第1章

translatedbyBenjaminJowett

TIMAEUSPERSONSOFTHEDIALOGUE:SOCRATES;CRITIAS;TIMAEUS;HERMOCRATES

Socrates。One,two,three;butwhere,mydearTimaeus,isthefourth

ofthosewhowereyesterdaymyguestsandaretobemyentertainers

to—day?

Timaeus。Hehasbeentakenill,Socrates;forhewouldnotwillingly

havebeenabsentfromthisgathering。

Soc。Then,ifheisnotcoming,youandthetwoothersmustsupply

hisplace。

Tim。Certainly,andwewilldoallthatwecan;havingbeen

handsomelyentertainedbyyouyesterday,thoseofuswhoremainshould

beonlytoogladtoreturnyourhospitality。

Soc。DoyourememberwhatwerethepointsofwhichIrequiredyouto

speak?

Tim。Weremembersomeofthem,andyouwillbeheretoremindus

ofanythingwhichwehaveforgotten:orrather,ifwearenot

troublingyou,willyoubrieflyrecapitulatethewhole,andthenthe

particularswillbemorefirmlyfixedinourmemories?

Soc。TobesureIwill:thechiefthemeofmyyesterday’s

discoursewastheState—howconstitutedandofwhatcitizens

composeditwouldseemlikelytobemostperfect。

Tim。Yes,Socrates;andwhatyousaidofitwasverymuchtoour

mind。

Soc。Didwenotbeginbyseparatingthehusbandmenandthe

artisansfromtheclassofdefendersoftheState?

Tim。Yes。

Soc。Andwhenwehadgiventoeachonethatsingleemploymentand

particularartwhichwassuitedtohisnature,wespokeofthosewho

wereintendedtobeourwarriors,andsaidthattheyweretobe

guardiansofthecityagainstattacksfromwithinaswellasfrom

without,andtohavenootheremployment;theyweretobemerciful

injudgingtheirsubjects,ofwhomtheywerebynaturefriends,but

fiercetotheirenemies,whentheycameacrosstheminbattle。

Tim。Exactly。

Soc。Wesaid,ifIamnotmistaken,thattheguardiansshouldbe

giftedwithatemperamentinahighdegreebothpassionateand

philosophical;andthatthentheywouldbeastheyoughttobe,gentle

totheirfriendsandfiercewiththeirenemies。

Tim。Certainly。

Soc。Andwhatdidwesayoftheireducation?Weretheynottobe

trainedingymnastic,andmusic,andallothersortsofknowledge

whichwereproperforthem?

Tim。Verytrue。

Soc。Andbeingthustrainedtheywerenottoconsidergoldorsilver

oranythingelsetobetheirownprivateproperty;theyweretobe

likehiredtroops,receivingpayforkeepingguardfromthosewhowere

protectedbythem—thepaywastobenomorethanwouldsufficeformen

ofsimplelife;andtheyweretospendincommon,andtolivetogether

inthecontinualpracticeofvirtue,whichwastobetheirsole

pursuit。

Tim。Thatwasalsosaid。

Soc。Neitherdidweforgetthewomen;ofwhomwedeclared,that

theirnaturesshouldbeassimilatedandbroughtintoharmonywith

thoseofthemen,andthatcommonpursuitsshouldbeassignedto

thembothintimeofwarandintheirordinarylife。

Tim。That,again,wasasyousay。

Soc。Andwhatabouttheprocreationofchildren?Orrathernotthe

proposaltoosingulartobeforgotten?forallwivesandchildrenwere

tobeincommon,totheintentthatnooneshouldeverknowhisown

child,buttheyweretoimaginethattheywereallonefamily;those

whowerewithinasuitablelimitofageweretobebrothersand

sisters,thosewhowereofaneldergenerationparentsand

grandparents,andthoseofayoungerchildrenandgrandchildren。

Tim。Yes,andtheproposaliseasytoremember,asyousay。

Soc。Anddoyoualsorememberhow,withaviewofsecuringasfaras

wecouldthebestbreed,wesaidthatthechiefmagistrates,male

andfemale,shouldcontrivesecretly,bytheuseofcertainlots,so

toarrangethenuptialmeeting,thatthebadofeithersexandthe

goodofeithersexmightpairwiththeirlike;andtherewastobe

noquarrellingonthisaccount,fortheywouldimaginethatthe

unionwasamereaccident,andwastobeattributedtothelot?

Tim。Iremember。

Soc。Andyourememberhowwesaidthatthechildrenofthegood

parentsweretobeeducated,andthechildrenofthebadsecretly

dispersedamongtheinferiorcitizens;andwhiletheywereallgrowing

uptherulersweretobeonthelook—out,andtobringupfrombelow

intheirturnthosewhowereworthy,andthoseamongthemselveswho

wereunworthyweretotaketheplacesofthosewhocameup?

Tim。True。

Soc。ThenhaveInowgivenyoualltheheadsofouryesterday’s

discussion?Oristhereanythingmore,mydearTimaeus,whichhasbeen

omitted?

