromtheUseofMoney。

ThisPaperpropos’dwillnotonlykeepitsValue;theencreaseoftheQuantitydecreasingastheDemanddecreases:ButlikewisetheLandpledg’disalsvaluableasthePapergivenout,abstractfromitsUseasMoney,andencreasesinValue。

TheObjectionmaybemadeagainstSilverMoney,andwithgoodReason;foritfallsfasterinitsValuethanotherGoods,andmaysoonbereducedtoitsValueasaMettal。

ThePaperMoneyPropos’disequaltoitsself;buttocontinueequaltosuchaQuantityofanyotherGoods,istohaveaQualitythatnoGoodscanhave:ForthatdependsontheChangesintheseotherGoods。IthasabetterandmorecertainValuethanSilverMoney,andalltheotherQualitiesnecessaryinMoneyinamuchgreaterDegree,withotherQualitiesthatSilverhasnot,andismorecapableofbeingmadeMoneythananythingyetknown。Landiswhatismostvaluable,andwhatencreasesinValuemorethanotherGoods;sothePaperMoneyissuedfromit,willinallappearancenotonlykeepequaltootherGoods,butriseabovethem。

BecauseoftheextraordinaryscarcityofSilverinScotland,andtheInclinationPeoplehavetoit,fromitshavingbeenlongusedasMoney;ItmaybenecessarytorestrictitsPriceto5sh。and2pencetheOunce:ButitwillsoonfallfromthatvalueofPaper,ifitcomeingreaterquantityintoEurope,thanisexportedorconsum’d。

SupposeandIslandbelongingtooneman,theNumberofTennentsa100,eachTennant10inFamily,inalla1000;bythesetheIslandislabour’d,parttotheproductofCorns,therestforPasturage:

BesidestheTennentsandtheirFamilies,thereare300PoororIdle,wholivebyCharity。ThereisnotMoney,butRentsarepayedinkind,andifoneTennanthasmoreofoneProduct,andlessofanotherthanhisFamilyhasoccasionfor,heBarterswithhisNeighbour。

ThePeopleofthisIslandknownothingofManufacture;TheIslandbeingplentiful,furnishesenoughfortheirConsumption,andanOverpluswhichtheyexchangeontheContinentforCloaths,andwhatotherGoodstheywant:ButasthatOverplusisonlysufficienttomakeaReturnofsuchaquanityofGoodsastheyconsumeyearly,sotheyhavenoMagazinesoftheirownorforreignGoodstoservetheminbadyears,nornoMagazinesofArms,Ammunition,etc。fortheirdefence。

’Tispropos’dtotheProprietor,thatifaMoneywereestablish’ttopaytheWagesofLabour,the300PoormightbeimployedinmanufacturingsuchGoodsasbeforewereexportedinproduct;Andasthe1000thatlabourtheGroundwereidleonehalfoftheirtime,theymightbeimployedsoastheiradditionalLabourwouldbeequaltothatof500more,whichwouldlessentheirImportbyprovidingthemwithapartofsuchGoodsasbeforetheybroughtfromtheContinent,andraisetheirExportto3or4timesthevalueithad:ThereturnofwhichwouldfurnishthemwithgreaterQuantitiesofForreignGoodsthantheywantedforConsumption,whichmightbelaidupinMagazines。

TheMoneypropos’disafterthismanner。TheProprietortocoinpiecesofPaperfigur’dNumber1,Number2,andsoon;Number4tobeequaltoacertainmeasureofCorn。ThePoorandotherLabourerswouldbesatisfiedtotakeNumber4fortheWagesofadayslabour,provideditbesocontriv’dthatNumber4purchasethemthemeasureofCorn;

ForasthatCorncanbebarter’dwithotherGoods,soNumber4wouldpurchaseanequalvalueofanyotherGoods。

TomakeNumber4equaltothatmeasureofCorn,theProprietorcallshisTennentstogether;tellsthemforthefuture,hewillhavehisRentpayedinPaper,sorenewstheirLeafes,andwherea100

measuresofCornwaspayed,theyoblidgethemselvestopayhimNumber400。TheotherkindstheProprietorwaspayedinarevalued,accordingtotheValuetheyhadinBarterwithCorn;andLeasesmadeforPaper。

