第1章

Thegreaterpartofmankindmaybedividedintotwoclasses;

thatofshallowthinkers,whofallshortofthetruth;andthatofabstrusethinkers,whogobeyondit。Thelatterclassarebyfarthemostrare:andImayadd,byfarthemostusefulandvaluable。Theysuggesthints,atleast,andstartdifficulties,whichtheywant,perhaps,skilltopursue;butwhichmayproducefinediscoveries,whenhandledbymenwhohaveamorejustwayofthinking。Atworst,whattheysayisuncommon;andifitshouldcostsomepainstocomprehendit,onehas,however,thepleasureofhearingsomethingthatisnew。Anauthorislittletobevalued,whotellsusnothingbutwhatwecanlearnfromeverycoffee—houseconversation。

Allpeopleofshallowthoughtareapttodecryeventhoseofsolidunderstanding,asabstrusethinkers,andmetaphysicians,andrefiners;andneverwillallowanythingtobejustwhichisbeyondtheirownweakconceptions。Therearesomecases,Iown,whereanextraordinaryrefinementaffordsastrongpresumptionoffalsehood,andwherenoreasoningistobetrustedbutwhatisnaturalandeasy。Whenamandeliberatesconcerninghisconductinanyparticularaffair,andformsschemesinpolitics,trade,oeconomy,oranybusinessinlife,heneveroughttodrawhisargumentstoofine,orconnecttoolongachainofconsequencestogether。Somethingissuretohappen,thatwilldisconcerthisreasoning,andproduceaneventdifferentfromwhatheexpected。

Butwhenwereasonupongeneralsubjects,onemayjustlyaffirm,thatourspeculationscanscarcelyeverbetoofine,providedtheybejust;andthatthedifferencebetweenacommonmanandamanofgeniusischieflyseenintheshallownessordepthoftheprinciplesuponwhichtheyproceed。Generalreasoningsseemintricate,merelybecausetheyaregeneral;norisiteasyforthebulkofmankindtodistinguish,inagreatnumberofparticulars,thatcommoncircumstanceinwhichtheyallagree,ortoextractit,pureandunmixed,fromtheothersuperfluouscircumstances。Everyjudgmentorconclusion,withthem,isparticular。Theycannotenlargetheirviewtothoseuniversalpropositions,whichcomprehendunderthemaninfinitenumberofindividuals,andincludeawholescienceinasingletheorem。

Theireyeisconfoundedwithsuchanextensiveprospect;andtheconclusions,derivedfromit,eventhoughclearlyexpressed,seemintricateandobscure。Buthoweverintricatetheymayseem,itiscertain,thatgeneralprinciples,ifjustandsound,mustalwaysprevailinthegeneralcourseofthings,thoughtheymayfailinparticularcases;anditisthechiefbusinessofphilosopherstoregardthegeneralcourseofthings。Imayadd,thatitisalsothechiefbusinessofpoliticians;especiallyinthedomesticgovernmentofthestate,wherethepublicgood,whichis,oroughttobetheirobject,dependsontheconcurrenceofamultitudeofcauses;not,asinforeignpolitics,onaccidentsandchances,andthecapricesofafewpersons。Thisthereforemakesthedifferencebetweenparticulardeliberationsandgeneralreasonings,andrenderssubtiltyandrefinementmuchmoresuitabletothelatterthantotheformer。

Ithoughtthisintroductionnecessarybeforethefollowingdiscoursesoncommerce,money,interest,balanceoftrade,&c。

where,perhaps,therewilloccursomeprincipleswhichareuncommon,andwhichmayseemtoorefinedandsubtileforsuchvulgarsubjects。Iffalse,letthemberejected:Butnooneoughttoentertainaprejudiceagainstthem,merelybecausetheyareoutofthecommonroad。

Thegreatnessofastate,andthehappinessofitssubjects,howindependentsoevertheymaybesupposedinsomerespects,arecommonlyallowedtobeinseparablewithregardtocommerce;andasprivatemenreceivegreatersecurity,inthepossessionoftheirtradeandriches,fromthepowerofthepublic,sothepublicbecomespowerfulinproportiontotheopulenceandextensivecommerceofprivatemen。Thismaximistrueingeneral;

thoughIcannotforbearthinking,thatitmaypossiblyadmitofexceptions,andthatweoftenestablishitwithtoolittlereserveandlimitation。Theremaybesomecircumstances,wherethecommerceandrichesandluxuryofindividuals,insteadofaddingstrengthtothepublic,willserveonlytothinitsarmies,anddiminishitsauthorityamongtheneighbouringnations。Manisaveryvariablebeing,andsusceptibleofmanydifferentopinions,principles,andrulesofconduct。Whatmaybetrue,whileheadherestoonewayofthinking,willbefoundfalse,whenhehasembracedanoppositesetofmannersandopinions。

