blewabitterrainintothefacesoftheRussians;theFrenchprofitedbythiscircumstancetobeataretreat,evacuatingthevalleyofUrsern,crossingtheReuss,andtakinguptheirpositionontheheightsoftheFurkaandGrimsel。OneportionoftheRussianarmy’sdesignhadbeenachieved,theyweremastersoftheSt。
Gothard。Itistruethatassoonastheymarchedfartheron,theFrenchwouldretakeitandcutofftheirretreat;butwhatdidthismattertoSouvarow?Didhenotalwaysmarchforward?
Hemarchedon,then,withoutworryingaboutthatwhichwasbehindhim,reachedAndermatt,clearedTroud’Ury,andfoundLecourbeguardingthedefileoftheDevil’sBridgewithfifteenhundredmen。
Therethestrugglebeganagain;forthreedaysfifteenhundredFrenchmenkeptthirtythousandRussiansatbay。Souvarowragedlikealiontrappedinasnare,forhecouldnotunderstandthischangeoffortune。Atlast,onthefourthday,heheardthatGeneralKorsakoff,whohadprecededhimandwhowastorejoinhimlater,hadbeenbeatenbyMolitor,andthatMassenahadrecapturedZurichandoccupiedthecantonofGlaris。SouvarownowgaveuptheattempttoproceedupthevalleyoftheReuss,andwrotetoKorsakoffandJallachieh,\"Ihastentoretrieveyourlosses;standfirmasramparts:youshallanswertomewithyourheadsforeverystepinretreatthatyoutake。\"Theaide-de-campwasalsochargedtocommunicatetotheRussianandAustriangeneralsaverbalplanofbattle。GeneralsLinskenandJallachiehweretoattacktheFrenchtroopsseparatelyandthentojointheforcesinthevalleyofGlaris,intowhichSouvarowhimselfwastodescendbytheKlon-Thal,thushemmingMolitorinbetweentwowallsofiron。
Souvarowwassosurethatthisplanwouldbesuccessful,thatwhenhearrivedonthebordersofthelakeofKlon-Thal,hesentabearerwithaflagoftruce,summoningMolitortosurrender,seeingthathewassurroundedoneveryside。
Molitorreplied,tothefield-marshalthathisproposedmeetingwithhisgeneralshadfailed,ashehadbeatenthemoneaftertheother,anddriventhembackintotheGrisons,andthatmoreover,inretaliation,asMassenawasadvancingbyMuotta,itwashe,Souvarow,whowasbetweentwofires,andthereforehecalleduponhimtolaydownhisarmsinstead。
Onhearingthisstrangereply,Souvarowthoughtthathemustbedreaming,butsoonrecoveringhimselfandrealisingthedangerofhispositioninthedefiles,hethrewhimselfonGeneralMolitor,whoreceivedhimatthepointofthebayonet,andthenclosingupthepasswithtwelvehundredmen,theFrenchsucceededinholdingfifteentoeighteenthousandRussiansincheckforeighthours。Atlengthnightcame,andMolitorevacuatedtheKlonThal,andretiredtowardstheLinth,todefendthebridgesofNoefelsandMollis。
Theoldfield-marshalrushedlikeatorrentoverGlarisandMiltodi;
therehelearntthatMolitorhadtoldhimthetruth,andthatJallachiehandLinskenhadbeenbeatenanddispersed,thatMassenawasadvancingonSchwitz,andthatGeneralRosenberg,whohadbeengiventhedefenceofthebridgeofMuotta,hadbeenforcedtoretreat,sothathefoundhimselfinthepositioninwhichhehadhopedtoplaceMolitor。
Notimewastobelostinretreating。SouvarowhurriedthroughthepassesofEngi,Schwauden,andElm。Hisflightwassohurriedthathewasobligedtoabandonhiswoundedandpartofhisartillery。
ImmediatelytheFrenchrushedinpursuitamongtheprecipicesandclouds。Onesawwholearmiespassingoverplaceswherechamois-
hunterstookofftheirshoesandwalkedbarefoot,holdingonbytheirhandstopreventthemselvesfromfalling。Threenationshadcomefromthreedifferentpartstoameeting-placeinthehomeoftheeagles,asiftoallowthosenearestGodtojudgethejusticeoftheircause。Thereweretimeswhenthefrozenmountainschangedintovolcanoes,whencascadesnowfilledwithbloodfellintothevalleys,andavalanchesofhumanbeingsrolleddownthedeepestprecipices。
Deathreapedsuchaharvesttherewherehumanlifehadneverbeenbefore,thatthevultures,becomingfastidiousthroughtheabundance,pickedoutonlytheeyesofthecorpsestocarrytotheiryoung——atleastsosaysthetraditionofthepeasantsofthesemountains。
SouvarowwasabletorallyhistroopsatlengthintheneighbourhoodofLindau。HerecalledKorsakoff,whostilloccupiedBregenz;butallhistroopstogetherdidnotnumbermorethanthirtythousandmen-
allthatremainedoftheeightythousandwhomPaulhadfurnishedashiscontingentinthecoalition。InfifteendaysMassenahaddefeatedthreeseparatearmies,eachnumericallystrongerthanhisown。Souvarow,furiousathavingbeendefeatedbythesesameRepublicanswhomhehadsworntoexterminate,blamedtheAustriansforhisdefeat,anddeclaredthatheawaitedordersfromhisemperor,towhomhehadmadeknownthetreacheryoftheallies,beforeattemptinganythingfurtherwiththecoalition。
Paul’sanswerwasthatheshouldimmediatelyreturntoRussiawithhissoldiers,arrivingatSt。Petersburgassoonaspossible,whereatriumphalentryawaitedthem。
ThesameukasedeclaredthatSouvarowshouldbequarteredintheimperialpalacefortherestofhislife,andlastlythatamonumentshouldberaisedtohiminoneofthepublicplacesofSt。
Petersburg。
FoedorwasthusabouttoseeVaninkaoncemore。Throughoutthecampaign,wheretherewasachanceofdanger,whetherintheplainsofItaly,inthedefilesofTesino,orontheglaciersofMountPragal,hewasthefirsttothrowhimselfintoit,andhisnamehadfrequentlybeenmentionedasworthyofdistinction。Souvarowwastoobravehimselftobeprodigalofhonourswheretheywerenotmerited。