Tim。Nothing,Socrates;itwasjustasyouhavesaid。

Soc。Ishouldlike,beforeproceedingfurther,totellyouhowI

feelabouttheStatewhichwehavedescribed。Imightcomparemyself

toapersonwho,onbeholdingbeautifulanimalseithercreatedby

thepainter’sart,or,betterstill,alivebutatrest,isseizedwith

adesireofseeingtheminmotionorengagedinsomestruggleor

conflicttowhichtheirformsappearsuited;thisismyfeeling

abouttheStatewhichwehavebeendescribing。Thereareconflicts

whichallcitiesundergo,andIshouldliketohearsomeonetellof

ourowncitycarryingonastruggleagainstherneighbours,andhow

shewentouttowarinabecomingmanner,andwhenatwarshowedby

thegreatnessofheractionsandthemagnanimityofherwordsin

dealingwithothercitiesaresultworthyofhertrainingand

education。NowI,CritiasandHermocrates,amconsciousthatI

myselfshouldneverbeabletocelebratethecityandhercitizens

inabefittingmanner,andIamnotsurprisedatmyownincapacity;to

methewonderisratherthatthepoetspresentaswellaspastare

nobetter—notthatImeantodepreciatethem;buteveryonecansee

thattheyareatribeofimitators,andwillimitatebestandmost

easilythelifeinwhichtheyhavebeenbroughtup;whilethatwhich

isbeyondtherangeofaman’seducationhefindshardtocarryoutin

action,andstillharderadequatelytorepresentinlanguage。Iam

awarethattheSophistshaveplentyofbravewordsandfair

conceits,butIamafraidthatbeingonlywanderersfromonecityto

another,andhavingneverhadhabitationsoftheirown,theymay

failintheirconceptionofphilosophersandstatesmen,andmaynot

knowwhattheydoandsayintimeofwar,whentheyarefightingor

holdingparleywiththeirenemies。Andthuspeopleofyourclassare

theonlyonesremainingwhoarefittedbynatureandeducationtotake

partatoncebothinpoliticsandphilosophy。HereisTimaeus,of

LocrisinItaly,acitywhichhasadmirablelaws,andwhoishimself

inwealthandranktheequalofanyofhisfellow—citizens;hehas

heldthemostimportantandhonourableofficesinhisownstate,

and,asIbelieve,hasscaledtheheightsofallphilosophy;and

hereisCritias,whomeveryAthenianknowstobenonoviceinthe

mattersofwhichwearespeaking;andasto,Hermocrates,Iamassured

bymanywitnessesthathisgeniusandeducationqualifyhimtotake

partinanyspeculationofthekind。AndthereforeyesterdaywhenI

sawthatyouwantedmetodescribetheformationoftheState,I

readilyassented,beingverywellaware,that,ifyouonlywould,none

werebetterqualifiedtocarrythediscussionfurther,andthatwhen

youhadengagedourcityinasuitablewar,youofallmenliving

couldbestexhibitherplayingafittingpart。WhenIhadcompletedmy

task,Iinreturnimposedthisothertaskuponyou。Youconferred

togetherandagreedtoentertainmeto—day,asIhadentertained

you,withafeastofdiscourse。HereamIinfestivearray,andnoman

canbemorereadyforthepromisedbanquet。

Her。Andwetoo,Socrates,asTimaeussays,willnotbewantingin

enthusiasm;andthereisnoexcusefornotcomplyingwithyour

request。Assoonaswearrivedyesterdayattheguest—chamberof

Critias,withwhomwearestaying,orratheronourwaythither,we

talkedthematterover,andhetoldusanancienttradition,whichI

wish,Critias,thatyouwouldrepeattoSocrates,sothathemay

helpustojudgewhetheritwillsatisfyhisrequirementsornot。

Crit。Iwill,ifTimaeus,whoisourotherpartner,approves。

Tim。Iquiteapprove。

Crit。Thenlisten,Socrates,toatalewhich,thoughstrange,is

certainlytrue,havingbeenattestedbySolon,whowasthewisestof

thesevensages。Hewasarelativeandadearfriendofmy

great—grandfather,Dropides,ashehimselfsaysinmanypassagesof

hispoems;andhetoldthestorytoCritias,mygrandfather,who

rememberedandrepeatedittous。Therewereofold,hesaid,great

andmarvellousactionsoftheAtheniancity,whichhavepassedinto

oblivionthroughlapseoftimeandthedestructionofmankind,andone

inparticular,greaterthanalltherest。Thiswewillnowrehearse。

Itwillbeafittingmonumentofourgratitudetoyou,andahymnof

praisetrueandworthyofthegoddess,onthisherdayoffestival。

Soc。Verygood。Andwhatisthisancientfamousactionofthe

Athenians,whichCritiasdeclared,ontheauthorityofSolon,tobe

notamerelegend,butanactualfact?

Crit。Iwilltellanold—worldstorywhichIheardfromanagedman;