TheProprietorcoinsPapertothevalueofayearsRent,imployssuchasarewillingtowork,andgivesthemPaper—moneyasthepriceoftheirLabour。TheTennentgivesCornoranyotherGoodshehastotheLabourersforPaper—money,andtehProprietorreceivesitforhisRent。ButastheConsumptionofthelabouringManmaybesuppos’dtobeonlyequaltoNumber2;SotheTennentscannotgetthewholeSumissuedbytheProprietor,andconsequentlynotenoughttopaytheirRent。Ifthiswerenotremeeded,thelabouringMenbeingMastersoftheremainingpartofthePaper,andhavingnooccasionformoreGoodsfromtheTennents,mightraisethevalueofthePaper。Topreventthis,theProprietorcoinsagreaterQuantity,whichbringsapartofthepoorandidleoftheContinenttotheIsland,andoccasionsagreaterConsumption,wherebytheTennentsareabletopaytheirrentsinpaperascontractedfor。TheAdditiontothepeopleisanadvantagetotheIsland;foritaddstothepoweroftheIsland,andtheirlabourisworthdoublewhattheyconsume。

ThisMoneythoithasnovaluebutwhattheproprietorgivesit,byreceivingitinpaymentsofhisRent;yetitwillbeesteem’dequaltotheproductpayedbefore。

IftheProprietorwouldgiveitavalueinLand,computingafterthisManner:AnAcreofLandpaysNumber100,at20yearspurchaseworthNumber2000。AnddisponethePropertyofLandforPaperatthatValue;WhowouldnotbesatisfiedtoreceiveorcontractforthatMoney,sinceitnotonlyboughttheProduct,butthePropertyofLandatareasonableprice。

MoneyisnotthevalueforwhichGoodsareexchanged,buttheValuebywhichtheyareExchanged:TheuseofMoneyistobuyGoods,andSilverwhileMoneyisofnootheruse。

ThoSilverwereourproduct,yetitisnotsopropertobemadeMoneyasLand。Landiswhatproduceseverything,Silverisonlytheproduct。LanddoesnotincreaseordecreaseinQuantity,Silveroranyotherproductmay。SolandismorecertaininitsvaluethanSilver,oranyotherGoods。

LandiscapableofImprovement,andtheDemandforitmaybegreater;soitmaybemorevaluable。Silvercannotbesuppos’d,tobeapplyedtoanyotherUses,thanitisnowapply’dto;orthattheDemandwillencreasemorethantheQuantity。

LandcannotloseanyofitsUses,sowillnotbelessvaluable;

SilvermaylosetheUseofMoneyitisnowapply’dto,sobereduc’dtoitsValueasaMettal。

ItmaylikewiseloseapartofitsUsesasaMettal,theseUsesbeingsupply’dbyotherGoods:SolosesapartofitsValueasaMettal。ButnothingcansupplytheUsesofLand。

Landmaybeconvey’dbyPaper,andtherebyhastheotherQualitiesnecessaryinMoney,inagreaterdegreethanSilver。

LandhasotherQualitiesfittingitfortheUseofMoney,thatSilverhasnot。

Landapply’dtotheUseofMoney,doesnotloseanyoftheotherUsesitisapply’dto:SilvercannotservetheUseofMoney,andanyofitsotherUsesasaMettal。

TradeandMoneydependmutuallyononeanother;whenTradedecayes,Moneylessens;andwhenMoneylessens,Tradedecayes。PowerandWealthconsistsinNumbersofPeople,andMagazinesofHomeandForreignGoods;thesedependonTrade,andTradeonMoney。SowhileTradeandMoneymaybeaffecteddirectlyandconsequently;thatwhatishurtfultoeither,mustbesotoboth,PowerandWealthwillbeprecarious。

Fromwhenceitisevident,thatLandismoreQualifiedfortheUseofMoneythanSilver;andpreferableforthatUsethoSilverweretheProductofScotland:BeingmorecertaininitsValue,andhavingtheQualitiesnecessaryinMoney,inagreaterdegree:WithotherQualitiesthatSilverhasnot。SomorecapableofbeingthegeneralMeasurebywhichGoodsarevalued,theValuebywhichGoodsareExchanged,andinwhichContractsaretaken。

If2000lib。ofPaperMoney,isequaltothepropertyofLandworth2000lib。inSilver;thenthat2000lib。ofPaperMoney,isequalto2000lib。ofSilver。