Foedorwasreturning,ashehadpromised,worthyofhisnobleprotector’sfriendship,andwhoknows,perhapsworthyofVaninka’slove。Field-MarshalSouvarowhadmadeafriendofhim,andnonecouldknowtowhatthisfriendshipmightnotlead;forPaulhonouredSouvarowlikeoneoftheancientheroes。
ButnoonecouldrelyuponPaul,forhischaracterwasmadeupofextremeimpulses。Withouthavingdoneanythingtooffendhismaster,andwithoutknowingthecauseofhisdisgrace,Souvarow,onarrivingatRiga,receivedaprivateletterwhichinformedhim,intheemperor’sname,that,havingtoleratedaninfractionofthelawsofdisciplineamonghissoldiers,theemperordeprivedhimofallthehonourswithwhichhehadbeeninvested,andalsoforbadehimtoappearbeforehim。
Suchtidingsfelllikeathunderboltupontheoldwarrior,alreadyembitteredbyhisreverses:hewasheart-brokenthatsuchstorm-
cloudsshouldtarnishtheendofhisgloriousday。
Inconsequenceofthisorder,heassembledallhisofficersinthemarket-placeofRiga,andtookleaveofthemsorrowfully,likeafathertakingleaveofhisfamily。Havingembracedthegeneralsandcolonels,andhavingshakenhandswiththeothers,hesaidgood-byetothemoncemore,andleftthemfreetocontinuetheirmarchtotheirdestination。
Souvarowtookasledge,and,travellingnightandday,arrivedincognitointhecapital,whichhewastohaveenteredintriumph,andwasdriventoadistantsuburb,tothehouseofoneofhisnieces,wherehediedofabrokenheartfifteendaysafterwards。
Onhisownaccount,Foedortravelledalmostasrapidlyashisgeneral,andenteredSt。Petersburgwithouthavingsentanylettertoannouncehisarrival。Ashehadnoparentinthecapital,andashisentireexistencewasconcentratedinoneperson,hedrovedirecttothegeneral’shouse,whichwassituatedintheProspectofNiewski,atanangleoftheCatherineCanal。
Havingarrivedthere,hesprangoutofhiscarriage,enteredthecourtyard,andboundedupthesteps。Heopenedtheante-chamberdoor,andprecipitatedhimselfintothemidstoftheservantsandsubordinatehouseholdofficers。Theycriedoutwithsurpriseuponseeinghim:heaskedthemwherethegeneralwas;theyrepliedbypointingtothedoorofthediningroom;hewasinthere,breakfastingwithhisdaughter。
Then,throughastrangereaction,Foedorfelthiskneesfailinghim,andhewasobligedtoleanagainstawalltopreventhimselffromfalling。Atthismoment,whenhewasabouttoseeVaninkaagain,thissoulofhissoul,forwhomalonehehaddonesomuch,hedreadedlestheshouldnotfindherthesameaswhenhehadlefther。
Suddenlythedining-roomdooropened,andVaninkaappeared。Seeingtheyoungman,sheutteredacry,and,turningtothegeneral,said,\"Father,itisFoedor\";andtheexpressionofhervoiceleftnodoubtofthesentimentwhichinspiredit。
\"Foedor!\"criedthegeneral,springingforwardandholdingouthisarms。
FoedordidnotknowwhethertothrowhimselfatthefeetofVaninkaorintothearmsofherfather。Hefeltthathisfirstrecognitionoughttobedevotedtorespectandgratitude,andthrewhimselfintothegeneral’sarms。Hadheactedotherwise,itwouldhavebeenanavowalofhislove,andhehadnorighttoavowthislovetillheknewthatitwasreciprocated。
Foedorthenturned,andasatparting,sankonhiskneebeforeVaninka;butamomenthadsufficedforthehaughtygirltobanishthefeelingshehadshown。Theblushwhichhadsuffusedhercheekhaddisappeared,andshehadbecomeagaincoldandhaughtylikeanalabasterstatue-amasterpieceofpridebegunbynatureandfinishedbyeducation。Foedorkissedherhand;itwastremblingbutcoldhefelthisheartsink,andthoughthewasabouttodie。
\"Why,Vaninka,\"saidthegeneral——\"whyareyousocooltoafriendwhohascausedussomuchanxietyandyetsomuchpleasure?Come,Fordor,kissmydaughter。\"
Foedorroseentreatingly,butwaitedmotionless,thatanotherpermissionmightconfirmthatofthegeneral。
\"Didyounothearmyfather?\"saidVaninka,smiling,butneverthelesspossessingsufficientself-controltopreventtheemotionshewasfeelingfromappearinginhervoice。
FoedorstoopedtokissVaninka,andasheheldherhandsitseemedtohimthatshelightlypressedhisownwithanervous,involuntarymovement。Afeeblecryofjoynearlyescapedhim,when,suddenlylookingatVaninka,hewasastonishedatherpallor:herlipswereaswhiteasdeath。
ThegeneralmadeFoedorsitdownatthetable:Vaninkatookherplaceagain,andasbychanceshewasseatedwithherbacktothelight,thegeneralnoticednothing。
BreakfastpassedinrelatingandlisteningtoanaccountofthisstrangecampaignwhichbeganundertheburningsunofItalyandendedintheglaciersofSwitzerland。AstherearenojournalsinSt。
Petersburgwhichpublishanythingotherthanthatwhichispermittedbytheemperor,Souvarow’ssuccesseswerespreadabroad,buthisreverseswereignored。Foedordescribedtheformerwithmodestyandthelatterwithfrankness。
Onecanimagine,theimmenseinterestthegeneraltookinFoedor’sstory。Histwocaptain’sepauletsandthedecorationsonhisbreastprovedthattheyoungmanhadmodestlysuppressedhisownpartinthestoryhehadtold。Butthegeneral,toocourageoustofearthathemightshareinSouvarow’sdisgrace,hadalreadyvisitedthedyingfield-marshal,andhadheardfromhimanaccountofhisyoungprotege’sbravery。Therefore,whenFoedorhadfinishedhisstory,itwasthegeneral’sturntoenumerateallthefinethingsFoedorhaddoneinacampaignoflessthanayear。Havingfinishedthisenumeration,headdedthatheintendednextdaytoasktheemperor’spermissiontotaketheyoungcaptainforhisaide-de-camp。Foedorhearingthiswishedtothrowhimselfatthegeneral’sfeet,buthereceivedhimagaininhisarms,andtoshowFoedorhowcertainhewasthathewouldbesuccessfulinhisrequest,hefixedtheroomsthattheyoungmanwastooccupyinthehouseatonce。