forCritias,atthetimeoftellingit,wasashesaid,nearly

ninetyyearsofage,andIwasaboutten。Nowthedaywasthatday

oftheApaturiawhichiscalledtheRegistrationofYouth,atwhich,

accordingtocustom,ourparentsgaveprizesforrecitations,and

thepoemsofseveralpoetswererecitedbyusboys,andmanyofus

sangthepoemsofSolon,whichatthattimehadnotgoneoutof

fashion。Oneofourtribe,eitherbecausehethoughtsoortoplease

Critias,saidthatinhisjudgmentSolonwasnotonlythewisestof

men,butalsothenoblestofpoets。Theoldman,asIverywell

remember,brightenedupathearingthisandsaid,smiling:Yes,

Amynander,ifSolonhadonly,likeotherpoets,madepoetrythe

businessofhislife,andhadcompletedthetalewhichhebroughtwith

himfromEgypt,andhadnotbeencompelled,byreasonofthe

factionsandtroubleswhichhefoundstirringinhisowncountry

whenhecamehome,toattendtoothermatters,inmyopinionhe

wouldhavebeenasfamousasHomerorHesiod,oranypoet。

Andwhatwasthetaleabout,Critias?saidAmynander。

AboutthegreatestactionwhichtheAthenianseverdid,andwhich

oughttohavebeenthemostfamous,but,throughthelapseoftimeand

thedestructionoftheactors,ithasnotcomedowntous。

Tellus,saidtheother,thewholestory,andhowandfromwhom

Solonheardthisveritabletradition。

Hereplied:—IntheEgyptianDelta,attheheadofwhichtheriver

Niledivides,thereisacertaindistrictwhichiscalledthedistrict

ofSais,andthegreatcityofthedistrictisalsocalledSais,and

isthecityfromwhichKingAmasiscame。Thecitizenshaveadeityfor

theirfoundress;sheiscalledintheEgyptiantongueNeith,andis

assertedbythemtobethesamewhomtheHellenescallAthene;they

aregreatloversoftheAthenians,andsaythattheyareinsomeway

relatedtothem。TothiscitycameSolon,andwasreceivedthere

withgreathonour;heaskedthepriestswhoweremostskilfulin

suchmatters,aboutantiquity,andmadethediscoverythatneither

henoranyotherHelleneknewanythingworthmentioningaboutthe

timesofold。Ononeoccasion,wishingtodrawthemontospeakof

antiquity,hebegantotellaboutthemostancientthingsinour

partoftheworld—aboutPhoroneus,whoiscalled\"thefirstman,\"

andaboutNiobe;andaftertheDeluge,ofthesurvivalofDeucalion

andPyrrha;andhetracedthegenealogyoftheirdescendants,and

reckoningupthedates,triedtocomputehowmanyyearsagotheevents

ofwhichhewasspeakinghappened。Thereupononeofthepriests,who

wasofaverygreatage,said:OSolon,Solon,youHellenesare

neveranythingbutchildren,andthereisnotanoldmanamongyou。

Soloninreturnaskedhimwhathemeant。Imeantosay,hereplied,

thatinmindyouareallyoung;thereisnooldopinionhandeddown

amongyoubyancienttradition,noranysciencewhichishoarywith

age。AndIwilltellyouwhy。Therehavebeen,andwillbeagain,many

destructionsofmankindarisingoutofmanycauses;thegreatest

havebeenbroughtaboutbytheagenciesoffireandwater,andother

lesseronesbyinnumerableothercauses。Thereisastory,which

evenyouhavepreserved,thatonceuponatimePaethon,thesonof

Helios,havingyokedthesteedsinhisfather’schariot,becausehe

wasnotabletodrivetheminthepathofhisfather,burntupall

thatwasupontheearth,andwashimselfdestroyedbyathunderbolt。

Nowthishastheformofamyth,butreallysignifiesadeclinationof

thebodiesmovingintheheavensaroundtheearth,andagreat

conflagrationofthingsupontheearth,whichrecursafterlong

intervals;atsuchtimesthosewholiveuponthemountainsandin

dryandloftyplacesaremoreliabletodestructionthanthosewho

dwellbyriversorontheseashore。AndfromthiscalamitytheNile,

whoisournever—failingsaviour,deliversandpreservesus。When,

ontheotherhand,thegodspurgetheearthwithadelugeofwater,

thesurvivorsinyourcountryareherdsmenandshepherdswhodwell

onthemountains,butthosewho,likeyou,liveincitiesare

carriedbytheriversintothesea。Whereasinthisland,neitherthen

noratanyothertime,doesthewatercomedownfromaboveonthe

fields,havingalwaysatendencytocomeupfrombelow;forwhich

reasonthetraditionspreservedherearethemostancient。

Thefactis,thatwherevertheextremityofwinterfrostorof

summerdoesnotprevent,mankindexist,sometimesingreater,

sometimesinlessernumbers。Andwhateverhappenedeitherinyour

countryorinours,orinanyotherregionofwhichweareinformed—if

therewereanyactionsnobleorgreatorinanyotherway

remarkable,theyhaveallbeenwrittendownbyusofold,andare

preservedinourtemples。Whereasjustwhenyouandothernations

arebeginningtobeprovidedwithlettersandtheotherrequisites

ofcivilizedlife,aftertheusualinterval,thestreamfromheaven,

likeapestilence,comespouringdown,andleavesonlythoseofyou

whoaredestituteoflettersandeducation;andsoyouhavetobegin

alloveragainlikechildren,andknownothingofwhathappenedin

ancienttimes,eitheramongusoramongyourselves。Asforthose

genealogiesofyourswhichyoujustnowrecountedtous,Solon,they

arenobetterthanthetalesofchildren。Inthefirstplaceyou

rememberasingledelugeonly,butthereweremanypreviousones;in

thenextplace,youdonotknowthatthereformerlydweltinyourland

thefairestandnoblestraceofmenwhicheverlived,andthatyouand

yourwholecityaredescendedfromasmallseedorremnantofthem

whichsurvived。Andthiswasunknowntoyou,because,formany

generations,thesurvivorsofthatdestructiondied,leavingno

writtenword。Fortherewasatime,Solon,beforethegreatdeluge

ofall,whenthecitywhichnowisAthenswasfirstinwarandin

everywaythebestgovernedofallcities,issaidtohaveperformed

thenoblestdeedsandtohavehadthefairestconstitutionofanyof

whichtraditiontells,underthefaceofheaven。

Solonmarvelledathiswords,andearnestlyrequestedtheprieststo

informhimexactlyandinorderabouttheseformercitizens。Youare

welcometohearaboutthem,Solon,saidthepriest,bothforyour

ownsakeandforthatofyourcity,andaboveall,forthesakeofthe

goddesswhoisthecommonpatronandparentandeducatorofbothour

cities。Shefoundedyourcityathousandyearsbeforeours,

receivingfromtheEarthandHephaestustheseedofyourrace,and

afterwardsshefoundedours,ofwhichtheconstitutionisrecorded

inoursacredregisterstobeeightthousandyearsold。Astouching

yourcitizensofninethousandyearsago,Iwillbrieflyinformyouof

theirlawsandoftheirmostfamousaction;theexactparticularsof

thewholewewillhereaftergothroughatourleisureinthesacred

registersthemselves。Ifyoucomparetheseverylawswithoursyou

willfindthatmanyofoursarethecounterpartofyoursasthey

wereintheoldentime。Inthefirstplace,thereisthecasteof

priests,whichisseparatedfromalltheothers;next,therearethe

artificers,whoplytheirseveralcraftsbythemselvesanddonot

intermix;andalsothereistheclassofshepherdsandofhunters,

aswellasthatofhusbandmen;andyouwillobserve,too,thatthe

warriorsinEgyptaredistinctfromalltheotherclasses,andare

commandedbythelawtodevotethemselvessolelytomilitarypursuits;