Thebulkofeverystatemaybedividedintohusbandmenandmanufacturers。Theformerareemployedinthecultureoftheland;thelatterworkupthematerialsfurnishedbytheformer,intoallthecommoditieswhicharenecessaryorornamentaltohumanlife。Assoonasmenquittheirsavagestate,wheretheylivechieflybyhuntingandfishing,theymustfallintothesetwoclasses;thoughtheartsofagricultureemployatfirstthemostnumerouspartofthesociety。Timeandexperienceimprovesomuchthesearts,thatthelandmayeasilymaintainamuchgreaternumberofmen,thanthosewhoareimmediatelyemployedinitsculture,orwhofurnishthemorenecessarymanufacturestosuchasaresoemployed。

Ifthesesuperfluoushandsapplythemselvestothefinerarts,whicharecommonlydenominatedtheartsofluxury,theyaddtothehappinessofthestate;sincetheyaffordtomanytheopportunityofreceivingenjoyments,withwhichtheywouldotherwisehavebeenunacquainted。Butmaynotanotherschemebeproposedfortheemploymentofthesesuperfluoushands?Maynotthesovereignlayclaimtothem,andemploytheminfleetsandarmies,toencreasethedominionsofthestateabroad。andspreaditsfameoverdistantnations?Itiscertainthatthefewerdesiresandwantsarefoundintheproprietorsandlabourersofland,thefewerhandsdotheyemploy;andconsequentlythesuperfluitiesoftheland,insteadofmaintainingtradesmenandmanufacturers,maysupportfleetsandarmiestoamuchgreaterextent,thanwhereagreatmanyartsarerequiredtoministertotheluxuryofparticularpersons。Herethereforeseemstobeakindofoppositionbetweenthegreatnessofthestateandthehappinessofthesubject。Astateisnevergreaterthanwhenallitssuperfluoushandsareemployedintheserviceofthepublic。

Theeaseandconvenienceofprivatepersonsrequire,thatthesehandsshouldbeemployedintheirservice。Theonecanneverbesatisfied,butattheexpenceoftheother。Astheambitionofthesovereignmustentrenchontheluxuryofindividuals;sotheluxuryofindividualsmustdiminishtheforce,andchecktheambitionofthesovereign。

Noristhisreasoningmerelychimerical;butisfoundedonhistoryandexperience。TherepublicofSPARTAwascertainlymorepowerfulthananystatenowintheworld,consistingofanequalnumberofpeople;andthiswasowingentirelytothewantofcommerceandluxury。TheHELOTESwerethelabourers:TheSPARTANS

werethesoldiersorgentlemen。Itisevident,thatthelabouroftheHELOTEScouldnothavemaintainedsogreatanumberofSPARTANS,hadtheselatterlivedineaseanddelicacy,andgivenemploymenttoagreatvarietyoftradesandmanufactures。ThelikepolicymayberemarkedinROME。Andindeed,throughoutallancienthistory,itisobservable,thatthesmallestrepublicsraisedandmaintainedgreaterarmies,thanstatesconsistingoftriplethenumberofinhabitants,areabletosupportatpresent。

Itiscomputed,that,inallEUROPEANnations,theproportionbetweensoldiersandpeopledoesnotexceedonetoahundred。Butweread,thatthecityofROMEalone,withitssmallterritory,raisedandmaintained,inearlytimes,tenlegionsagainsttheLATINS。ATHENS,thewholeofwhosedominionswasnotlargerthanYORKSHIRE,senttotheexpeditionagainstSICILYnearfortythousandmen。DIONYSIUStheelder,itissaid,maintainedastandingarmyofahundredthousandfootandtenthousandhorse,besidesalargefleetoffourhundredsail;thoughhisterritoriesextendednofartherthanthecityofSYRACUSE,aboutathirdoftheislandofSICILY,andsomesea—porttownsandgarrisonsonthecoastofITALYandILLYRICUM。Itistrue,theancientarmies,intimeofwar,subsistedmuchuponplunder:Butdidnottheenemyplunderintheirturn?whichwasamoreruinouswayoflevyingatax,thananyotherthatcouldbedevised。Inshort,noprobablereasoncanbeassignedforthegreatpowerofthemoreancientstatesabovethemodern,buttheirwantofcommerceandluxury。Fewartizansweremaintainedbythelabourofthefarmers,andthereforemoresoldiersmightliveuponit。