WhatbuysLand,willbuyeverythingtheLandproduces;andwhatbuystheProductofLand,willbuyallotherGoodswhetherHomeorForreign。IfWineisbroughtfromFrance,theMerchantdesignstolayouthisMoneyonGoods,atInterest,oronLand:TheCommissiondoesnotreceiveSilverMoney,sohecannothaveaBondfromtheCommission,unlesshegivetheValueinPaper;andmanyoftheLandedMenwon’ttakeSilverfortheirGoodsorLands,havingoccasionforPapertopaytheCommission。SotheMerchantwillchoosetosellhisWinesforPaperMoney,becauseitwillpurchasehimGoods,BondsorLandswhereSilverMoneywill,beingequallyvaluable:AndincaseswhereSilverMoneywillnot。

AndthisissupposingSilverwereequallyQualifiedfortheUseofMoney,asLandis。ButasSilverisanuncertainValue,andisgivenformuchmorethanitsValueasaMettal;andhasnotalltheQualitiesnecessaryinMoney,norinsogreatadegreeasPaperMoney:

SoPaperMoneywillfortheseotherReasonsbeprefer’dtoSilver。

SomeObjectthataPaperMoneythouponagoodFund,andCurrentintheCountry;YetwillnotbevaluedAbroad,equaltowhatitwereinScotland。

TheGoodsofScotlandwillalwayesbevaluedAbroad,equaltoGoodsofthesamekindandgoodness;andthatMoneythoofPaper,whichbuysGoodsinScotland,willbuyGoodsorMoneyinotherplaces。

Ifa1000lib。inSerges,LinenCloth,etc。beworthAbroadallChargespayed1300lib。theMerchantwhoExportssuchGoods,willgiveaBillforthatMoneyatthePar,having1300lib。forwhatcosthima1000。

WhenaNationestablishesaMoney,iftheMoneytheysetup,haveaValueequaltowhatitismadeMoneyfor,andalltheotherQualitiesnecessarinMoney;theyoughttohavenoregardwhatValueitwillhaveinotherCountries。Onthecontrair,aseveryCountryendeavoursbyLawstopreservetheirMoney,ifthatPeoplecancontriveaMoneythatwillnotbevaluedAbroad;theywilldowhatotherCountrieshavebyLawsendeavour’dinvain。

NoNationkeepstoSilverbecauseitisusedinotherCountries,itisbecausetheycanfindnothingsosafeandconvenient。TradebetwixtNationsiscarriedonbyExchangeofGoods,andifoneMerchantsendsoutGoodsofalessValue,thanhebringsHome;hehasMoneyfurnish’dhimAbroad,byanotherwhobringshomeforalessValuethanhesentout:IfthereisnoMoneydueAbroad,thentheMerchantwhodesignedtoImportforagreaterValuethanheExported,isrestricted;andcanonlyImportequaltohisExport,whichisallthemanyLawstoregulateTradehavebeenendeavouring。

ItisObjectedthatweareunderanecessityofhavingGoodsfromCountrieswhowilltakenotofours。FrancedoesnotallowMoneytobeExported,noranyShiptoImportGoods,unlessFrenchGoodsareExportedfromthesamePort,totheValueoftheGoodswereImported。

ByourLawweareforbidtoExportMoney。ButasIdon’tthinktheExampleofNationsagoodanswer,Ishallendeavourtogiveabetter。

SupposeourMoneyisnotvaluedAbroad,andwehaveoccasionforGoodsfromDenmark,whotakesnoneofours。TheseGoodsbeingnecessaryhere,willbevaluedhigherthanotherGoodsthatarenotsonecessary;andtheValueofScotsGoodsSoldinotherCountries,willbecarriedtoDenmark,insuchGoodsaswillsellthere,orinForreignMoney,andthesenecessaryGoodsbebroughtHome:BecausetheTradermakesagreaterProfitbythem,thanbysuchGoodsascouldhavebeenImported,fromtheCountrywheretheGoodsExportedwereSold。

ButasthisAdditiontotheMoney,willemploythePeoplearenowIdle,andthesenowemploy’dtomoreAdvantage:SotheProductwillbeencreas’d,andManufactureadvanc’d。IftheConsumptionoftheNationcontinueasnow,theExportwillbegreater,andaBallanceduetous:

AndastheExchangedependsontheBallance,soPaperMoneyhere,willbeequaltoagreaterQuantityofSilverMoneyAbroad。