moreover,theweaponswhichtheycarryareshieldsandspears,astyle

ofequipmentwhichthegoddesstaughtofAsiaticsfirsttous,asin

yourpartoftheworldfirsttoyou。Thenastowisdom,doyouobserve

howourlawfromtheveryfirstmadeastudyofthewholeorderof

things,extendingeventoprophecyandmedicinewhichgiveshealth,

outofthesedivineelementsderivingwhatwasneedfulforhumanlife,

andaddingeverysortofknowledgewhichwasakintothem。Allthis

orderandarrangementthegoddessfirstimpartedtoyouwhen

establishingyourcity;andshechosethespotofearthinwhichyou

wereborn,becauseshesawthatthehappytemperamentoftheseasons

inthatlandwouldproducethewisestofmen。Whereforethegoddess,

whowasaloverbothofwarandofwisdom,selectedandfirstofall

settledthatspotwhichwasthemostlikelytoproducemenlikest

herself。Andthereyoudwelt,havingsuchlawsastheseandstill

betterones,andexcelledallmankindinallvirtue,asbecamethe

childrenanddisciplesofthegods。

Manygreatandwonderfuldeedsarerecordedofyourstateinour

histories。Butoneofthemexceedsalltherestingreatnessand

valour。Forthesehistoriestellofamightypowerwhichunprovoked

madeanexpeditionagainstthewholeofEuropeandAsia,andto

whichyourcityputanend。Thispowercameforthoutofthe

AtlanticOcean,forinthosedaystheAtlanticwasnavigable;and

therewasanislandsituatedinfrontofthestraitswhichareby

youcalledthePillarsofHeracles;theislandwaslargerthanLibya

andAsiaputtogether,andwasthewaytootherislands,andfrom

theseyoumightpasstothewholeoftheoppositecontinentwhich

surroundedthetrueocean;forthisseawhichiswithintheStraitsof

Heraclesisonlyaharbour,havinganarrowentrance,butthatother

isarealsea,andthesurroundinglandmaybemosttrulycalleda

boundlesscontinent。NowinthisislandofAtlantistherewasa

greatandwonderfulempirewhichhadruleoverthewholeislandand

severalothers,andoverpartsofthecontinent,and,furthermore,the

menofAtlantishadsubjectedthepartsofLibyawithinthecolumnsof

HeraclesasfarasEgypt,andofEuropeasfarasTyrrhenia。Thisvast

power,gatheredintoone,endeavouredtosubdueatablowour

countryandyoursandthewholeoftheregionwithinthestraits;

andthen,Solon,yourcountryshoneforth,intheexcellenceofher

virtueandstrength,amongallmankind。Shewaspre—eminentincourage

andmilitaryskill,andwastheleaderoftheHellenes。Andwhenthe

restfellofffromher,beingcompelledtostandalone,afterhaving

undergonetheveryextremityofdanger,shedefeatedandtriumphed

overtheinvaders,andpreservedfromslaverythosewhowerenotyet

subjugated,andgenerouslyliberatedalltherestofuswhodwell

withinthepillars。Butafterwardsthereoccurredviolent

earthquakesandfloods;andinasingledayandnightofmisfortune

allyourwarlikemeninabodysankintotheearth,andtheisland

ofAtlantisinlikemannerdisappearedinthedepthsofthesea。For

whichreasontheseainthosepartsisimpassableandimpenetrable,

becausethereisashoalofmudintheway;andthiswascausedbythe

subsidenceoftheisland。

Ihavetoldyoubriefly,Socrates,whattheagedCritiasheard

fromSolonandrelatedtous。Andwhenyouwerespeakingyesterday

aboutyourcityandcitizens,thetalewhichIhavejustbeen

repeatingtoyoucameintomymind,andIremarkedwithastonishment

how,bysomemysteriouscoincidence,youagreedinalmostevery

particularwiththenarrativeofSolon;butIdidnotliketospeakat

themoment。Foralongtimehadelapsed,andIhadforgottentoomuch;

IthoughtthatImustfirstofallrunoverthenarrativeinmyown

mind,andthenIwouldspeak。AndsoIreadilyassentedtoyour

requestyesterday,consideringthatinallsuchcasesthechief

difficultyistofindatalesuitabletoourpurpose,andthatwith

suchataleweshouldbefairlywellprovided。

Andtherefore,asHermocrateshastoldyou,onmywayhomeyesterday

IatoncecommunicatedthetaletomycompanionsasIrememberedit;