LIVYsays,thatROME,inhistime,wouldfinditdifficulttoraiseaslargeanarmyasthatwhich,inherearlydays,shesentoutagainsttheGAULSandLATINS。InsteadofthosesoldierswhofoughtforlibertyandempireinCAMILLUS’Stime,therewere,inAUGUSTUS’Sdays,musicians,painters,cooks,players,andtailors;andifthelandwasequallycultivatedatbothperiods,itcouldcertainlymaintainequalnumbersintheoneprofessionasintheother。Theyaddednothingtothemerenecessariesoflife,inthelatterperiodmorethanintheformer。

Itisnaturalonthisoccasiontoask,whethersovereignsmaynotreturntothemaximsofancientpolicy,andconsulttheirowninterestinthisrespect,morethanthehappinessoftheirsubjects?Ianswer,thatitappearstome,almostimpossible;andthatbecauseancientpolicywasviolent,andcontrarytothemorenaturalandusualcourseofthings。ItiswellknownwithwhatpeculiarlawsSPARTAwasgoverned,andwhataprodigythatrepublicisjustlyesteemedbyeveryone,whohasconsideredhumannatureasithasdisplayeditselfinothernations,andotherages。Werethetestimonyofhistorylesspositiveandcircumstantial,suchagovernmentwouldappearamerephilosophicalwhimorfiction,andimpossibleevertobereducedtopractice。AndthoughtheROMANandotherancientrepublicsweresupportedonprinciplessomewhatmorenatural,yetwasthereanextraordinaryconcurrenceofcircumstancestomakethemsubmittosuchgrievousburthens。Theywerefreestates;theyweresmallones;andtheagebeingmartial,alltheirneighbourswerecontinuallyinarms。Freedomnaturallybegetspublicspirit,especiallyinsmallstates;andthispublicspirit,thisamorpatriae,mustencrease,whenthepublicisalmostincontinualalarm,andmenareobliged,everymoment,toexposethemselvestothegreatestdangersforitsdefence。Acontinualsuccessionofwarsmakeseverycitizenasoldier:Hetakesthefieldinhisturn:Andduringhisserviceheischieflymaintainedbyhimself。

Thisserviceisindeedequivalenttoaheavytax;yetisitlessfeltbyapeopleaddictedtoarms,whofightforhonourandrevengemorethanpay,andareunacquaintedwithgainandindustryaswellaspleasure。Nottomentionthegreatequalityoffortunesamongtheinhabitantsoftheancientrepublics,whereeveryfield,belongingtoadifferentproprietor,wasabletomaintainafamily,andrenderedthenumbersofcitizensveryconsiderable,evenwithouttradeandmanufactures。

Butthoughthewantoftradeandmanufactures,amongafreeandverymartialpeople,maysometimeshavenoothereffectthantorenderthepublicmorepowerful,itiscertain,that,inthecommoncourseofhumanaffairs,itwillhaveaquitecontrarytendency。Sovereignsmusttakemankindastheyfindthem,andcannotpretendtointroduceanyviolentchangeintheirprinciplesandwaysofthinking。Alongcourseoftime,withavarietyofaccidentsandcircumstances,arerequisitetoproducethosegreatrevolutions,whichsomuchdiversifythefaceofhumanaffairs。Andthelessnaturalanysetofprinciplesare,whichsupportaparticularsociety,themoredifficultywillalegislatormeetwithinraisingandcultivatingthem。Itishisbestpolicytocomplywiththecommonbentofmankind,andgiveitalltheimprovementsofwhichitissusceptible。Now,accordingtothemostnaturalcourseofthings,industryandartsandtradeencreasethepowerofthesovereignaswellasthehappinessofthesubjects;andthatpolicyisviolent,whichaggrandizesthepublicbythepovertyofindividuals。Thiswilleasilyappearfromafewconsiderations,whichwillpresenttoustheconsequencesofslothandbarbarity。

Wheremanufacturesandmechanicartsarenotcultivated,thebulkofthepeoplemustapplythemselvestoagriculture;andiftheirskillandindustryencrease,theremustariseagreatsuperfluityfromtheirlabourbeyondwhatsufficestomaintainthem。Theyhavenotemptation,therefore,toencreasetheirskillandindustry;sincetheycannotexchangethatsuperfluityforanycommodities,whichmayserveeithertotheirpleasureorvanity。

Ahabitofindolencenaturallyprevails。Thegreaterpartofthelandliesuncultivated。Whatiscultivated,yieldsnotitsutmostforwantofskillandassiduityinthefarmers。Ifatanytimethepublicexigenciesrequire,thatgreatnumbersshouldbeemployedinthepublicservice,thelabourofthepeoplefurnishesnownosuperfluities,bywhichthesenumberscanbemaintained。Thelabourerscannotencreasetheirskillandindustryonasudden。Landsuncultivatedcannotbebroughtintotillageforsomeyears。Thearmies,meanwhile,musteithermakesuddenandviolentconquests,ordisbandforwantofsubsistence。