DIVISIONS
GENERALDIVISIONSOFTHEMETAPHYSICOFMORALS
I。DIVISIONOFTHEMETAPHYSICOFMORALSASASYSTEMOF
DUTIESGENERALLY。
1。Alldutiesareeitherdutiesofright,thatis,juridicalduties(officiajuris),ordutiesofvirtue,thatis,ethicalduties(officiavirtutiss。ethica)。Juridicaldutiesaresuchasmaybepromulgatedbyexternallegislation;ethicaldutiesarethoseforwhichsuchlegislationisnotpossible。Thereasonwhythelattercannotbeproperlymadethesubjectofexternallegislationisbecausetheyrelatetoanendorfinalpurpose,whichisitself,atthesametime,embracedintheseduties,andwhichitisadutyfortheindividualtohaveassuch。Butnoexternallegislationcancauseanyonetoadoptaparticularintention,ortoproposetohimselfacertainpurpose;forthisdependsuponaninternalconditionoractoftheminditself。However,externalactionsconducivetosuchamentalconditionmaybecommanded,withoutitsbeingimpliedthattheindividualwillofnecessitymakethemanendtohimself。
Butwhy,then,itmaybeasked,isthescienceofmorals,ormoralphilosophy,commonlyentitled—especiallybyCicero—thescienceofdutyandnotalsothescienceofright,sincedutiesandrightsrefertoeachother?Thereasonisthis。Weknowourownfreedom—fromwhichallmorallawsandconsequentlyallrightsaswellasalldutiesarise—onlythroughthemoralimperative,whichisanimmediateinjunctionofduty;whereastheconceptionofrightasagroundofputtingothersunderobligationhasafterwardstobedevelopedoutofit。
2。Inthedoctrineofduty,manmayandoughttoberepresentedinaccordancewiththenatureofhisfacultyoffreedom,whichisentirelysupra—sensible。Heis,therefore,toberepresentedpurelyaccordingtohishumanityasapersonalityindependentofphysicaldeterminations(homonoumenon),indistinctionfromthesamepersonasamanmodifiedwiththesedeterminations(homophenomenon)。Hencetheconceptionsofrightandendwhenreferredtoduty,inviewofthistwofoldquality,givethefollowingdivision:
DIVISIONOFTHEMETAPHYSICOFMORALSACCORDINGTOTHEOBJECTIVE
RELATIONOFTHELAWOFDUTY。
I。TheRightofHumanity。
I。JuridicalOneselfinourownperson(juridicialDutiestoordutiestowardsoneself)PerfectOthersDutyII。TheRightofMankind。
inothers(juridicaldutiestowardsothers。)
III。TheEndofHumanity。
II。EthicalOneselfinourperson(eithicaldutiesDutiestoortowardsoneself)ImperfectOthersDutyIV。TheEndofMankind。
inothers(ethicaldutiestowardsothers。)
II。DIVISIONOFTHEMETAPHYSICOFMORALSACCORDINGTORELATIONS
OFOBLIGATION。
Asthesubjectsbetweenwhomarelationofrightanddutyisapprehended—whetheritactuallyexistsornot—admitofbeingconceivedinvariousjuridicalrelationstoeachother,anotherdivisionmaybeproposedfromthispointofview,asfollows:
DIVISIONPOSSIBLEACCORDINGTOTHESUBJECTIVERELATIONOF
THOSEWHOBINDUNDEROBLIGATIONS,ANDTHOSEWHOARE
BOUNDUNDEROBLIGATIONS。
1。Thejuridicalrelationofmantobeingswhohaveneitherrightnorduty:
Vacat。Thereisnosuchrelation,forsuchbeingsareirrational,andtheyneitherputusunderobligation,norcanwebeputunderobligationbythem。
2。Thejuridicalrelationofmantobeingswhohavebothrightsandduties:
Adest。Thereissucharelation,foritistherelationofmentomen。
3。Thejuridicalrelationofmantobeingswhohaveonlydutiesandnorights:
Vacat。Thereisnosuchrelation,forsuchbeingswouldbemenwithoutjuridicalpersonality,asslavesofbondsmen。
4Thejuridicalrelationofmantoabeingwhohasonlyrightsandnoduties(God):
Vacat。Thereisnosuchrelationinmerephilosophy,becausesuchabeingisnotanobjectofpossibleexperience。
Arealrelationbetweenrightanddutyisthereforefound,inthisscheme,onlyinNo。2。ThereasonwhysuchisnotlikewisefoundinNo。4isbecauseitwouldconstituteatranscendentduty,thatis,onetowhichnocorrespondingsubjectcanbegiventhatisexternalandcapableofimposingobligation。Consequentlytherelationfromthetheoreticalpointofviewisheremerelyideal;thatis,itisarelationtoanobjectofthoughtwhichweformforourselves。Buttheconceptionofthisobjectisnotentirelyempty。Onthecontrary,itisafruitfulconceptioninrelationtoourselvesandthemaximsofourinnermorality,andthereforeinrelationtopracticegenerally。Anditisinthisbearingthatallthedutyinvolvedandpracticableforusinsuchamerelyidealrelationlies。
III。DIVISIONOFTHEMETAPHYSICOFMORALSASASYSTEMOF
DUTIESGENERALLY。
Accordingtotheconstituentprinciplesandthemethodofthesystem。
I。PrinciplesI。DutiesofRightI。PrivateRight。
II。PublicRightII。DutiesofVirtue,etc。
Andsoon,includingallthatrefersnotonlytothematerials,butalsotothearchitectonicformofascientificsystemofmorals,whenthemetaphysicalinvestigationoftheelementshascompletelytracedouttheuniversalprinciplesconstitutingthewhole。
II。MethodI。DidacticsII。AsceticsGENERALINTRODUCTIONTOTHEMETAPHYSICOFMORALS
I。THERELATIONOFTHEFACULTIESOFTHEHUMANMINDTOTHE