andafterIleftthem,duringthenightbythinkingIrecoverednearly

thewholeit。Truly,asisoftensaid,thelessonsofourchildhood

makewonderfulimpressiononourmemories;forIamnotsurethatI

couldrememberallthediscourseofyesterday,butIshouldbemuch

surprisedifIforgotanyofthesethingswhichIhaveheardverylong

ago。Ilistenedatthetimewithchildlikeinteresttotheoldman’s

narrative;hewasveryreadytoteachme,andIaskedhimagainand

againtorepeathiswords,sothatlikeanindeliblepicturetheywere

brandedintomymind。Assoonasthedaybroke,Irehearsedthemashe

spokethemtomycompanions,thatthey,aswellasmyself,might

havesomethingtosay。Andnow,Socrates,tomakeanendmypreface,I

amreadytotellyouthewholetale。Iwillgiveyounotonlythe

generalheads,buttheparticulars,astheyweretoldtome。The

cityandcitizens,whichyouyesterdaydescribedtousinfiction,

wewillnowtransfertotheworldofreality。Itshallbethe

ancientcityofAthens,andwewillsupposethatthecitizenswhomyou

imagined,wereourveritableancestors,ofwhomthepriestspoke;they

willperfectlyharmonise,andtherewillbenoinconsistencyinsaying

thatthecitizensofyourrepublicaretheseancientAthenians。Letus

dividethesubjectamongus,andallendeavouraccordingtoour

abilitygracefullytoexecutethetaskwhichyouhaveimposeduponus。

Considerthen,Socrates,ifthisnarrativeissuitedtothepurpose,

orwhetherweshouldseekforsomeotherinstead。

Soc。Andwhatother,Critias,canwefindthatwillbebetterthan

this,whichisnaturalandsuitabletothefestivalofthegoddess,

andhastheverygreatadvantageofbeingafactandnotafiction?