SupposetheyearlyValueofScotlandaMillionandahalf,theyearlyValueofEngland40Millions;theValueofScotland,isonlyaboutone28thpartoftheValueofEngland。YettheQuantityandQualityoftheLands,andtheNumbersofPeopleconsider’d;Scotlandwillbeatleastasoneto6。AndiftherewasMoneytoemploythePeople,wewouldbeasoneto6;forwehaveAdvantagespeculiartous,thatdomorethanequalthePlantationandEast—IndiaTrades。

Englandisnotimprov’dsofarasitmightbe,byagreaterQuantityofMoney。WemayhaveMoneyequaltotheDemand,byapplyingourLandtothatUse。Soourcountrymaybeimprov’dabovetheproportionofoneto6。Butifthepropos’dAdditiontoourMoney,improvedtheCountryonlysoastobearaproportionwithEnglandofoneto13,ouryearlyValuewouldbe3Millions:AndourConsumptionnotbeinghalfwhatthesameNumberofPeopleconsumeinEngland;iftheConsumptioncontinuedasnow,theBallanceduetoScotlandwouldbegreater,thantheBallanceduetoEngland。

ThisAdditiontoourYearlyvaluemaybethoughtbysomePeople,aSuppositionthat’sextravagant,butIdesirethesepeoplewillconsiderwhatConsequencestheplentyofMoneyhashadinotherplaces。AstheMoneyofEnglandhasincreas’d,theyearlyValuehasincreas’d;andastheMoneyhasdecreas’d,theyearlyvaluehasdecreas’d。

Idon’tdoubtthatthePaper—moneypropos’dbeinggivenoutequaltotheDemand,wouldbringtheyearlyvalueofScotlandto3Millions,thotheFishingandotherBranchesofforreignTrade(whichmightbeimprov’dtogreatadvantage)wereneglected。Butsupposetheyearlyvalueincreas’donlyhalfaMillion,ofwhicha4thspentinagreaterConsumptionoftheProductandManufactureoftheCountry,a4thinthegreaterConsumptionofForreignGoodsandExpenseabroad,a4thlaidupinMagazinesofForreignGoods,a4thwouldstillbedueofBallanceandbroughthomeinSilver。

IftheConsumptionandExpenseincreas’dequalto,orbeyondtheImprovement;asthePaper—moneycouldnotbeexported,sothepeoplewouldnotbesetidle,northeManufacturedecay:ThatMoneybeinglikeanEstateintail’d。Wemightcontinuetoconsumeequaltotheyearlyvalue,butcouldnotlessentheyearlyvalue,norbepooreifwecould。

IfagreatervalueofGoodswasimportedthanwasexported,andCreditgivenfortheBallance;forreignerstopaythemselves,wouldsendalesservalueofGoodstheyearafter。ButsuchRestrictionsmaybeputontheConsumptionofourownandforreignGoods,asmaymakeaBallancedue。

TheRevenueoftheCommissionwillbeagreathelptowardtheadvancingourTradeinitsInfancy:WhatincouragestheExportofGoods,incouragestheManufactureofthem;AndtheMoneygivenasaDraw—back,willnotonlyencouragetheExportandManufacture;butlikewiseregaintheReputationourGoodshavelost,andgivethemabetterReputationthantheGoodsofotherNations。

TheDraw—backoughtnottobegiventoallGoods,butsosuchasdonotyieldareasonableProfitAbroad;anduponconditiontheyarefoundsufficient。

TheSealoftheOfficeofDraw—backoughttobeapply’dtothesegoodsthatreceivetheDraw—bakc;andtheseintrustdwiththeDraw—

bakc,shouldgivesecuritytopaythepriceofsuchGoods,withallcharges,iffoundinsufficient。

WhenManufactureandTradeprospers,thelandedMansRentiswellpayed,andincreases:Whentheydecay,hisRentisillpay’d,anddecreases,aDrawbackissoeffectualaway,toencourageandpromoteManufactureandTrade;ThatitwerethelandedMensinteresttoTaxthemselves,ratherthanaDraw—backshouldnotbegiven,whereitisnecessary。

ADraw—backismorenecessaryherethaninotherCountries,forwedonotmanufacturesowellasotherNations:WearenotabletosellforthesameProfit,ourStocksbeingmuchsmaller;AndtheGoodsofotherNationswillbepreferr’dtoours,becauseourGoodsaresuspected。