ThenextdaythegeneralreturnedfromthepalaceofSt。Michelwiththepleasantnewsthathisrequesthadbeengranted。
Foedorwasoverwhelmedwithjoy:fromthistimehewastoformpartofthegeneral’sfamily。LivingunderthesameroofasVaninka,seeingherconstantly,meetingherfrequentlyintherooms,seeingherpasslikeanapparitionattheendofacorridor,findinghimselftwiceadayatthesametablewithher,allthiswasmorethanFoedorhadeverdaredhope,andhethoughtforatimethathehadattainedcompletehappiness。
Forherpart,Vaninka,althoughshewassoproud,atthebottomofherhearttookakeeninterestinFoedor。Hehadleftherwiththecertaintythathelovedher,andduringhisabsenceherwoman’spridehadbeengratifiedbythegloryhehadacquired,inthehopeofbridgingthedistancewhichseparatedthem。Sothat,whenshesawhimreturnwiththisdistancebetweenthemlessened,shefeltbythebeatingofherheartthatgratifiedpridewaschangingintoamoretendersentiment,andthatforherpartshelovedFoedorasmuchasitwaspossibleforhertoloveanyone。
Shehadneverthelessconcealedthesefeelingsunderanappearanceofhaughtyindifference,forVaninkawasmadeso:sheintendedtoletFoedorknowsomedaythatshelovedhim,butuntilthetimecamewhenitpleasedhertorevealit,shedidnotwishtheyoungmantodiscoverherlove。Thingswentoninthiswayforseveralmonths,andthecircumstanceswhichhadatfirstappearedtoFoedorastheheightofhappinesssoonbecameawfultorture。
Toloveandtofeelhishearteveronthepointofavowingitslove,tobefrommorningtillnightinthecompanyofthebelovedone,tomeetherhandatthetable,totouchherdressinanarrowcorridor,tofeelherleaningonhisarmwhentheyenteredasalonorleftaballroom,alwaystohaveceaselesslytocontroleveryword,look,ormovementwhichmightbetrayhisfeelings,nohumanpowercouldenduresuchastruggle。
VaninkasawthatFoedorcouldnotkeephissecretmuchlonger,anddeterminedtoanticipatetheavowalwhichshesaweverymomentonthepointofescapinghisheart。
Onedaywhentheywerealone,andshesawthehopelesseffortstheyoungmanwasmakingtohidehisfeelingsfromher,shewentstraightuptohim,and,lookingathimfixedly,said:
\"Youloveme!\"
\"Forgiveme,forgiveme,\"criedtheyoungman,claspinghishands。
\"Whyshouldyouaskmetoforgiveyou,Foedor?Isnotyourlovegenuine?\"
\"Yes,yes,genuinebuthopeless。\"
\"Whyhopeless?Doesnotmyfatherloveyouasason?\"saidVaninka。
\"Oh,whatdoyoumean?\"criedFoedor。\"Doyoumeanthatifyourfatherwillbestowyourhanduponme,thatyouwillthenconsent——?\"
\"Areyounotbothnobleinheartandbybirth,Foedor?Youarenotwealthy,itistrue,butthenIamrichenoughforboth。\"
\"ThenIamnotindifferenttoyou?\"
\"IatleastpreferyoutoanyoneelseIhavemet。\"
\"Vaninka!\"Theyounggirldrewherselfawayproudly。
\"Forgiveme!\"saidFoedor。\"WhatamIdoing?Youhavebuttoorder:
Ihavenowishapartfromyou。IdreadlestIshalloffendyou。
Tellmewhattodo,andIwillobey。\"
\"Thefirstthingyoumustdo,Foedor,istoaskmyfather’sconsent。\"
\"Soyouwillallowmetotakethisstep?\"
\"Yes,butononecondition。\"
\"Whatisit?Tellme。\"
\"Myfather,whateverhisanswer,mustneverknowthatIhaveconsentedtoyourmakingthisapplicationtohim;noonemustknowthatyouarefollowingmyinstructions;theworldmustremainignorantoftheconfessionIhavejustmadetoyou;and,lastly,youmustnotaskme,whateverhappens,tohelpyouinanyotherwaythanwithmygoodwishes。\"
\"Whateveryouplease。Iwilldoeverythingyouwishmetodo。DoyounotgrantmeathousandtimesmorethanIdaredhope,andifyourfatherrefusesme,doInotknowmyselfthatyouaresharingmygrief?\"criedFoedor。
\"Yes;butthatwillnothappen,Ihope,\"saidVaninka,holdingoutherhandtotheyoungofficer,whokisseditpassionately。
\"Nowbehopefulandtakecourage;\"andVaninkaretired,leavingtheyoungmanahundredtimesmoreagitatedandmovedthanshewasherself,womanthoughshewas。
ThesamedayFoedoraskedforaninterviewwiththegeneral。Thegeneralreceivedhisaide-de-campasusualwithagenialandsmilingcountenance,butwiththefirstwordsFoedorutteredhisfacedarkened。However,whenheheardtheyoungman’sdescriptionofthelove,sotrue,constant,andpassionate,thathefeltforVaninka,andwhenheheardthatthispassionhadbeenthemotivepowerofthosegloriousdeedshehadpraisedsooften,heheldouthishandtoFoedor,almostasmovedastheyoungsoldier。
Andthenthegeneraltoldhim,thatwhilehehadbeenaway,andignorantofhisloveforVaninka,inwhomhehadobservednotraceofitsbeingreciprocated,hehad,attheemperor’sdesire,promisedherhandtothesonofaprivycouncillor。Theonlystipulationthatthegeneralhadmadewas,thatheshouldnotbeseparatedfromhisdaughteruntilshehadattainedtheageofeighteen。Vaninkahadonlyfivemonthsmoretospendunderherfather’sroof。Nothingmorecouldbesaid:inRussiatheemperor’swishisanorder,andfromthemomentthatitisexpressed,nosubjectwouldopposeit,eveninthought。However,therefusalhadimprintedsuchdespairontheyoungman’sface,thatthegeneral,touchedbyhissilentandresignedsorrow,heldouthisarmstohim。Foedorflunghimselfintothemwithloudsobs。