Howorwhereshallwefindanotherifweabandonthis?Wecannot,

andthereforeyoumusttellthetale,andgoodlucktoyou;andIin

returnformyyesterday’sdiscoursewillnowrestandbealistener。

Crit。Letmeproceedtoexplaintoyou,Socrates,theorderinwhich

wehavearrangedourentertainment。Ourintentionis,thatTimaeus,

whoisthemostofanastronomeramongstus,andhasmadethenature

oftheuniversehisspecialstudy,shouldspeakfirst,beginning

withthegenerationoftheworldandgoingdowntothecreationof

man;next,Iamtoreceivethemenwhomhehascreatedofwhomsome

willhaveprofitedbytheexcellenteducationwhichyouhavegiven

them;andthen,inaccordancewiththetaleofSolon,andequallywith

hislaw,wewillbringthemintocourtandmakethemcitizens,asif

theywerethoseveryAthenianswhomthesacredEgyptianrecordhas

recoveredfromoblivion,andthenceforwardwewillspeakofthemas

Atheniansandfellow—citizens。

Soc。IseethatIshallreceiveinmyturnaperfectandsplendid

feastofreason。Andnow,Timaeus,you,Isuppose,shouldspeak

next,afterdulycallingupontheGods。

Tim。Allmen,Socrates,whohaveanydegreeofrightfeeling,atthe

beginningofeveryenterprise,whethersmallorgreat,alwayscall

uponGod。Andwe,too,whoaregoingtodiscourseofthenatureofthe

universe,howcreatedorhowexistingwithoutcreation,ifwebenot

altogetheroutofourwits,mustinvoketheaidofGodsand

Goddessesandpraythatourwordsmaybeacceptabletothemand

consistentwiththemselves。Letthis,then,beourinvocationofthe

Gods,towhichIaddanexhortationofmyselftospeakinsuch

manneraswillbemostintelligibletoyou,andwillmostaccord

withmyownintent。

Firstthen,inmyjudgment,wemustmakeadistinctionandask,What

isthatwhichalwaysisandhasnobecoming;andwhatisthatwhichis

alwaysbecomingandneveris?Thatwhichisapprehendedby

intelligenceandreasonisalwaysinthesamestate;butthatwhichis

conceivedbyopinionwiththehelpofsensationandwithoutreason,is

alwaysinaprocessofbecomingandperishingandneverreallyis。Now

everythingthatbecomesoriscreatedmustofnecessitybecreated

bysomecause,forwithoutacausenothingcanbecreated。Theworkof

thecreator,wheneverhelookstotheunchangeableandfashionsthe

formandnatureofhisworkafteranunchangeablepattern,must

necessarilybemadefairandperfect;butwhenhelookstothecreated

only,andusesacreatedpattern,itisnotfairorperfect。Wasthe

heaventhenortheworld,whethercalledbythisorbyanyother

moreappropriatename—assumingthename,Iamaskingaquestion

whichhastobeaskedatthebeginningofanenquiryabout

anything—wastheworld,Isay,alwaysinexistenceandwithout

beginning?orcreated,andhaditabeginning?Created,Ireply,being

visibleandtangibleandhavingabody,andthereforesensible;and

allsensiblethingsareapprehendedbyopinionandsenseandarein

aprocessofcreationandcreated。Nowthatwhichiscreatedmust,

asweaffirm,ofnecessitybecreatedbyacause。Butthefatherand

makerofallthisuniverseispastfindingout;andevenifwefound

him,totellofhimtoallmenwouldbeimpossible。Andthereisstill

aquestiontobeaskedabouthim:Whichofthepatternshadthe

artificerinviewwhenhemadetheworld—thepatternofthe

unchangeable,orofthatwhichiscreated?Iftheworldbeindeedfair

andtheartificergood,itismanifestthathemusthavelookedto

thatwhichiseternal;butifwhatcannotbesaidwithoutblasphemyis

true,thentothecreatedpattern。Everyonewillseethathemust

havelookedto,theeternal;fortheworldisthefairestofcreations

andheisthebestofcauses。Andhavingbeencreatedinthisway,the

worldhasbeenframedinthelikenessofthatwhichisapprehended

byreasonandmindandisunchangeable,andmustthereforeof

necessity,ifthisisadmitted,beacopyofsomething。Nowitis

all—importantthatthebeginningofeverythingshouldbeaccording

tonature。Andinspeakingofthecopyandtheoriginalwemay

assumethatwordsareakintothematterwhichtheydescribe;when

theyrelatetothelastingandpermanentandintelligible,they

oughttobelastingandunalterable,and,asfarastheirnature

allows,irrefutableandimmovable—nothingless。Butwhenthey

expressonlythecopyorlikenessandnottheeternalthings

themselves,theyneedonlybelikelyandanalogoustothereal

words。Asbeingistobecoming,soistruthtobelief。Ifthen,

Socrates,amidthemanyopinionsaboutthegodsandthegeneration

oftheuniverse,wearenotabletogivenotionswhichare

altogetherandineveryrespectexactandconsistentwithoneanother,

donotbesurprised。Enough,ifweadduceprobabilitiesaslikelyas

anyothers;forwemustrememberthatIwhoamthespeaker,andyou

whoarethejudges,areonlymortalmen,andweoughttoacceptthe

talewhichisprobableandenquirenofurther。

Soc。Excellent,Timaeus;andwewilldopreciselyasyoubidus。The

preludeischarming,andisalreadyacceptedbyus—maywebegofyou

toproceedtothestrain?

Tim。Letmetellyouthenwhythecreatormadethisworldof

generation。Hewasgood,andthegoodcanneverhaveanyjealousyof

anything。Andbeingfreefromjealousy,hedesiredthatallthings

shouldbeaslikehimselfastheycouldbe。Thisisinthetruest

sensetheoriginofcreationandoftheworld,asweshalldowell

inbelievingonthetestimonyofwisemen:Goddesiredthatallthings

shouldbegoodandnothingbad,sofarasthiswasattainable。

Whereforealsofindingthewholevisiblespherenotatrest,but

movinginanirregularanddisorderlyfashion,outofdisorderhe

broughtorder,consideringthatthiswasineverywaybetterthan

theother。Nowthedeedsofthebestcouldneverbeorhavebeenother

thanthefairest;andthecreator,reflectingonthethingswhich

arebynaturevisible,foundthatnounintelligentcreaturetakenasa

wholewasfairerthantheintelligenttakenasawhole;andthat

intelligencecouldnotbepresentinanythingwhichwasdevoidof

soul。Forwhichreason,whenhewasframingtheuniverse,heput

intelligenceinsoul,andsoulinbody,thathemightbethecreator

ofaworkwhichwasbynaturefairestandbest。Wherefore,usingthe

languageofprobability,wemaysaythattheworldbecamealiving

creaturetrulyendowedwithsoulandintelligencebytheprovidenceof

God。

Thisbeingsupposed,letusproceedtothenextstage:Inthe

likenessofwhatanimaldidtheCreatormaketheworld?Itwouldbean

unworthythingtolikenittoanynaturewhichexistsasapart

only;fornothingcanbebeautifulwhichislikeanyimperfect

thing;butletussupposetheworldtobetheveryimageofthatwhole

ofwhichallotheranimalsbothindividuallyandintheirtribesare

portions。Fortheoriginaloftheuniversecontainsinitselfall

intelligiblebeings,justasthisworldcomprehendsusandallother

visiblecreatures。FortheDeity,intendingtomakethisworldlike

thefairestandmostperfectofintelligiblebeings,framedone

visibleanimalcomprehendingwithinitselfallotheranimalsofa

kindrednature。Arewerightinsayingthatthereisoneworld,or

thattheyaremanyandinfinite?Theremustbeoneonly,ifthe

createdcopyistoaccordwiththeoriginal。Forthatwhichincludes

allotherintelligiblecreaturescannothaveasecondorcompanion;in

thatcasetherewouldbeneedofanotherlivingbeingwhichwould

includeboth,andofwhichtheywouldbeparts,andthelikenesswould

bemoretrulysaidtoresemblenotthem,butthatotherwhichincluded

them。Inorderthenthattheworldmightbesolitary,liketheperfect

animal,thecreatormadenottwoworldsoraninfinitenumberofthem;