SomeobjectthatthisProposalisnew,andhasnotbeenpractis’dinanyNation。

TheExampleofanotherNationoughtnottodetermineus,tofollowthesamemeasures,withoutexaminingwhetherthatNationwasthebetterortheworsebysuchmeasures;andwhetherourCircumstancesandtheirsdon’tdifferso,astomakethathurfulorineffectualtous,whichwasofadvantagetothem。ontheotherhand,itisnoArgumentagainstanythingpropos’dforthegeneralgood,tosayitisnew,andwhathasnotbeenpractis’d。

Whenanythingpropos’dhasbeenalreadypractis’dbyotherNations,’tisaPresumptioninfavoursofsuchaProposal;andit’saPresumptionagainstit,ifithasbeenrefused:ButawiseNationoughtnottobedeterminedbyExample,tofolloworrefusewithoutexamining。

ThisProposalhasnotbeenrefus’d。Theessentialpartisnowpractis’dinFrance,forPaperiscurrentbyLaw:Andthoafteramannerthatinallappearanceoughttohavehindreditscurrency,yetI’minform’dforreignBillsareboughtwithPapermoney,thesameaswithSilverorGold。

TheExampleofNationsinrelationtoMoneywouldbeaveryuncertainRule。Forashasbeensaidpage35,oppositemeasureshavebeenus’dinsomeCountriestowhathavebeenusedinothers,andcontrarymeasureshavebeenusedinthesameCountriestowhatwasusedimmediatelybefore,notbecauseofanydifferenceintheirCircumstances,butfromtheOpinion,thatsincetheMethodusedhadnottheeffectdesign’d,acontrarywould;AndtherearegoodReasonstothinkthattheNatureofMoneyisnotyetrightlyunderstood。

AnyotherObjectionsthatIhaveyetheardagainstthisProposal,aresuchasmaybefullyanswered,andsofarasIcanseeintoit,withalltheApplicationIhavebeencapableof,IcannotfindanyObjectionbutwhatmaybefullyanswer’d;noranydifficultyintheExecution,butwhatmayberemoved:IfthereisanyFallacyinthePositionIlaydown,oranywrongConsequencesdrawnfromthesePositions,Ihavenotbeenabletodiscoverthem。

Chapter8

ThelowConditionthisCountryisreducedto,notwithstandingitsnaturalAdvantages。

ThenaturalAdvantagestheDutchhaveforTrade,are,theirSituationattheMouthsoftheRiversofGermany,andbeingnearthebulkyTrade。

TheirnaturalDisadvantagesare,smalnessofTerritory,barrennessofSoil,producinglittlebutwhat’sforc’t;wantofMines;

longWinters;unwholsomeAir;Marishy,sooblig’dtogreatExpenseforFundationtotheirBuildings,inmakingandkeepinguptheHigh—ways,andindrainingtheCountryyearly;adangerousCoast;difficultEntrytotheirRivers;theSeatodefendagainstononeside,andpowerfulNeighboursontheother;andheavyTaxes,theConsequenceoftheseotherDisadvantages。

Yettheyhavesoimprov’dtheirfewAdvantages,thattheyarebecomearichandpowerfulPeople。WhathascontributtotheirRichesandPower,wastheearlyProtectionandFavourtheGovernmentgavetoTrade;theLibertywasgiventoPeopleofdifferentReligions;thefreedomofTradeallowedtoStrangers;theExampleoftheirRulerstoOEconomy;butchieflytheneglectofTradeinothercountries,particularlyinSpain,whoforc’tthePeopleandTradeofFlanderstoHolland。

ScotlandhasbyNaturemanyAdvantagesforTrade;alargeTerritory;ofeasiedefence;plentyofPeople;awholsomeAir;Mines;

aproperSituationfortheEasternandWesternTrades;nearthebulkyTrade;asafeCoast;RiversofeasieEntry;theSeasandRiversstocktwithFish。

ButNumbersofPeople,thegreatestRichesofotherNations,areaburdentous;theLandisnotimprov’d,theProductisnotmanufactur’d;theFishing,andotherAdvantagesforforreignTradeareneglected:andtheReasongenerallygivenis,thatLazinessandwantofHonestyarenaturaltous。