Thenthegeneralquestionedhimabouthisdaughter,andFoedoranswered,ashehadpromised,thatVaninkawasignorantofeverything,andthattheproposalcamefromhimalone,withoutherknowledge。Thisassurancecalmedthegeneral:hehadfearedthathewasmakingtwopeoplewretched。
Atdinner-timeVaninkacamedownstairsandfoundherfatheralone。
Foedorhadnotenoughcouragetobepresentatthemealandtomeetheragain,justwhenhehadlostallhope:hehadtakenasleigh,anddrivenouttotheoutskirtsofthecity。
DuringthewholetimedinnerlastedVaninkaandthegeneralhardlyexchangedaword,butalthoughthissilencewassoexpressive,Vaninkacontrolledherfacewithherusualpower,andthegeneralaloneappearedsadanddejected。
Thatevening,justwhenVaninkawasgoingdownstairs,teawasbroughttoherroom,withthemessagethatthegeneralwasfatiguedandhadretired。Vaninkaaskedsomequestionsaboutthenatureofhisindisposition,andfindingthatitwasnotserious,shetoldtheservantwhohadbroughtherthemessagetoaskherfathertosendforherifhewantedanything。Thegeneralsenttosaythathethankedher,butheonlyrequiredquietandrest。Vaninkaannouncedthatshewouldretirealso,andtheservantwithdrew。
HardlyhadhelefttheroomwhenVaninkaorderedAnnouschka,herfoster-sister,whoactedashermaid,tobeonthewatchforFoedor’sreturn,andtoletherknowassoonashecamein。
Ateleveno’clockthegateofthemansionopened:Foedorgotoutofhissleigh,andimmediatelywentuptohisroom。Hethrewhimselfuponasofa,overwhelmedbyhisthoughts。Aboutmidnightheheardsomeonetappingatthedoor:muchastonished,hegotupandopenedit。ItwasAnnouschka,whocamewithamessagefromhermistress,thatVaninkawishedtoseehimimmediately。Althoughhewasastonishedatthismessage,whichhewasfarfromexpecting,Foedorobeyed。
HefoundVaninkaseated,dressedinawhiterobe,andasshewaspalerthanusualhestoppedatthedoor,foritseemedtohimthathewasgazingatamarblestatue。
\"Comein,\"saidVaninkacalmly。
Foedorapproached,drawnbyhervoicelikesteeltoamagnet。
Annouschkashutthedoorbehindhim。
\"Well,andwhatdidmyfathersay?\"saidVaninka。
Foedortoldherallthathadhappened。Theyounggirllistenedtohisstorywithanunmovedcountenance,butherlips,theonlypartofherfacewhichseemedtohaveanycolour,becameaswhiteasthedressing-gownshewaswearing。Foedor,onthecontrary,wasconsumedbyafever,andappearednearlyoutofhissenses。
\"Now,whatdoyouintendtodo?\"saidVaninkainthesamecoldtoneinwhichshehadaskedtheotherquestions。
\"YouaskmewhatIintendtodo,Vaninka?Whatdoyouwishmetodo?
WhatcanIdo,butfleefromSt。Petersburg,andseekdeathinthefirstcornerofRussiawherewarmaybreakout,inordernottorepaymypatron’skindnessbysomeinfamousbaseness?\"
\"Youareafool,\"saidVaninka,withamixedsmileoftriumphandcontempt;forfromthatmomentshefelthersuperiorityoverFoedor,andsawthatshewouldrulehimlikeaqueenfortherestofherlife。
\"Thenorderme——amInotyourslave?\"criedtheyoungsoldier。
\"Youmuststayhere,\"saidVaninka。
\"Stayhere?\"
\"Yes;onlywomenandchildrenwillthusconfessthemselvesbeatenatthefirstblow:aman,ifhebeworthyofthename,fights。\"
\"Fight!——againstwhom?——againstyourfather?Never!\"
\"Whosuggestedthatyoushouldcontendagainstmyfather?Itisagainsteventsthatyoumuststrive;forthegeneralityofmendonotgovernevents,butarecarriedawaybythem。Appeartomyfatherasthoughyouwerefightingagainstyourlove,andhewillthinkthatyouhavemasteredyourself。AsIamsupposedtobeignorantofyourproposal,Ishallnotbesuspected。Iwilldemandtwoyears’morefreedom,andIshallobtainthem。Whoknowswhatmayhappeninthecourseoftwoyears?Theemperormaydie,mybetrothedmaydie,myfather——mayGodprotecthim!——myfatherhimselfmaydie——!\"
\"Butiftheyforceyoutomarry?\"
\"Forceme!\"interruptedVaninka,andadeepflushrosetohercheekandimmediatelydisappearedagain。\"Andwhowillforcemetodoanything?Father?Helovesmetoowell。Theemperor?Hehasenoughworriesinhisownfamily,withoutintroducingthemintoanother’s。Besides,thereisalwaysalastresourcewheneveryotherexpedientfails:theNevaonlyflowsafewpacesfromhere,anditswatersaredeep。\"
Foedorutteredacry,forintheyounggirl’sknitbrowsandtightlycompressedlipstherewassomuchresolutionthatheunderstoodthattheymightbreakthischildbutthattheywouldnotbendher。ButFoedor’sheartwastoomuchinharmonywiththeplanVaninkahadproposed;hisobjectionsonceremoved,hedidnotseekfreshones。
Besides,hadhehadthecouragetodoso;Vaninka’spromisetomakeupinsecrettohimforthedissimulationshewasobligedtopractiseinpublicwouldhaveconqueredhislastscruples。
Vaninka,whosedeterminedcharacterhadbeenaccentuatedbyhereducation,hadanunboundedinfluenceoverallwhocameincontactwithher;eventhegeneral,withoutknowingwhy,obeyedher。Foedorsubmittedlikeachildtoeverythingshewished,andtheyounggirl’slovewasincreasedbythewishessheopposedandbyafeelingofgratifiedpride。