butthereisandeverwillbeoneonly—begottenandcreatedheaven。

Nowthatwhichiscreatedisofnecessitycorporeal,andalso

visibleandtangible。Andnothingisvisiblewherethereisnofire,

ortangiblewhichhasnosolidity,andnothingissolidwithoutearth。

WhereforealsoGodinthebeginningofcreationmadethebodyofthe

universetoconsistoffireandearth。Buttwothingscannotbe

rightlyputtogetherwithoutathird;theremustbesomebondofunion

betweenthem。Andthefairestbondisthatwhichmakesthemost

completefusionofitselfandthethingswhichitcombines;and

proportionisbestadaptedtoeffectsuchaunion。Forwheneverinany

threenumbers,whethercubeorsquare,thereisamean,whichisto

thelasttermwhatthefirsttermistoit;andagain,whenthemean

istothefirsttermasthelasttermistothemean—thenthemean

becomingfirstandlast,andthefirstandlastbothbecomingmeans,

theywillallofthemofnecessitycometobethesame,andhaving

becomethesamewithoneanotherwillbeallone。Iftheuniversal

framehadbeencreatedasurfaceonlyandhavingnodepth,asingle

meanwouldhavesufficedtobindtogetheritselfandtheother

terms;butnow,astheworldmustbesolid,andsolidbodiesare

alwayscompactednotbyonemeanbutbytwo,Godplacedwaterand

airinthemeanbetweenfireandearth,andmadethemtohavethesame

proportionsofaraswaspossible(asfireistoairsoisairto

water,andasairistowatersoiswatertoearth);andthushebound

andputtogetheravisibleandtangibleheaven。Andforthesereasons,

andoutofsuchelementswhichareinnumberfour,thebodyofthe

worldwascreated,anditwasharmonisedbyproportion,and

thereforehasthespiritoffriendship;andhavingbeenreconciled

toitself,itwasindissolublebythehandofanyotherthanthe

framer。

Nowthecreationtookupthewholeofeachofthefourelements;for

theCreatorcompoundedtheworldoutofallthefireandallthewater

andalltheairandalltheearth,leavingnopartofanyofthem

noranypowerofthemoutside。Hisintentionwas,inthefirst

place,thattheanimalshouldbeasfaraspossibleaperfectwhole

andofperfectparts:secondly,thatitshouldbeone,leavingno

remnantsoutofwhichanothersuchworldmightbecreated:andalso

thatitshouldbefreefromoldageandunaffectedbydisease。

Consideringthatifheatandcoldandotherpowerfulforceswhich

unitebodiessurroundandattackthemfromwithoutwhentheyare

unprepared,theydecomposethem,andbybringingdiseasesandold

ageuponthem,makethemwasteaway—forthiscauseandonthese

groundshemadetheworldonewhole,havingeverypartentire,and

beingthereforeperfectandnotliabletooldageanddisease。And

hegavetotheworldthefigurewhichwassuitableandalsonatural。

Nowtotheanimalwhichwastocomprehendallanimals,thatfigurewas

suitablewhichcomprehendswithinitselfallotherfigures。

Whereforehemadetheworldintheformofaglobe,roundasfroma

lathe,havingitsextremesineverydirectionequidistantfromthe

centre,themostperfectandthemostlikeitselfofallfigures;

forheconsideredthatthelikeisinfinitelyfairerthanthe

unlike。Thishefinishedoff,makingthesurfacesmoothallaroundfor

manyreasons;inthefirstplace,becausethelivingbeinghadnoneed

ofeyeswhentherewasnothingremainingoutsidehimtobeseen;nor

ofearswhentherewasnothingtobeheard;andtherewasno

surroundingatmospheretobebreathed;norwouldtherehavebeenany

useoforgansbythehelpofwhichhemightreceivehisfoodorget

ridofwhathehadalreadydigested,sincetherewasnothingwhich

wentfromhimorcameintohim:fortherewasnothingbesidehim。Of

designhewascreatedthus,hisownwasteprovidinghisownfood,

andallthathedidorsufferedtakingplaceinandbyhimself。For

theCreatorconceivedthatabeingwhichwasself—sufficientwould

befarmoreexcellentthanonewhichlackedanything;and,ashehad

noneedtotakeanythingordefendhimselfagainstanyone,the

Creatordidnotthinkitnecessarytobestowuponhimhands:norhad

heanyneedoffeet,norofthewholeapparatusofwalking;butthe

movementsuitedtohissphericalformwasassignedtohim,beingof

alltheseventhatwhichismostappropriatetomindandintelligence;