IfwantofHonestyandLazinesswereNatural,theywouldbesotoMankind;orifpeculiartoaPeople,thiswouldbesototheDutchratherthantous:TheAirofHollandisgrosserwhichinclinestoLaziness;andtheCountrynotproducingwherewithtomaintaintheInhabitants,wouldforcethemtoRoborCheattheirNeighbours,oroneanother。ButitismoreReasonabletothinkLazinessandwantofHonestyareVices,theconsequencesofPoverty;andPovertytheconsequenceofafaultyAdministration。IfthesamemeasureshadbeentakeninScotlandforencouragingTrade,aswastakeninHolland,wehadbeenamorePowerfulandRicherNationthanHolland。IfSpain,FranceandBrittain,oranyoneofthemhadapply’dtoTrade,alsearly,anduponthesamemeasuresHollanddid;HollandwouldnothavebeenInhabit。ButbytheirearlyApplication,andthewrongmeasuresofotherCountries,theyhavegotsuchgreatMagazinesofwhatsnecessarfortheirmaintenanceandDefence;ofRichCommoditiestoselltootherNations,ofmaterialsforShipping,etc。andsuchaQuantityofSilver,esteem’daboveitsvalueasMettalbybeingusedasMoney:ThatinallappearancesolongasSilverisusedasMoney,thegreatQuantitytheyhaveofit,withtheirgreatOeconomy,enablingthemtounder—sellotherNations:TheywillmaintaintheRangtheyholdinTrade,andconsequentlyinPower;notwithstandingthenaturalDisadvantages,thepresentApplication,andnaturalAdvantagesofotherNations。

ThisCountryismorecapableofanextendedTradethananyotherCountryofEurope,yetitisreduc’dtoaverylowstate。Tradeisruin’d;thenationalStockiswasted;thePeopleforsaketheCountry;

theRentsofLandareunpay’d;HousesinTowns,andFarmsintheCountryarethrownupontheOwnersHands;theCreditorcannothavetheInterestofhisMoneytoLiveupon;andtheDebitorsPersonandEstateareexpos’dtotheLaw。

TheLandedMan,byhavingengadgedhisPersonandEstateforthePaymentofaSpecies,whichisnotinhispowertoperform;andhavingnoAlternative:BytheLawhisPersonisatthemercyoftheCreditor,andhisEstatetobeSoldforsomuchofthatSpeciesasitwillyield。If2or3Money’dMencallintheirMoney,withadesigntoforcetheirDebitorstopartwiththeirEstates,atwhatPricestheypleasetoimpose:TheymaybringthePriceofLandto15or10YearsPurchase。FortheywouldnottakeBondsinPayment,andfewornonewouldbeinaconditiontobuywithMoney。

IfVictualshouldprovescarce,aswehavenotGoodsorMoneyforanyValuetosendoutforCorns;soonlyapartofthePeoplecouldbemaintained:ThebetterpartwouldhaveBread,butthemorenecessarypart,theLabouringMenwouldbeforc’ttoleavetheCountry,ortostarveinit。NowwouldtheyfarebetterinEngland;forasthescarcityofMoneyhassetIdlemanyofthePeopleofEngland,sotherearemorealreadythanthereisEmploymentfor:AndourPeople,atleastmanyofthem,wouldmeetthesamefatetheyhadendeavouredtoevite。

TheLandedMenwouldwantPeopletoLabourtheGround;theywouldperhapsgetFoodandCloathingforthemselvesandFamilies,butthesetheywereOwingto,inallappearance,wouldgetnothing:Forthecasebeinggeneral,andtheLandedMenthestrongerparty;theywouldnotsuffertheirLibertyandEstatestobetakenfromthem。ButthotheLawcouldbeputinExecution,andtheEstatesoftheLandedMenwereputtoSale;astherewouldbefewPurchasers,thepriceofLandwouldfallverylow。SupposetheLandwereSoldorgivenamongtheCreditorsfor15Yearspurchase,orless;itwouldbesoldformorethanitwereworth,fortheywouldnotfindPeopletoLabourit:Somanywouldbesufferers,andnonegainers。

Ifneitherofthesecaseshappen;yetthisCountrycannotwellsubsistinthecondition’tisin:IfthisOpportunityisneglected,ifwrongorineffectualmeasuresaretaken,inallappearancewewillbeinconfusionbeforewehaveanotherOpportunity。

