第3章

Inordertoanswerouroriginalquestion,letusnow,therefore,assumeoneproposition,whichisclearfromwhatprecedes,viz.thatevenwhentheexternalobjectofperceptionhasdeparted,theimpressionsithasmadepersist,andarethemselvesobjectsofperception:and[letusassume],besides,thatweareeasilydeceivedrespectingtheoperationsofsense—perceptionwhenweareexcitedbyemotions,anddifferentpersonsaccordingtotheirdifferentemotions;forexample,thecowardwhenexcitedbyfear,theamorouspersonbyamorousdesire;sothat,withbutlittleresemblancetogoupon,theformerthinksheseeshisfoesapproaching,thelatter,thatheseestheobjectofhisdesire;andthemoredeeplyoneisundertheinfluenceoftheemotion,thelesssimilarityisrequiredtogiverisetotheseillusoryimpressions.

Thustoo,bothinfitsofanger,andalsoinallstatesofappetite,allmenbecomeeasilydeceived,andmoresothemoretheiremotionsareexcited.Thisisthereasontoowhypersonsinthedeliriumoffeversometimesthinktheyseeanimalsontheirchamberwalls,anillusionarisingfromthefaintresemblancetoanimalsofthemarkingsthereonwhenputtogetherinpatterns;andthissometimescorrespondswiththeemotionalstatesofthesufferers,insuchawaythat,ifthelatterbenotveryill,theyknowwellenoughthatitisanillusion;butiftheillnessismoreseveretheyactuallymoveaccordingtotheappearances.Thecauseoftheseoccurrencesisthatthefacultyinvirtueofwhichthecontrollingsensejudgesisnotidenticalwiththatinvirtueofwhichpresentationscomebeforethemind.Aproofofthisis,thatthesunpresentsitselfasonlyafootindiameter,thoughoftensomethingelsegainsaysthepresentation.Again,whenthefingersarecrossed,theoneobject[placedbetweenthem]isfelt[bythetouch]astwo;butyetwedenythatitistwo;forsightismoreauthoritativethantouch.Yet,iftouchstoodalone,weshouldactuallyhavepronouncedtheoneobjecttobetwo.Thegroundofsuchfalsejudgementsisthatanyappearanceswhateverpresentthemselves,notonlywhenitsobjectstimulatesasense,butalsowhenthesensebyitselfaloneisstimulated,providedonlyitbestimulatedinthesamemannerasitisbytheobject.Forexample,topersonssailingpastthelandseemstomove,whenitisreallytheeyethatisbeingmovedbysomethingelse[themovingship.]

3

Fromthisitismanifestthatthestimulatorymovementsbaseduponsensoryimpressions,whetherthelatterarederivedfromexternalobjectsorfromcauseswithinthebody,presentthemselvesnotonlywhenpersonsareawake,butalsothen,whenthisaffectionwhichiscalledsleephascomeuponthem,withevengreaterimpressiveness.Forbyday,whilethesensesandtheintellectareworkingtogether,they(i.e.suchmovements)areextrudedfromconsciousnessorobscured,justasasmallerisbesidealargerfire,orassmallbesidegreatpainsorpleasures,though,assoonasthelatterhaveceased,eventhosewhicharetriflingemergeintonotice.Butbynight[i.e.insleep]owingtotheinactionoftheparticularsenses,andtheirpowerlessnesstorealizethemselves,whicharisesfromtherefluxofthehotfromtheexteriorpartstotheinterior,they[i.e.theabove\'movements\']areborneintotheheadquartersofsense—perception,andtheredisplaythemselvesasthedisturbance(ofwakinglife)subsides.Wemustsupposethat,likethelittleeddieswhicharebeingeverformedinrivers,sothesensorymovementsareeachacontinuousprocess,oftenremaininglikewhattheywerewhenfirststarted,butoften,too,brokenintootherformsbycollisionswithobstacles.This[lastmentionedpoint],moreover,givesthereasonwhynodreamsoccurinsleepimmediatelyaftermeals,ortosleeperswhoareextremelyyoung,e.g.toinfants.Theinternalmovementinsuchcasesisexcessive,owingtotheheatgeneratedfromthefood.Hence,justasinaliquid,ifonevehementlydisturbsit,sometimesnoreflectedimageappears,whileatothertimesoneappears,indeed,bututterlydistorted,soastoseemquiteunlikeitsoriginal;while,whenoncethemotionhasceased,thereflectedimagesareclearandplain;inthesamemannerduringsleepthephantasms,orresiduarymovements,whicharebaseduponthesensoryimpressions,becomesometimesquiteobliteratedbytheabovedescribedmotionwhentooviolent;whileatothertimesthesightsareindeedseen,butconfusedandweird,andthedreams[whichthenappear]areunhealthy,likethoseofpersonswhoareatrabilious,orfeverish,orintoxicatedwithwine.Forallsuchaffections,beingspirituous,causemuchcommotionanddisturbance.Insanguineousanimals,inproportionasthebloodbecomescalm,andasitspurerareseparatedfromitslesspureelements,thefactthatthemovement,basedonimpressionsderivedfromeachoftheorgansofsense,ispreservedinitsintegrity,rendersthedreamshealthy,causesa[clear]imagetopresentitself,andmakesthedreamerthink,owingtotheeffectsborneinfromtheorganofsight,thatheactuallysees,andowingtothosewhichcomefromtheorganofhearing,thathereallyhears;andsoonwiththosealsowhichproceedfromtheothersensoryorgans.Foritisowingtothefactthatthemovementwhichreachestheprimaryorganofsensecomesfromthem,thatoneevenwhenawakebelieveshimselftosee,orhear,orotherwiseperceive;justasitisfromabeliefthattheorganofsightisbeingstimulated,thoughinrealitynotsostimulated,thatwesometimeserroneouslydeclareourselvestosee,orthat,fromthefactthattouchannouncestwomovements,wethinkthattheoneobjectistwo.For,asarule,thegoverningsenseaffirmsthereportofeachparticularsense,unlessanotherparticularsense,moreauthoritative,makesacontradictoryreport.Ineverycaseanappearancepresentsitself,butwhatappearsdoesnotineverycaseseemreal,unlesswhenthedecidingfacultyisinhibited,ordoesnotmovewithitspropermotion.