第2章

MORALLAWS。

Theactivefacultyofthehumanmind,asthefacultyofdesireinitswidestsense,isthepowerwhichmanhas,throughhismentalrepresentations,ofbecomingthecauseofobjectscorrespondingtotheserepresentations。Thecapacityofabeingtoactinconformitywithhisownrepresentationsiswhatconstitutesthelifeofsuchabeing。

Itistobeobserved,first,thatwithdesireoraversionthereisalwaysconnectedpleasureorpain,thesusceptibilityforwhichiscalledfeeling。Buttheconversedoesnotalwayshold;fortheremaybeapleasureconnected,notwiththedesireofanobject,butwithamerementalrepresentation,itbeingindifferentwhetheranobjectcorrespondingtotherepresentationexistornot。Andsecond,thepleasureorpainconnectedwiththeobjectofdesiredoesnotalwaysprecedetheactivityofdesire;norcanitberegardedineverycaseasthecause,butitmayaswellbetheeffectofthatactivity。Thecapacityofexperiencingpleasureorpainontheoccasionofamentalrepresentationiscalled\"feeling,\"becausepleasureandpaincontainonlywhatissubjectiveintherelationsofourmentalactivity。Theydonotinvolveanyrelationtoanobjectthatcouldpossiblyfurnishaknowledgeofitassuch;theycannotevengiveusaknowledgeofourownmentalstate。Forevensensations,*consideredapartfromthequalitieswhichattachtothemonaccountofthemodificationsofthesubject—as,forinstance,inreferencetored,sweet,andsuchlike—arereferredasconstituentelementsofknowledgetoobjects,whereaspleasureorpainfeltinconnectionwithwhatisredorsweetexpressabsolutelynothingthatisintheobject,butmerelyarelationtothesubject。Andforthereasonjuststated,pleasureandpainconsideredinthemselvescannotbemorepreciselydefined。Allthatcanbefurtherdonewithregardtothemismerelytopointoutwhatconsequencestheymayhaveincertainrelations,inordertomaketheknowledgeofthemavailablepractically。

*Thesensibilityasthefacultyofsensemaybedefinedbyreferencetothesubjectivenatureofourrepresentationsgenerally。Itistheunderstandingthatfirrefersthesubjectiverepresentationstoanobject;italonethinksanythingbymeansoftheserepresentations。

Now,thesubjectivenatureofourrepresentationsmightbeofsuchakindthattheycouldberelatedtoobjectssoastofurnishknowledgeofthem,eitherinregardtotheirformormatter—intheformerrelationbypureperception,inthelatterbysensationproper。

Inthiscase,thesense—faculty,asthecapacityforreceivingobjectiverepresentations,wouldbeproperlycalledsenseperception。Butmerementalrepresentationfromitssubjectivenaturecannot,infact,becomeaconstituentofobjectiveknowledge,becauseitcontainsmerelytherelationoftherepresentationstothesubject,andincludesnothingthatcanbeusedforattainingaknowledgeoftheobject。Inthiscase,then,thisreceptivityofthemindforsubjectiverepresentationsiscalledfeeling。Itincludestheeffectoftherepresentations,whethersensibleorintellectual,uponthesubject;anditbelongstothesensibility,althoughtherepresentationitselfmaybelongtotheunderstandingorthereason。

Thepleasurewhichisnecessarilyconnectedwiththeactivityofdesire,whentherepresentationoftheobjectdesiredaffectsthecapacityoffeeling,maybecalledpracticalpleasure。Andthisdesignationisapplicablewhetherthepleasureisthecauseortheeffectofthedesire。Ontheotherhand,thatpleasurewhichisnotnecessarilyconnectedwiththedesireofanobject,andwhich,therefore,isnotapleasureintheexistenceoftheobject,butismerelyattachedtoamentalrepresentationalone,maybecalledinactivecomplacency,ormerecontemplativepleasure。Thefeelingofthislatterkindofpleasureiswhatiscalledtaste。Hence,inasystemofpracticalphilosophy,thecontemplativepleasureoftastewillnotbediscussedasanessentialconstituentconception,butneedonlybereferredtoincidentallyorepisodically。Butasregardspracticalpleasure,itisotherwise。Forthedeterminationoftheactivityofthefacultyofdesireorappetency,whichisnecessarilyprecededbythispleasureasitscause,iswhatproperlyconstitutesdesireinthestrictsenseoftheterm。Habitualdesire,again,constitutesinclination;andtheconnectionofpleasurewiththeactivityofdesire,insofarasthisconnectionisjudgedbytheunderstandingtobevalidaccordingtoageneralruleholdinggoodatleastfortheindividual,iswhatiscalledinterest。Hence,insuchacase,thepracticalpleasureisaninterestoftheinclinationoftheindividual。Ontheotherhand,ifthepleasurecanonlyfollowaprecedingdeterminationofthefacultyofdesire,itisanintellectualpleasure,andtheinterestintheobjectmustbecalledarationalinterest;forweretheinterestsensuous,andnotbasedonlyuponpureprinciplesofreason,sensationwouldnecessarilybeconjoinedwiththepleasure,andwouldthusdeterminetheactivityofthedesire。Whereanentirelypureinterestofreasonmustbeassumed,itisnotlegitimatetointroduceintoitaninterestofinclinationsurreptitiously。However,inordertoconformsofarwiththecommonphraseology,wemayallowtheapplicationoftheterm\"inclination\"eventothatwhichcanonlybetheobjectofan\"intellectual\"pleasureinthesenseofahabitualdesirearisingfromapureinterestofreason。Butsuchinclinationwouldhavetobeviewed,notasthecause,butastheeffectoftherationalinterest;andwemightcallitthenon—sensuousorrationalinclination(propensiointellectualis)。Further,concupiscenceistobedistinguishedfromtheactivityofdesireitself,asastimulusorincitementtoitsdetermination。Itisalwaysasensuousstateofthemind,whichdoesnotitselfattaintothedefinitenessofanactofthepowerofdesire。

Theactivityofthefacultyofdesiremayproceedinaccordancewithconceptions;andinsofarastheprinciplethusdeterminingittoactionisfoundinthemind,andnotinitsobjectitconstitutesapoweractingornotactingaccordingtoliking。Insofarastheactivityisaccompaniedwiththeconsciousnessofthepoweroftheactiontoproducetheobject,itformsanactofchoice;ifthisconsciousnessisnotconjoinedwithit,theactivityiscalledawish。

Thefacultyofdesire,insofarasitsinnerprincipleofdeterminationasthegroundofitslikingorpredilectionliesinthereasonofthesubject,constitutesthewill。Thewillisthereforethefacultyofactivedesireorappetency,viewednotsomuchinrelationtotheaction—whichistherelationoftheactofchoice—asratherinrelationtotheprinciplethatdeterminesthepowerofchoicetotheaction。Ithas,initself,properlynospecialprincipleofdetermination,butinsofarasitmaydeterminethevoluntaryactofchoice,itisthepracticalreasonitself。