ToraiseorallaytheMoney,toCointhePlate,orregulateTrade,areoffer’dasmeasurestosupplythewantofMoney:And’tisthoughtanyoneofthemwillbringusoutofourDifficulties。WhentheycometobeExamin’d,raisingorallayingtheMoneywillbefoundnohelpbutahurttotheCountry,whateverourCircumstancesare。Theothersmayproveineffectual。

’TisthoughtourImportandExpenseAbroadthislastyearexceedourExportbyaveryconsiderableSum,sotomaketheBallanceequalwemustnotonlyretrenchequaltotheMoneywassentoutlastYear;

butlikewisesomuchmoreasthewantofthatMoney,andoftheAdditiontotheBankmadetoourMoney,andoftheAdditiontheBankmadetoourMoneymayhavelessen’dtheyearlyValue。Sotho’tispossiblethatCoiningthePlateandRegulatingTrademaybringtheBallancetoourside,yet’tistobefear’dtheConsequenceswillshowthatitisnotverypracticable;forthatandotherReasonsalreadygiven,Pag。56,and180。Howevertheymayassist,butinregulatingourImport,regardoughttobehadthatthesaleofourGoodsAbroadbenowayhindered,forifthatisnottakencareof,weshalllosemoreforwantofMarket,thanweshallsavebyImportingless。AndthoallnecessaryCarebetaken,yettheAssistancemayReasonablybeExpectedfromthesemeasures,willnotrelieveus;theymaykeepuslingeringinthestateweare,expos’dtoConfusionatHome,andtoInsultsfromAbroad。

MostPeoplethinkscarcityofMoneyisonlytheConsequenceofaBallancedue;but’tistheCausealswellastheConsequence,andtheeffectualwaytobringtheBallancetoourside,istoaddtotheMoney。

Ourpoorhavebeencomputed200000,ourPeoplewerethenmorethannow,butourPoormaybealsmanyasthen;Supposeonly100000,andbytheAdditiontoourMoney50000ofthemwereimployed,andonlyforonehalfoftheyear,theirLabourtobepayed3pence,andworth3pencemoretotheImployer,theirConsumptionapennymorethannow:

Theyearlyvalueofthenationwouldbeincreas’dbysuchLabour208333lib。6sh。and8pence。

IftheCountryPeopleaboutPerthandStirling,havetothevalueof20000l。ofLinen,Serges,andotherManufacturemorethanisbroughtup;thotheseGoodsexportedwillyield20or30percentprofit,yettheOwnerscan’texportthem,theGoodsbeinginsomanydifferntHands,andnothavingCorrespondentsAbroadtowhomtheycouldtrusttheSaleofthem。A。B。andC。aresatisfiedforthatProfittotaketheTroubleandHazardofexportingthem,butMoneybeingscarcetheycannotgetanytoborrow,thotheirSecuritybegood;NorcannotwellhaveCreditfortheGoodsfromsomanydifferentPeopletheyareStrangersto。IftheycouldhaveCreditforthem,yettheseCountryPeoplemustbeidleAbroad。SoforwantofMoneytoExchangeby,Goodsfallinvalue,andManufacturedecays。

ItcannotwellbeknownwhatSumwillservetheOccasionsoftheNation,forasManufactureandTradeadvance,theDemandforMoneywillincrease;butthemanyPoorwehavealwayshad,isagreatPresumptionwehaveneverhadMoneyenough。

Englandhasbeencomputedtohavehad14MillionsinGoldandSilver,andatthesametimehadPaper—moneyforagreatSum;YetEnglandneverhadMoneyenoughtoimploythePeople:50MillionwouldimproveEnglandsofarasitiscapableofImprovement。IfallthePeoplewerethenimployedandtothebestadvantage,moreMoneywouldbringmorePeoplefromotherCountries。TheProvinceofHollandbyagreatQuantityofMoney,andNumbersofPeopletheconsequenceofmuchMoney,isabletobearashareintheWarsofEurope,equaltomanytimesthesameNumberofAcresofbetterLandinEngland;yetHollandhasnottheadvantagesforTradethatEnglandhas。SothatCountrythatcanhaveMoneyequaltoDemand,willbemorepowerfulthananyotherCountrywiththesameAdvantages,whoseMoneyislessthantheDemand。