Itwassomedaysafterthisnocturnaldecisionthattheknoutinghadtakenplaceatwhichourreadershaveassisted。Itwasforsomeslightfault,andGregoryhadbeenthevictim;Vaninkahavingcomplainedtoherfatherabouthim。Foedor,whoasaide-de-camphadbeenobligedtopresideoverGregory’spunishment,hadpaidnomoreattentiontothethreatstheserfhadutteredonretiring。
Ivan,thecoachman,whoafterhavingbeenexecutionerhadbecomesurgeon,hadappliedcompressesofsaltandwatertohealupthescarredshouldersofhisvictim。Gregoryhadremainedthreedaysintheinfirmary,andduringthistimehehadturnedoverinhismindeverypossiblemeansofvengeance。Thenattheendofthreedays,beinghealed,hehadreturnedtohisduty,andsooneveryoneexcepthehadforgottenthepunishment。IfGregoryhadbeenarealRussian,hewouldsoonhaveforgottenitall;forthispunishmentistoofamiliartotheroughMuscoviteforhimtorememberitlongandwithrancour。Gregory,aswehavesaid,hadGreekbloodinhisveins;hedissembledandremembered。AlthoughGregorywasaserf,hisdutieshadlittlebylittlebroughthimintogreaterfamiliaritywiththegeneralthananyoftheotherservants。Besides,ineverycountryintheworldbarbershavegreatlicencewiththosetheyshave;thisisperhapsduetothefactthatamanisinstinctivelymoregracioustoanotherwhofortenminuteseverydayholdshislifeinhishands。
Gregoryrejoicedintheimmunityofhisprofession,anditnearlyalwayshappenedthatthebarber’sdailyoperationonthegeneral’schinpassedinconversation,ofwhichheborethechiefpart。
Onedaythegeneralhadtoattendareview:hesentforGregorybeforedaybreak,andasthebarberwaspassingtherazorasgentlyaspossibleoverhismaster’scheek,theconversationfell,ormorelikelywasled,onFoedor。Thebarberpraisedhimhighly,andthisnaturallycausedhismastertoaskhim,rememberingthecorrectiontheyoungaide-decamphadsuperintended,ifhecouldnotfindsomefaultinthismodelofperfectionthatmightcounterbalancesomanygoodqualities。GregoryrepliedthatwiththeexceptionofpridehethoughtFoedorirreproachable。
\"Pride?\"askedtheastonishedgeneral。\"ThatisafailingfromwhichIshouldhavethoughthimmostfree。\"
\"PerhapsIshouldhavesaidambition,\"repliedGregory。
\"Ambition!\"saidthegeneral。\"Itdoesnotseemtomethathehasgivenmuchproofofambitioninenteringmyservice;forafterhisachievementsinthelastcampaignhemighteasilyhaveaspiredtothehonourofaplaceintheemperor’shousehold。\"
\"Ohyes,heisambitious,\"saidGregory,smiling。\"Oneman’sambitionisforhighposition,another’sanillustriousalliance:theformerwilloweeverythingtohimself,thelatterwillmakeastepping-stoneofhiswife,thentheyraisetheireyeshigherthantheyshould。\"
\"Whatdoyoumeantosuggest?\"saidthegeneral,beginningtoseewhatGregorywasaimingat。
\"Imean,yourexcellency,\"repliedGregory,\"therearemanymenwho,owingtothekindnessshownthembyothers,forgettheirpositionandaspiretoamoreexaltedone;havingalreadybeenplacedsohigh,theirheadsareturned。\"
\"Gregory,\"criedthegeneral,\"believeme,youaregettingintoascrape;foryouaremakinganaccusation,andifItakeanynoticeofit,youwillhavetoproveyourwords。\"
\"BySt。Basilius,general,itisnoscrapewhenyouhavetruthonyourside;forIhavesaidnothingIamnotreadytoprove。\"
\"Then,\"saidthegeneral,\"youpersistindeclaringthatFoedorlovesmydaughter?\"
\"Ah!Ihavenotsaidthat:itisyourexcellency。IhavenotnamedtheladyVaninka,\"saidGregory,withtheduplicityofhisnation。
\"Butyoumeantit,didyounot?Come,contrarytoyourcustom,replyfrankly。\"
\"Itistrue,yourexcellency;itiswhatImeant。\"
\"And,accordingtoyou,mydaughterreciprocatesthepassion,nodoubt?\"
\"Ifearso,yourexcellency。\"
\"Andwhatmakesyouthinkthis,say?\"
\"First,Mr。FoedornevermissesachanceofspeakingtotheladyVaninka。\"
\"Heisinthesamehousewithher,wouldyouhavehimavoidher?\"
\"WhentheladyVaninkareturnslate,andwhenperchanceMr。Foedorhasnotaccompaniedyou,whateverthehourMr。Foedoristhere,ready,tohelpheroutofthecarriage。\"
\"Foedorattendsme,itishisduty,\"saidthegeneral,beginningtobelievethattheserf’ssuspicionswerefoundedonslightgrounds。
\"Hewaitsforme,\"he,continued,\"becausewhenIreturn,atanyhourofthedayornight,Imayhaveorderstogivehim。\"
\"NotadaypasseswithoutMr。FoedorgoingintomyladyVaninka’sroom,althoughsuchafavourisnotusuallygrantedtoayoungmaninahouselikethatofyourexcellency。\"
\"UsuallyitisIwhosendhimtoher,\"saidthegeneral。
\"Yes,inthedaytime,\"repliedGregory,\"butatnight?\"
\"Atnight!\"criedthegeneral,risingtohisfeet,andturningsopalethat,afteramoment,hewasforcedtoleanforsupportonatable。
\"Yes,atnight,yourexcellency,\"answeredGregoryquietly;\"andsince,asyousay,Ihavebeguntomixmyselfupinabadbusiness,I
mustgoonwithit;besides,evenifthereweretoresultfromitanotherpunishmentforme,evenmoreterriblethanthatIhavealreadyendured,Ishouldnotallowsogood,amastertobedeceivedanylonger。\"
\"Beverycarefulaboutwhatyouaregoingtosay,slave;forIknowthemenofyournation。Takecare,iftheaccusationyouaremakingbywayofrevengeisnotsupportedbyvisible,palpable,andpositiveproofs,youshallbepunishedasaninfamousslanderer。\"
\"TothatIagree,\"saidGregory。
\"DoyouaffirmthatyouhaveseenFoedorentermydaughter’schamberatnight?\"
\"IdonotsaythatIhaveseenhimenterit,yourexcellency。IsaythatIhaveseenhimcomeout。\"
