第4章

Moreover,aswesaidthatdifferentmenaresubjecttoillusions,eachaccordingtothedifferentemotionpresentinhim,soitisthatthesleeper,owingtosleep,andtothemovementsthengoingoninhissensoryorgans,aswellastotheotherfactsofthesensoryprocess,[isliabletoillusion],sothatthedreampresentation,thoughbutlittlelikeit,appearsassomeactualgiventhing.Forwhenoneisasleep,inproportionasmostofthebloodsinksinwardstoitsfountain[theheart],theinternal[sensory]movements,somepotential,othersactualaccompanyitinwards.Theyaresorelated[ingeneral]that,ifanythingmovetheblood,someonesensorymovementwillemergefromit,whileifthisperishesanotherwilltakeitsplace;whiletooneanotheralsotheyarerelatedinthesamewayastheartificialfrogsinwaterwhichseverallyrise[infixedsuccesion]tothesurfaceintheorderinwhichthesalt[whichkeepsthemdown]becomesdissolved.Theresiduarymovementsarelikethese:theyarewithinthesoulpotentially,butactualizethemselvesonlywhentheimpedimenttotheirdoingsohasbeenrelaxed;andaccordingastheyarethussetfree,theybegintomoveinthebloodwhichremainsinthesensoryorgans,andwhichisnowbutscanty,whiletheypossessverisimilitudeafterthemannerofcloud—shapes,whichintheirrapidmetamorphosesonecomparesnowtohumanbeingsandamomentafterwardstocentaurs.Eachofthemishowever,ashasbeensaid,theremnantofasensoryimpressiontakenwhensensewasactualizingitself;andwhenthis,thetrueimpression,hasdeparted,itsremnantisstillimmanent,anditiscorrecttosayofit,thatthoughnotactuallyKoriskos,itislikeKoriskos.Forwhenthepersonwasactuallyperceiving,hiscontrollingandjudgingsensoryfacultydidnotcallitKoriskos,but,promptedbythis[impression],calledthegenuinepersonyonderKoriskos.Accordingly,thissensoryimpulse,which,whenactuallyperceiving,it[thecontrollingfaculty]describes(unlesscompletelyinhibitedbytheblood),itnow[indreams]whenquasi—perceiving,receivesfromthemovementspersistinginthesense—organs,andmistakesit—animpulsethatismerelylikethetrue[objective]impression—forthetrueimpressionitself,whiletheeffectofsleepissogreatthatitcausesthismistaketopassunnoticed.Accordingly,justasifafingerbeinsertedbeneaththeeyeballwithoutbeingobserved,oneobjectwillnotonlypresenttwovisualimages,butwillcreateanopinionofitsbeingtwoobjects;

whileifit[thefinger]beobserved,thepresentationwillbethesame,butthesameopinionwillnotbeformedofit;exactlysoitisinstatesofsleep:ifthesleeperperceivesthatheisasleep,andisconsciousofthesleepingstateduringwhichtheperceptioncomesbeforehismind,itpresentsitselfstill,butsomethingwithinhimspeakstothiseffect:\'theimageofKoriskospresentsitself,buttherealKoriskosisnotpresent\';foroften,whenoneisasleep,thereissomethinginconsciousnesswhichdeclaresthatwhatthenpresentsitselfisbutadream.If,however,heisnotawareofbeingasleep,thereisnothingwhichwillcontradictthetestimonyofthebarepresentation.

Thatwhatwehereurgeistrue,i.e.thattherearesuchpresentativemovementsinthesensoryorgans,anyonemayconvincehimself,ifheattendstoandtriestoremembertheaffectionsweexperiencewhensinkingintoslumberorwhenbeingawakened.Hewillsometimes,inthemomentofawakening,surprisetheimageswhichpresentthemselvestohiminsleep,andfindthattheyarereallybutmovementslurkingintheorgansofsense.Andindeedsomeveryyoungpersons,ifitisdark,thoughlookingwithwideopeneyes,seemultitudesofphantomfiguresmovingbeforethem,sothattheyoftencoveruptheirheadsinterror.

Fromallthis,then,theconclusiontobedrawnis,thatthedreamisasortofpresentation,and,moreparticularly,onewhichoccursinsleep;sincethephantomsjustmentionedarenotdreams,norisanyotheradreamwhichpresentsitselfwhenthesense—perceptionsareinastateoffreedom.Noriseverypresentationwhichoccursinsleepnecessarilyadream.Forinthefirstplace,somepersons[whenasleep]actually,inacertainway,perceivesounds,light,savour,andcontact;feebly,however,and,asitwere,remotely.Fortherehavebeencasesinwhichpersonswhileasleep,butwiththeeyespartlyopen,sawfaintlyintheirsleep(astheysupposed)thelightofalamp,andafterwards,onbeingawakened,straightwayrecognizeditastheactuallightofareallamp;while,inothercases,personswhofaintlyheardthecrowingofcocksorthebarkingofdogsidentifiedtheseclearlywiththerealsoundsassoonastheyawoke.Somepersons,too,returnanswerstoquestionsputtotheminsleep.Foritisquitepossiblethat,ofwakingorsleeping,whiletheoneispresentintheordinarysense,theotheralsoshouldbepresentinacertainway.Butnoneoftheseoccurrencesshouldbecalledadream.Norshouldthetruethoughts,asdistinctfromthemerepresentations,whichoccurinsleep[becalleddreams].Thedreamproperisapresentationbasedonthemovementofsenseimpressions,whensuchpresentationoccursduringsleep,takingsleepinthestrictsenseoftheterm.

Therearecasesofpersonswhointheirwholeliveshaveneverhadadream,whileothersdreamwhenconsiderablyadvancedinyears,havingneverdreamedbefore.Thecauseoftheirnothavingdreamsappearssomewhatlikethatwhichoperatesinthecaseofinfants,and[thatwhichoperates]immediatelyaftermeals.Itisintelligibleenoughthatnodream—presentationshouldoccurtopersonswhosenaturalconstitutionissuchthatinthemcopiousevaporationisborneupwards,which,whenbornebackdownwards,causesalargequantityofmotion.Butitisnotsurprisingthat,asageadvances,adreamshouldatlengthappeartothem.Indeed,itisinevitablethat,asachangeiswroughtintheminproportiontoageoremotionalexperience,thisreversal[fromnon—dreamingtodreaming]shouldoccuralso.