andhewasmadetomoveinthesamemannerandonthesamespot,

withinhisownlimitsrevolvinginacircle。Alltheothersixmotions

weretakenawayfromhim,andhewasmadenottopartakeoftheir

deviations。Andasthiscircularmovementrequirednofeet,the

universewascreatedwithoutlegsandwithoutfeet。

SuchwasthewholeplanoftheeternalGodaboutthegodthatwasto

be,towhomforthisreasonhegaveabody,smoothandeven,having

asurfaceineverydirectionequidistantfromthecentre,abody

entireandperfect,andformedoutofperfectbodies。Andinthe

centreheputthesoul,whichhediffusedthroughoutthebody,

makingitalsotobetheexteriorenvironmentofit;andhemadethe

universeacirclemovinginacircle,oneandsolitary,yetby

reasonofitsexcellenceabletoconversewithitself,andneeding

nootherfriendshiporacquaintance。Havingthesepurposesinview

hecreatedtheworldablessedgod。

NowGoddidnotmakethesoulafterthebody,althoughweare

speakingoftheminthisorder;forhavingbroughtthemtogetherhe

wouldneverhaveallowedthattheeldershouldberuledbythe

younger;butthisisarandommannerofspeakingwhichwehave,

becausesomehowweourselvestooareverymuchunderthedominionof

chance。Whereashemadethesoulinoriginandexcellencepriortoand

olderthanthebody,tobetherulerandmistress,ofwhomthebody

wastobethesubject。Andhemadeheroutofthefollowingelements

andonthiswise:Outoftheindivisibleandunchangeable,andalso

outofthatwhichisdivisibleandhastodowithmaterialbodies,

hecompoundedathirdandintermediatekindofessence,partakingof

thenatureofthesameandoftheother,andthiscompoundheplaced

accordinglyinameanbetweentheindivisible,andthedivisibleand

material。Hetookthethreeelementsofthesame,theother,andthe

essence,andmingledthemintooneform,compressingbyforcethe

reluctantandunsociablenatureoftheotherintothesame。Whenhe

hadmingledthemwiththeessenceandoutofthreemadeone,he

againdividedthiswholeintoasmanyportionsaswasfitting,each

portionbeingacompoundofthesame,theother,andtheessence。

Andheproceededtodivideafterthismanner:—Firstofall,hetook

awayonepartofthewhole[1],andthenheseparatedasecondpart

whichwasdoublethefirst[2],andthenhetookawayathirdpart

whichwashalfasmuchagainasthesecondandthreetimesasmuch

asthefirst[3],andthenhetookafourthpartwhichwastwiceas

muchasthesecond[4],andafifthpartwhichwasthreetimesthe

third[9],andasixthpartwhichwaseighttimesthefirst[8],anda

seventhpartwhichwastwenty—seventimesthefirst[27]。Afterthis

hefilledupthedoubleintervals[i。e。between1,2,4,8]andthe

triple[i。e。between1,3,9,27]cuttingoffyetotherportions

fromthemixtureandplacingthemintheintervals,sothatineach

intervalthereweretwokindsofmeans,theoneexceedingandexceeded

byequalpartsofitsextremes[asforexample1,4/3,2,inwhichthe

mean4/3isone—thirdof1morethan1,andone—thirdof2lessthan

2],theotherbeingthatkindofmeanwhichexceedsandisexceededby

anequalnumber。Wheretherewereintervalsof3/2andof4/3andof

9/8,madebytheconnectingtermsintheformerintervals,hefilled

upalltheintervalsof4/3withtheintervalof9/8,leavinga

fractionover;andtheintervalwhichthisfractionexpressedwasin

theratioof256to243。Andthusthewholemixtureoutofwhichhe

cuttheseportionswasallexhaustedbyhim。Thisentirecompoundhe

dividedlengthwaysintotwoparts,whichhejoinedtooneanotherat

thecentreliketheletterX,andbentthemintoacircularform,

connectingthemwiththemselvesandeachotheratthepointopposite

totheiroriginalmeeting—point;and,comprehendingthemina

uniformrevolutionuponthesameaxis,hemadetheonetheouterand

theothertheinnercircle。Nowthemotionoftheoutercirclehe

calledthemotionofthesame,andthemotionoftheinnercircle

themotionoftheotherordiverse。Themotionofthesamehe

carriedroundbythesidetotheright,andthemotionofthe

diversediagonallytotheleft。Andhegavedominiontothemotion

ofthesameandlike,forthatheleftsingleandundivided;butthe

innermotionhedividedinsixplacesandmadesevenunequalcircles

havingtheirintervalsinratiosoftwo—andthree,threeofeach,

andbadetheorbitsproceedinadirectionoppositetooneanother;

andthree[Sun,Mercury,Venus]hemadetomovewithequal

swiftness,andtheremainingfour[Moon,Saturn,Mars,Jupiter]to

movewithunequalswiftnesstothethreeandtooneanother,butin

dueproportion。

NowwhentheCreatorhadframedthesoulaccordingtohiswill,he

formedwithinherthecorporealuniverse,andbroughtthetwo

together,andunitedthemcentretocentre。Thesoul,interfused

everywherefromthecentretothecircumferenceofheaven,ofwhich

alsosheistheexternalenvelopment,herselfturninginherself,

beganadivinebeginningofneverceasingandrationallifeenduring

throughoutalltime。Thebodyofheavenisvisible,butthesoulis

invisible,andpartakesofreasonandharmony,andbeingmadebythe

bestofintellectualandeverlastingnatures,isthebestofthings

created。Andbecausesheiscomposedofthesameandoftheother

andoftheessence,thesethree,andisdividedandunitedindue

proportion,andinherrevolutionsreturnsuponherself,thesoul,

whentouchinganythingwhichhasessence,whetherdispersedinparts

orundivided,isstirredthroughallherpowers,todeclarethe

samenessordifferenceofthatthingandsomeother;andtowhat

individualsarerelated,andbywhataffected,andinwhatwayandhow

andwhen,bothintheworldofgenerationandintheworldof

immutablebeing。Andwhenreason,whichworkswithequaltruth,

whethershebeinthecircleofthediverseorofthesame—in

voicelesssilenceholdingheronwardcourseinthesphereofthe

self—moved—whenreason,Isay,ishoveringaroundthesensibleworld

andwhenthecircleofthediversealsomovingtrulyimpartsthe

intimationsofsensetothewholesoul,thenariseopinionsand

beliefssureandcertain。Butwhenreasonisconcernedwiththe

rational,andthecircleofthesamemovingsmoothlydeclaresit,then

intelligenceandknowledgearenecessarilyperfected。Andifanyone

affirmsthatinwhichthesetwoarefoundtobeotherthanthesoul,

hewillsaytheveryoppositeofthetruth。

Whenthefathercreatorsawthecreaturewhichhehadmademoving

andliving,thecreatedimageoftheeternalgods,herejoiced,andin

hisjoydeterminedtomakethecopystillmoreliketheoriginal;

andasthiswaseternal,hesoughttomaketheuniverseeternal,so

farasmightbe。Nowthenatureoftheidealbeingwaseverlasting,

buttobestowthisattributeinitsfulnessuponacreaturewas

impossible。Whereforeheresolvedtohaveamovingimageof

eternity,andwhenhesetinordertheheaven,hemadethisimage

eternalbutmovingaccordingtonumber,whileeternityitselfrestsin

unity;andthisimagewecalltime。Fortherewerenodaysand

nightsandmonthsandyearsbeforetheheavenwascreated,butwhenhe

constructedtheheavenhecreatedthemalso。Theyareallpartsof

time,andthepastandfuturearecreatedspeciesoftime,whichwe

unconsciouslybutwronglytransfertotheeternalessence;forwe

saythathe\"was,\"he\"is,\"he\"willbe,\"butthetruthisthat\"is\"

aloneisproperlyattributedtohim,andthat\"was\"and\"willbe\"only

tobespokenofbecomingintime,fortheyaremotions,butthatwhich

isimmovablythesamecannotbecomeolderoryoungerbytime,norever

didorhasbecome,orhereafterwillbe,olderoryounger,noris

subjectatalltoanyofthosestateswhichaffectmovingandsensible

thingsandofwhichgenerationisthecause。Thesearetheformsof

time,whichimitateseternityandrevolvesaccordingtoalawof

number。Moreover,whenwesaythatwhathasbecomeisbecomeand

whatbecomesisbecoming,andthatwhatwillbecomeisabouttobecome

andthatthenon—existentisnon—existent—alltheseareinaccurate

modesofexpression。Butperhapsthiswholesubjectwillbemore

suitablydiscussedonsomeotheroccasion。