\"Whenwasthat?\"
\"Aquarterofanhourago,whenIwasonmywaytoyourexcellency。\"
\"Youlie!\"saidthegeneral,raisinghisfist。
\"Thisisnotouragreement,yourexcellency,\"saidtheslave,drawingback。\"IamonlytobepunishedifIfailtogiveproofs。\"
\"Butwhatareyourproofs?\"
\"Ihavetoldyou。\"
\"Anddoyouexpectmetobelieveyourwordalone?\"
\"No;butIexpectyoutobelieveyourowneyes。\"
\"How?\"
\"ThefirsttimethatMr。FoedorisinmyladyVaninka’sroomaftermidnight,Ishallcometofindyourexcellency,andthenyoucanjudgeforyourselfifIlie;butuptothepresent,yourexcellency,alltheconditionsoftheserviceIwishtorenderyouaretomydisadvantage。\"
\"Inwhatway?\"
\"Well,ifIfailtogiveproofs,Iamtobetreatedasaninfamousslanderer;butifIgivethem,whatadvantageshallIgain?\"
\"Athousandroublesandyourfreedom。\"
\"Thatisabargain,then,yourexcellency,\"repliedGregoryquietly,replacingtherazorsonthegeneral’stoilet-table,\"andIhopethatbeforeaweekhaspassedyouwillbemorejusttomethanyouarenow。\"
Withthesewordstheslavelefttheroom,leavingthegeneralconvincedbyhisconfidencethatsomedreadfulmisfortunethreatenedhim。
>Fromthistimeonward,asmightbeexpected,thegeneralweighedeverywordandnoticedeverygesturewhichpassedbetweenVaninkaandFoedorinhispresence;buthesawnothingtoconfirmhissuspicionsonthepartoftheaide-de-camporofhisdaughter;onthecontrary,Vaninkaseemedcolderandmorereservedthanever。
Aweekpassedinthisway。Abouttwoo’clockinthemorningoftheninthday,someoneknockedatthegeneral’sdoor。ItwasGregory。
\"Ifyourexcellencywillgointoyourdaughter’sroom,\"saidGregory,\"youwillfindMr。Foedorthere。\"
Thegeneralturnedpale,dressedhimselfwithoututteringaword,andfollowedtheslavetothedoorofVaninka’sroom。Havingarrivedthere,withamotionofhishandhedismissedtheinformer,who,insteadofretiringinobediencetothismutecommand,hidhimselfinthecornerofthecorridor。
Whenthegeneralbelievedhimselftobealone,heknockedonce;butallwassilent。Thissilence,however,provednothing;forVaninkamightbeasleep。Heknockedasecondtime,andtheyounggirl,inaperfectlycalmvoice,asked,\"Whoisthere?\"
\"ItisI,\"saidthegeneral,inavoicetremblingwithemotion。
\"Annouschka!\"saidthegirltoherfoster-sister,whosleptintheadjoiningroom,\"openthedoortomyfather。Forgiveme,father,\"
shecontinued;\"butAnnouschkaisdressing,andwillbewithyouinamoment。\"
Thegeneralwaitedpatiently,forhecoulddiscovernotraceofemotioninhisdaughter’svoice,andhehopedthatGregoryhadbeenmistaken。
Inafewmomentsthedooropened,andthegeneralwentin,andcastalonglookaroundhim;therewasnooneinthisfirstapartment。
Vaninkawasinbed,palerperhapsthanusual,butquitecalm,withthelovingsmileonherlipswithwhichshealwayswelcomedherfather。
\"Towhatfortunatecircumstance,\"askedtheyounggirlinhersoftesttones,\"doIowethepleasureofseeingyouatsolateanhour?\"
\"Iwishedtospeaktoyouaboutaveryimportantmatter,\"saidthegeneral,\"andhoweverlateitwas,Ithoughtyouwouldforgivemefordisturbingyou。\"
\"Myfatherwillalwaysbewelcomeinhisdaughter’sroom,atwhateverhourofthedayornighthepresentshimselfthere。\"
Thegeneralcastanothersearchinglookround,andwasconvincedthatitwasimpossibleforamantobeconcealedinthefirstroom——butthesecondstillremained。
\"Iamlistening,\"saidVaninka,afteramomentofsilence。
\"Yes,butwearenotalone,\"repliedthegeneral,\"anditisimportantthatnootherearsshouldhearwhatIhavetosaytoyou。\"
\"Annauschka,asyouknow,ismyfoster-sister,\"saidVaninka。
\"Thatmakesnodifference,\"saidthegeneral,goingcandleinhandintothenextroom,whichwassomewhatsmallerthanhisdaughter’s。
\"Annouschka,\"saidhe,\"watchinthecorridorandseethatnooneoverhearsus。\"
Ashespokethesewords,thegeneralthrewthesamescrutinizingglanceallroundtheroom,butwiththeexceptionoftheyounggirltherewasnoonethere。
Annouschkaobeyed,andthegeneralfollowedherout,and,lookingeagerlyroundforthelasttime,re-enteredhisdaughter’sroom,andseatedhimselfonthefootofherbed。Annouschka,atasignfromhermistress,leftheralonewithherfather。ThegeneralheldouthishandtoVaninka,andshetookitwithouthesitation。
\"Mychild,\"saidthegeneral,\"Ihavetospeaktoyouaboutaveryimportantmatter。\"
\"Whatisit,father?\"saidVaninka。
\"Youwillsoonbeeighteen,\"continuedthegeneral,\"andthatistheageatwhichthedaughtersoftheRussiannobilityusuallymarry。\"
ThegeneralpausedforamomenttowatchtheeffectofthesewordsuponVaninka,butherhandrestedmotionlessinhis。\"Forthelastyearyourhandhasbeenengagedbyme,\"continuedthegeneral。
\"MayIknowtowhom?\"askedVaninkacoldly。
\"TothesonoftheCouncillor-in-Ordinary,\"repliedthegeneral。
\"Whatisyouropinionofhim?\"
\"Heisaworthyandnobleyoungman,Iamtold,butIcanhaveformednoopinionexceptfromhearsay。HashenotbeeningarrisonatMoscowforthelastthreemonths?\"
\"Yes,\"saidthegeneral,\"butinthreemonths’timeheshouldreturn。\"
Vaninkaremainedsilent。
\"Haveyounothingtosayinreply?\"askedthegeneral。
\"Nothing,father;butIhaveafavourtoaskofyou。\"
\"Whatisit?\"
\"IdonotwishtomarryuntilIamtwentyyearsold。\"
\"Whynot?\"
\"Ihavetakenavowtothateffect。\"