IfMoneyweregiventoaPeopleingreaterQuantitythantherewasaDemandfor,Moneywouldfallinitsvalue;butifonlygivenequaltotheDemand,itwillnotfallinvalue。

Atpresentperhaps3or400000libismorethanthereisaDemandfor;butasTradeandManufactureincrease,theDemandforMoneywillbegreater。

WhatIhavepropos’dtosupplytheCountrywithMoney,maybereduc’dtothis。IfanEstateofa100l。Rentisworth2000l。inSilver—money,andthisEstatecanbeconvey’dbyPaper,andthisPaperbecapableofbeingdivided;thenthatEstatemaybemadecurrentMoneyfor2000lib。andanypersonwhoreceivessuchPaper—money,receivesavalueequaltothesameSumofSilver—money,asSilverisvaluednow。Ifitiscoin’dfor15yearspurchase,thenthatPaper—

moneywillbemorevaluablethanSilver,for1500lib。inthatPaperwillpurchaseLandworth2000lib。Silver—money。Ifitiscoin’dfor25yearspurchase,thenthatpaper—moneywillnotbesovaluableasSilver,for2000lib。inSilverwillbuyalsmuchLandas2500lib。inPaper。

SinceitisverypracticabletomakeLandMoney,itwouldbecontrairtoReasontolimittheIndustryofthePeople,bymakingitdependonaSpeciesisnotinourpower,butinthepowerofourEnemies;whenwehaveaSpeciesofourowneverywaymorequalified。

AndconsideringthestateofthisCountryfromthegreatscarcityofMoney;thattheValueofLandsfall,Rentsareunpayed,FarmsarethrownupontheMastersHand,andtheDebitorsPersonandEstateexpos’dtotheLaw,beingengadg’dtopayaSpeciesofwhichthereisscarceanyintheNation。

2。TheHazardtheMoney’dManisinfromtheuncertaintyoftheValueofMoney,andthedangerofConfusioninwhichcasetheMoney’dManmayloseall。

3。ThelowstateofTrade,thatmanyofthePeoplewhodependedonTradeandLiv’dwell,arestarvingorforc’tAbroad。

4。ThattheotherdegreesofthePeoplesufferinproportion。

5。ThattheNationinthisConditionmayrunintoConfusion,andisexpos’dtoitsEnemies。

ConsideringtheBenefittheNationwillhavebythisAdditiontotheMoney;ThattheLandwillbeimprov’dsobemorevaluable,Rentsbewellpayed,andthatDebitorsbypayingaValueequaltowhatisContractedfor,mayfreetheirPersonsandEstatesfromthedangertheyarenowexposedto。

2。ThattheMoney’dManwillreceivepunctualPayment,inaMoneyofamorecertainValuethanSilveroranyotherGoods,andbeinnodangerofConfusion。

3。ThatTradewillFlourish,andthesewhodependonitbeEncouraged。

4。ThattheConditionoftheotherDegreesofthePeoplewillbebetter’d。

5。ThattheNationwillbeabletomaintainitsselfinOrder,andresistitsEnemies。

TheseReasonsconsider’d,theQuestionthenwillbe,WhetherwewillImprovetheCountryalsmuchasitiscapable,withoutbeingatanyExpenseforaMeasureofTrade,orcontinueasweareinhopesofSilverfromotherNations。

ItwillbeagreatAdvantagetothisNation,thatbytheRegisterwearecapableofputtingthisProposalinExecution,andenjoyingtheBenefitofit;whenotherNations,thotheyresolv’duponit,wouldforsomeyearsbeincapableofit。ThoforthegeneralGoodofEuropeitweretobewith’tEnglandwerealscapableofitasweare。

IhavenothadtimetoputmyThoughtsinthatOrdertheyoughttohavebeen,andamforc’ttoleaveoutAnswersIdesign’dtohavegiventosomeObjectionsIhaveheardmadeagainstthisProposal;ButiftheParliamentthinkGoodtoenterupontheConsiderationofit,I

don’tdoubtbutitmaybemadeappeartobeofgreatandcertainAdvantage;thatitcannotpossiblybeanywayhurtfultothecountryingeneral,andthatitmaybesoOrdered,asnottobehurtfultoanyPerson,butonthecontrair。

ERRATA,Page49。Line8。latereadTale。

Page74。l。183。read30。

Page83。l。2raised,readrated。

Pag。116ParI。lastLinefor208333lib。read189583lib。