\"Butifcircumstancesdemandedthebreakingofthisvow,andmadethecelebrationofthismarriageimperativelynecessary?\"
\"Whatcircumstances?\"askedVaninka。
\"Foedorlovesyou,\"saidthegeneral,lookingsteadilyatVaninka。
\"Iknowthat,\"saidVaninka,withaslittleemotionasifthequestiondidnotconcernher。
\"Youknowthat!\"criedthegeneral。
\"Yes;hehastoldmeso。\"
\"When?\"
\"Yesterday。\"
\"Andyoureplied——?\"
\"Thathemustleavehereatonce。\"
\"Andheconsented?\"
\"Yes,father。\"
\"Whendoeshego?\"
\"Hehasgone。\"
\"Howcanthatbe?\"saidthegeneral:\"heonlyleftmeatteno’clock。\"
\"Andheleftmeatmidnight,\"saidVaninka。
\"Ah!\"saidthegeneral,drawingadeepbreathofrelief,\"youareanoblegirl,Vaninka,andIgrantyouwhatyouask-twoyearsmore。
Butrememberitistheemperorwhohasdecideduponthismarriage。\"
\"MyfatherwilldomethejusticetobelievethatIamtoosubmissiveadaughtertobearebellioussubject。\"
\"Excellent,Vaninka,excellent,\"saidthegeneral。\"So,then,poorFoedorhastoldyouall?\"
\"Yes,\"saidVaninka。
\"Youknewthatheaddressedhimselftomefirst?\"
\"Iknewit。\"
\"Thenitwasfromhimthatyouheardthatyourhandwasengaged?\"
\"Itwasfromhim。\"
\"Andheconsentedtoleaveyou?Heisagoodandnobleyoungman,whoshallalwaysbeundermyprotectionwhereverhegoes。Oh,ifmywordhadnotbeengiven,Ilovehimsomuchthat,supposingyoudidnotdislikehim,Ishouldhavegivenhimyourhand。\"
\"Andyoucannotrecallyourpromise?\"askedVaninka。
\"Impossible,\"saidthegeneral。
\"Well,then,Isubmittomyfather’swill,\"saidVaninka。
\"Thatisspokenlikemydaughter,\"saidthegeneral,embracingher。
\"Farewell,Vaninka;Idonotaskifyoulovehim。Youhavebothdoneyourduty,andIhavenothingmoretoexact。\"
Withthesewords,heroseandlefttheroom。Annouschkawasinthecorridor;thegeneralsignedtoherthatshemightgoinagain,andwentonhisway。AtthedoorofhisroomhefoundGregorywaitingforhim。
\"Well,yourexcellency?\"heasked。
\"Well,\"saidthegeneral,\"youarebothrightandwrong。Foedorlovesmydaughter,butmydaughterdoesnotlovehim。Hewentintomydaughter’sroomateleveno’clock,butatmidnightheleftherforever。Nomatter,cometometomorrow,andyoushallhaveyourthousandroublesandyourliberty。\"
Gregorywentoff,dumbwithastonishment。
Meanwhile,Annouschkahadre-enteredhermistress’sroom,asshehadbeenordered,andclosedthedoorcarefullybehindher。
Vaninkaimmediatelysprangoutofbedandwenttothedoor,listeningtotheretreatingfootstepsofthegeneral。Whentheyhadceasedtobeheard,sherushedintoAnnouschka’sroom,andbothbegantopullasideabundleoflinen,throwndown,asifbyaccident,intotheembrasureofawindow。Underthelinenwasalargechestwithaspringlock。Annouschkapressedabutton,Vaninkaraisedthelid。
Thetwowomenutteredaloudcry:thechestwasnowacoffin;theyoungofficer,stifledforwantofair,laydeadwithin。
Foralongtimethetwowomenhopeditwasonlyaswoon。Annouschkasprinkledhisfacewithwater;Vaninkaputsaltstohisnose。Allwasinvain。Duringthelongconversationwhichthegeneralhadhadwithhisdaughter,andwhichhadlastedmorethanhalfanhour,Foedor,unabletogetoutofthechest,asthelidwasclosedbyaspring,haddiedforwantofair。Thepositionofthetwogirlsshutupwithacorpsewasfrightful。AnnouschkasawSiberiacloseathand;Vaninka,todoherjustice,thoughtofnothingbutFoedor。
Bothwereindespair。However,asthedespairofthemaidwasmoreselfishthanthatofhermistress,itwasAnnouschkawhofirstthoughtofaplanofescapingfromthesituationinwhichtheywereplaced。
\"Mylady,\"shecriedsuddenly,\"wearesaved。\"Vaninkaraisedherheadandlookedatherattendantwithhereyesbathedintears。
\"Saved?\"saidshe,\"saved?Weare,perhaps,butFoedor!\"
\"Listennow,\"saidAnnouschka:\"yourpositionisterrible,Igrantthat,andyourgriefisgreat;butyourgriefcouldbegreaterandyourpositionmoreterriblestill。Ifthegeneralknewthis。\"
\"Whatdifferencewoulditmaketome?\"saidVaninka。\"Ishallweepforhimbeforethewholeworld。\"
\"Yes,butyouwillbedishonouredbeforethewholeworld!To-morrowyourslaves,andthedayafterallSt。Petersburg,willknowthatamandiedofsuffocationwhileconcealedinyourchamber。Reflect,mylady:yourhonouristhehonourofyourfather,thehonourofyourfamily。\"
\"Youareright,\"saidVaninka,shakingherhead,asiftodispersethegloomythoughtsthatburdenedherbrain,——\"youareright,butwhatmustwedo?\"
\"DoesmyladyknowmybrotherIvan?\"
\"Yes。\"
\"Wemusttellhimall。\"
\"Ofwhatareyouthinking?\"criedVaninka。\"Toconfideinaman?A
man,doIsay?Aserf!aslave!\"
\"Thelowerthepositionoftheserfandslave,thesaferwilloursecretbe,sincehewillhaveeverythingtogainbykeepingfaithwithus。\"
\"Yourbrotherisadrunkard,\"saidVaninka,withmingledfearanddisgust。
\"Thatistrue,\"saidAnnouschka;\"butwherewillyoufindaslavewhoisnot?Mybrothergetsdrunklessthanmost,andisthereforemoretobetrustedthantheothers。Besides,inthepositioninwhichwearewemustrisksomething。\"
\"Youareright,\"saidVaninka,recoveringherusualresolution,whichalwaysgrewinthepresenceofdanger。\"Goandseekyourbrother。\"
\"Wecandonothingthismorning,\"saidAnnouschka,drawingbackthewindowcurtains。\"Look,thedawnisbreaking。\"
\"Butwhatcanwedowiththebodyofthisunhappyman?\"criedVaninka。
\"Itmustremainhiddenwhereitisallday,andthisevening,whileyouareattheCourtentertainment,mybrothershallremoveit。\"
\"True,\"murmuredVaninkainastrangetone,\"ImustgotoCourtthisevening;tostayawaywouldarousesuspicion。Oh,myGod!myGod!\"
\"Helpme,mylady,\"saidAnnouschka;\"Iamnotstrongenoughalone。\"
Vaninkaturneddeadlypale,but,spurredonbythedanger,shewentresolutelyuptothebodyofherlover;then,liftingitbytheshoulders,whilehermaidraiseditbythelegs,shelaiditoncemoreinthechest。ThenAnnouschkashutdownthelid,lockedthechest,andputthekeyintoherbreast。Thenboththrewbackthelinenwhichhadhiddenitfromtheeyesofthegeneral。Daydawned,asmightbeexpected,eresleepvisitedtheeyesofVaninka。
Shewentdown,however,atthebreakfasthour;forshedidnotwishtoarousetheslightestsuspicioninherfather’smind。Onlyitmighthavebeenthoughtfromherpallorthatshehadrisenfromthegrave,butthegeneralattributedthistothenocturnaldisturbanceofwhichhehadbeenthecause。
LuckhadservedVaninkawonderfullyinpromptinghertosaythatFoedorhadalreadygone;fornotonlydidthegeneralfeelnosurprisewhenhedidnotappear,buthisveryabsencewasaproofofhisdaughter’sinnocence。Thegeneralgaveapretextforhisaide-
de-camp’sabsencebysayingthathehadsenthimonamission。AsforVaninka,sheremainedoutofherroomtillitwastimetodress。
Aweekbefore,shehadbeenattheCourtentertainmentwithFoedor。
Vaninkamighthaveexcusedherselffromaccompanyingherfatherbyfeigningsomeslightindisposition,buttwoconsiderationsmadeherfeartoactthus:thefirstwasthefearofmakingthegeneralanxious,andperhapsofmakinghimremainathomehimself,whichwouldmaketheremovalofthecorpsemoredifficult;thesecondwasthefearofmeetingIvanandhavingtoblushbeforeaslave。Shepreferred,therefore,tomakeasuperhumanefforttocontrolherself;
and,goingupagainintoherroom,accompaniedbyherfaithfulAnnouschka,shebegantodresswithasmuchcareasifherheartwerefullofjoy。Whenthiscruelbusinesswasfinished,sheorderedAnnouschkatoshutthedoor;forshewishedtoseeFoedoroncemore,andtobidalastfarewelltohimwhohadbeenherlover。Annouschkaobeyed;andVaninka,withflowersinherhairandherbreastcoveredwithjewels,glidedlikeaphantomintoherservant’sroom。
Annouschkaagainopenedthechest,andVaninka,withoutsheddingatear,withoutbreathingasigh,withtheprofoundanddeath-likecalmofdespair,leantdowntowardsFoedorandtookoffaplainringwhichtheyoungmanhadonhisfinger,placeditonherown,betweentwomagnificentrings,thenkissinghimonthebrow,shesaid,\"Goodbye,mybetrothed。\"
Atthismomentsheheardstepsapproaching。Itwasagroomofthechamberscomingfromthegeneraltoaskifshewereready。
Annouschkaletthelidofthechestfall,andVaninkagoingherselftoopenthedoor,followedthemessenger,whowalkedbeforeher,lightingtheway。
Suchwashertrustinherfoster-sisterthatshelefthertoaccomplishthedarkandterribletaskwithwhichshehadburdenedherself。
Aminutelater,Annouschkasawthecarriagecontainingthegeneralandhisdaughterleavebythemaingateofthehotel。
Shelethalfanhourgoby,andthenwentdowntolookforIvan。ShefoundhimdrinkingwithGregory,withwhomthegeneralhadkepthisword,andwhohadreceivedthesamedayonethousandroublesandhisliberty。Fortunately,therevellerswereonlybeginningtheirrejoicings,andIvaninconsequencewassoberenoughforhissistertoentrusthersecrettohimwithouthesitation。
IvanfollowedAnnouschkaintothechamberofhermistress。TheresheremindedhimofallthatVaninka,haughtybutgenerous,hadallowedhissistertodoforhim。The,fewglassesofbrandyIvanhadalreadyswallowedhadpredisposedhimtogratitude(thedrunkennessoftheRussianisessentiallytender)。IvanprotestedhisdevotionsowarmlythatAnnouschkahesitatednolonger,and,raisingthelidofthechest,showedhimthecorpseofFoedor。AtthisterriblesightIvanremainedaninstantmotionless,buthesoonbegantocalculatehowmuchmoneyandhowmanybenefitsthepossessionofsuchasecretwouldbringhim。Hesworebythemostsolemnoathsnevertobetrayhismistress,andoffered,asAnnouschkahadhoped,todisposeofthebodyoftheunfortunateaide-decamp。
Thethingwaseasilydone。InsteadofreturningtodrinkwithGregoryandhiscomrades,Ivanwenttoprepareasledge,filleditwithstraw,andhidatthebottomanironcrowbar。Hebroughtthistotheoutsidegate,andassuringhimselfhewasnotbeingspiedupon,heraisedthebodyofthedeadmaninhisarms,hiditunderthestraw,andsatdownaboveit。Hehadthegateofthehotelopened,followedNiewskiStreetasfarastheZunamenieChurch,passedthroughtheshopsintheRejestwenskoidistrict,drovethesledgeoutontothefrozenNeva,andhaltedinthemiddleoftheriver,infrontofthedesertedchurchofSte。Madeleine。There,protectedbythesolitudeanddarkness,hiddenbehindtheblackmassofhissledge,hebegantobreaktheice,whichwasfifteeninchesthick,withhispick。Whenhehadmadealargeenoughhole,hesearchedthebodyofFoedor,tookallthemoneyhehadabouthim,andslippedthebodyheadforemostthroughtheopeninghehadmade。Hethenmadehiswaybacktothehotel,whiletheimprisonedcurrentoftheNevaboreawaythecorpsetowardstheGulfofFinland。Anhourafter,anewcrustoficehadformed,andnotevenatraceoftheopeningmadebyIvanremained。